Is KPji the only one to blame? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

65

Views

3.9k

Users

14

Likes

83

Frequent Posters

jayanti_dj thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao



True Deepa...right down to the spot boy and the food served on the sets...just because we know of his identity or have access to him, we cannot justify the language used at times...

I have personally fought with him on numerous occasions...have not agreed with him on many things,,,and yet, we cannot lecture him on creativity or ethics!


true ...
felt very bad that day when ppl questioned his professionalism !
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao



Tanu...I do not have your knowledge when it comes to the way the television industry works,,,

But tell me, the show is more than a year old...and this is a business and not a charity...so if they felt the head did not deserve the crown, what prevented the channel from taking it off...

The veto power always rests with the channel...you know that better then me...so, why were these things okayed in the first place,,,why was a flawed vision accepted...


And far be it from me to say feedback is not welcome...that is the purpose of his page...but I think temperate language and courtesy are essential at all times..we know who he is...he does not know who we are...hiding behind fake or real virtual identities, how is it fair to censure him on ethics...



It must b a major failure of interpretation on both sides... KP jis vision of women ..friendship .. and the holy scriptures (which he loves to quote) is not what the channel mite b expecting.. ! As a channel.. i believe Sony has been extremely kind n lenient to the show...! N maybe now it recognises that there r flaws that need to b plugged.. but since haseena ji herself had wished to share th script of dk with kp ji...so the channel mite not hv an alternative to do away with him totally..!

To this date any neutral person who hears that ktlk is written by the writer of tezab/rang de basanti...is left speechless..more out of shock.. than awe/admiration!
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: jayanti_dj


true ...
felt very bad that day when ppl questioned his professionalism !


😲 Et tu? Deepa ji... kya baat hai.. 😆 did u take a dip in the gomati river too? 😆
Sujatha.rao thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Armu4eva


It must b a major failure of interpretation on both sides... KP jis vision of women ..friendship .. and the holy scriptures (which he loves to quote) is not what the channel mite b expecting.. ! As a channel.. i believe Sony has been extremely kind n lenient to the show...! N maybe now it recognises that there r flaws that need to b plugged.. but since haseena ji herself had wished to share th script of dk with kp ji...so the channel mite not hv an alternative to do away with him totally..!

To this date any neutral person who hears that ktlk is written by the writer of tezab/rang de basanti...is left speechless..more out of shock.. than awe/admiration!


The show got past DK a long time ago...so I don't think that holds water anymore...

RDB is a film...and only the story was written by KPji...let us not forget that there was a creative genius by name Aamir Khan involved there... I do not credit RDB entirely to KPji..so I am sorry...but I am not shocked,,,

Anyway...I do not hold responsible singularly for the flaws in the show...while I do not absolve him of blame either...whatever, it does not excuse the disdain with which he is spoken of here...however, that is my pov...

btw, do these people know that he also wrote Beta...they would be even more shocked...
Edited by Sujatha.rao - 13 years ago
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao


The show got past DK a long time ago...so I don't think that holds water anymore...

RDB is a film...and the only the story was written by KPji...let us not forget that there was a creative genius by name Aamir Khan involved there... I do not credit RDB entirely to KPji..so I am sorry...but I am not shocked,,,

Anyway...I do not hold responsible singularly for the flaws in the show...while I do not absolve him of blame either...whatever, it does not excuse the disdain with which he is spoken of here...however, that is my pov...


It does hold water.. legally .. or contractually else haseena jis name wont hv been in th credits..

rdb mite hv 100 reasons to its success.. but writing.. direction.. acting all make it special.. ! the dialogues were hard hitting..n so was the writing.. in ktlk i can hardly claim any such earth shattering moments..! [PS : i said neutral.. u n i r not neutral ..we r fans of th show/actor/writer etc]

Yh one musnt get personal .. .but in my view he has a major part to play in making it difficult for the viewers to connect with the show..or tracks... so yh.. he does deserve a large part of the blame if not the whole thing...
jayanti_dj thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: Armu4eva


😲 Et tu? Deepa ji... kya baat hai.. 😆 did u take a dip in the gomati river too? 😆


😆 nahi re .. its just that i dont think any one can question him abt his work ethics !
besides i think he was forced to say what he did ..coz of the 24/7 nagging abt the baby on his wall !
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao

btw, do these people know that he also wrote Beta...they would be even more shocked...


and beta is a good film...amongst its regressive setting.. Madhuri.. as a potent female lead.. had an author backed role..so there.. no shocks for me.. 😊
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: jayanti_dj


😆 nahi re .. its just that i dont think any one can question him abt his work ethics !
besides i think he was forced to say what he did ..coz of the 24/7 nagging abt the baby on his wall !


@bold.. - good point 😊
jayanti_dj thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

[

To this date any neutral person who hears that ktlk is written by the writer of tezab/rang de basanti...is left speechless..more out of shock.. than awe/admiration!


the other day ,while surfin channels ,I saw the india gate candle light vigil scene of RDB .. and I was thinkin the person who wrote this scene ..and the sequence which led to the justice in jessica lal case ..and the person who writes KTLK ,are they actually same?
jayanti_dj thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#30


😆 nahi re .. its just that i dont think any one can question him abt his work ethics !
besides i think he was forced to say what he did ..coz of the 24/7 nagging abt the baby on his wall !


@bold.. - good point 😊

boy ,seriously , I saw it for like 2 days and it drove me nuts ,can totally imagine the poor man's state ! I was like how can anyone nag so much !

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".