Feedback to CVs thread- Story distortion#2 - Page 12

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

97.9k

Users

99

Likes

4.2k

Frequent Posters

guenhwyvar thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shani88

@All - I agree with you. The two most irritating characterizations of Starbharat have been Karna and Draupadi.

Good thing StarYudi doesn't care for StarDrau's tantrums, and coolly tells her what needs to be done next, rather than trying to "pacify" her...seriously, what was Bhim trying to do?? It was looking so funny...😆
And as per the CVs, the Pandavas are "completely flawless" human beings, who can do absolutely NO wrong. I mean, even on the one occasion when the Pandavas could've been shown to be "flawed" (Drau's vibhaajan), even there, they got the clean chit.

StarArjuna introduces StarDrau as "daan" to StarKunti, and later explains that by "daan", he actually meant "kanyadaan". So, as per CVs, the StarPandavas did NOT "objectify" StarDrau in any way. And even when StarYudi was trying to tell StarKunti that they had actually brought a girl, StarKunti issues her order for the "vibhaajan". Therefore, ALL the blame for Drau's vibhaajan lies with StarKunti...oh well, at least StarKunti possessed ONE flaw, much better than her sickly sweet saintly characterization.

And then the fictional rajyasabhaa apmaan. StarPandavas (being "completely flawless" as per CVs) prove themselves to be best aaryas in the world...Hello CVs, dice game and vastraharan???

Or maybe, even during the dice game and vastraharan, the Pandavas could STILL get the clean chit. How? CVs could show Harry Potter-MB crossover during the dice game/vastraharan - StarShakuni putting StarYudi under the Imperious curse so that Yudi completely loses track of his senses and stakes everything.

As it is, this week, StarShakuni will prove that he is an ancestor of Severus Snape by pouring a "green liquid" in the havan, and invoking Takshak to turn into a cow thief, so as to obstruct the Indraprastha nagar poojan...

wait so does this mean that all the snakes are dead? Or did they leave the moment Takshak disappeared?

lol that was such a funny scene. Bhim tries to calm Draupadi down and it fails ... and then Yuddhi has enough of that nonsense and was like "Shut up and listen to the truth before giving us another crappy bhasaan ... god you have a talking problem like your annoying frickin' dad!!"
Justitia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shyam09

wait so does this mean that all the snakes are dead? Or did they leave the moment Takshak disappeared?

lol that was such a funny scene. Bhim tries to calm Draupadi down and it fails ... and then Yuddhi has enough of that nonsense and was like "Shut up and listen to the truth before giving us another crappy bhasaan ... god you have a talking problem like your annoying frickin' dad!!"


Part in red - As per spoiler (and precap), Indra will try to konk off Arjun before Krishna (finally) intervenes, and convinces Indra to help Arjun instead. Takshak decides to leave in a huff. Indraprastha gets established. HP gets a whiff that Indraprastha has plans to declare sovereignty as per Kunti's instructions which she relays via Karna who has now become buddies with the Pandavas (Is conducting a nagar poojan the same as "declaring sovereignty"??). And, Shakuni proves his Hogwarts potioneering skills by using a "green liquid" to invoke Takshak who returns as a cow thief to create problems and stop the nagar poojan from taking place...baaki sab kuch CVs explain karenge.

Part in blue - I so wish he had said that!!

Edited by shani88 - 11 years ago
ParomaSurya thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
-@shyam (And then the fictional rajyasabhaa apmaan. StarPandavas (being "completely flawless" as per CVs) prove themselves to be best aaryas in the world...Hello CVs, dice game and vastraharan??? )




Maybe they are trying to show that even though they are flawless all their lives they go through so much crap!!! The ONE time they slip up, people just couldn't let it go...where duryodhan did one adharm after another ... And not only was he never punished but no one even protested him.
Edited by ParomaSurya - 11 years ago
guenhwyvar thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: ParomaSurya

-@shyam (And then the fictional rajyasabhaa apmaan. StarPandavas (being "completely flawless" as per CVs) prove themselves to be best aaryas in the world...Hello CVs, dice game and vastraharan??? )




Maybe they are trying to show that even though they are flawless all their lives they go through so much crap!!! The ONE time they slip up, people just couldn't let it go...where duryodhan did one adharm after another ... And not only was he never punished but no one even protested him.

actually, that sounds pretty logical ... and now that I think about every event where Dury does adharm towards Pandavas ... nothing happens...
Case in point: Duryodhana insulting Pandu and Kunti during the Rangbhoomi. Mr. Dhriti didn't seem to give a crap about younger dead bro Pandu back then, whereas nowadays he is keeping Kunti hostage. 😆
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: .Vrish.

Actually, after reading the perspectives thread about the other version, I am coming around to this serial. I think they're taking bits & pieces from everywhere - from Indonesian versions, they took Vrushali's name from Mrityunjaya, they'll take something from Yagnaseni, something else from Palace of Illusions and so on. So we'll get a blended Mahabharata.

Yeah, it's a legit question of whether such a khichri is preferable to Vyasa, but Vyasa too has a lot of internal contradictions which, if examined closely, throw doubts on it. And if one looks @ differences b/w Vyasa's different works such as Mahabharata vs Shrimad Bhagvatam, contradictions are even more glaring. Such as what did Kunti do after the Pandavas won the war?


🥳I know where they took the Arjuna-Karna bromance from.🥳

It is Indo MB too, the day before Karna joins the war, they have a secret emotional meeting.

Hugs were given too.
SonaSA thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: .Vrish.

Actually, after reading the perspectives thread about the other version, I am coming around to this serial. I think they're taking bits & pieces from everywhere - from Indonesian versions, they took Vrushali's name from Mrityunjaya, they'll take something from Yagnaseni, something else from Palace of Illusions and so on. So we'll get a blended Mahabharata.

Yeah, it's a legit question of whether such a khichri is preferable to Vyasa, but Vyasa too has a lot of internal contradictions which, if examined closely, throw doubts on it. And if one looks @ differences b/w Vyasa's different works such as Mahabharata vs Shrimad Bhagvatam, contradictions are even more glaring. Such as what did Kunti do after the Pandavas won the war?


THIS.

The first post I have seen on this forum that is accepting of other POVs

Edited by SonaSA - 11 years ago
Justitia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: ParomaSurya


Maybe they are trying to show that even though they are flawless all their lives they go through so much crap!!! The ONE time they slip up, people just couldn't let it go...where duryodhan did one adharm after another ... And not only was he never punished but no one even protested him.


But looking at the way CVs are going, I doubt that the Pandavas will be shown to have "slipped up" even during the dice game. As it is, Shakuni has already told Duri that once the Pandavas establish a kingdom at Khandavaprasth, they will "chheen" it away from them...
Justitia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Medha.S

took the Arjuna-Karna bromance from.🥳


It is Indo MB too, the day before Karna joins the war, they have a secret emotional meeting.

Hugs were given too.


Isn't that COMPLETELY contrasting to what Vyas' MB states?
In other words, in the Indo MB, were Karna and the Pandavas buddies, and Karna had no role to play in Drau's humiliation???

Then in the Indo MB, whose side did Karna fight on in Kurukshetra??? And who killed him?? Did Karna have any role to play in Abhimanyu's death?


Vr15h thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shyam09

actually, that sounds pretty logical ... and now that I think about every event where Dury does adharm towards Pandavas ... nothing happens...

Case in point: Duryodhana insulting Pandu and Kunti during the Rangbhoomi. Mr. Dhriti didn't seem to give a crap about younger dead bro Pandu back then, whereas nowadays he is keeping Kunti hostage. 😆



Not just that - when he got an idea of what Duryodhan was plotting, he begged him to spare Kunti, asking what would Pandu think of him?

But as you point out, he didn't care about Duryodhan insulting Pandu during the rangbhoomi, or the plot to kill Bhima. Why would Pandu be okay w/ his sons being killed if his wife was spared?

Never mind that this serial's Pandu was totally blind to Dhritarashtra's hatred of him.
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shani88


Isn't that COMPLETELY contrasting to what Vyas' MB states?
In other words, in the Indo MB, were Karna and the Pandavas buddies, and Karna had no role to play in Drau's humiliation???

Then in the Indo MB, whose side did Karna fight on in Kurukshetra??? And who killed him?? Did Karna have any role to play in Abhimanyu's death?



Actually, everything is the same. Karna hated Pandavas and vice-versa. Actually, his hate is stated more explicitly where after Duryodhan gets them supposedly killed in Varnawrath, Karna gives away lot of gold and stuff to the poor.

The Karna and Arjuna meeting secret meeting scene is between Bhishma dying and Karna taking his place as the Commander in Chief.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".