Is KPji the only one to blame?

Page

Next Last

Sujatha.rao

@Sujatha.rao

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

Thank you Alka...your post on why Khushi alone is blamed inspired me to write this...

I do not know KPji personally..he is not my grandfather, father, uncle, brother, cousin or anything else before people start wondering...so, I have nothing to gain by writing this...

I have been a personal recipient of his anger many times...so no, there is no personal motive here...

Who is KPJi at the end of a day...I just see him as a much older man doing a thankless job most of the time...

Why do we all blame KPji for everything that goes wrong with the show...yesterday, a post was made on his wall questioning his professional ethics...I felt really hurt on his behalf...yes, the actor or actress enacts a character on screen...most of us are overtaken by their charisma and become their fans and are willing to back their every move...and yet, we are simply not willing to be a little more charitable and understanding when it comes to the writer...

i would say Mallika, Khushi and KPji are the most hated people among those associated with the show...two of them are fictional and any amount of bashing is not going to affect them...but the third is human like all of us and yet we do not spare him ...

is this show really being run by KPji? The truth is - far from it. Every track is approved by the channel, every single episode passes through a channel edit before it is telecast. Reason why we find some scenes shown during SBS/SBB missing during the telecast.

The PH - if I am right, then the PH employs the writer...and Rajan Shahi actively involves himself in the running of his shows...he is a technician himself after all...

the writers - till sometime ago, KPji was credited with the story as also screenplay and dialogues...now, he is only in charge of the screenplay and dialogues...although he does have a degree of involvement in shaping the story, it is not his brainchild...the tracks are conceived by this new set of writers...

The actors - we do not even need to discuss this...we know what an actor did to the show already. So suffice to say, the actors heavily influence the tracks and the final shape the show takes.

under the circumstances, is it really fair to blame this man for everything that is wrong with the show...

We blame him when he defends himself and his team...we blame him when he does not...why...because we know he exists...because he has been generous enough to interact with us and share information on the show with us...

Isn't this a case of shoot the messenger...?

Why are we so ready to pour our abuse on KPji's head, unmindful of the fact that he probably has more years in experience than most of us have in age!

Quote

Frequent Posters

mahwishsolanki

@mahwishsolanki

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

i think 1st thing is coz he is the only one who interact wid us n secondly he is the 1st hero of the ship so watever he writes comes to the actor...i feel somtimes show didnot go the path it shud hav gone mallikas conspiracy went un noticed which shud hav com up ok not when SK had surgery but 2nd time it cud hav...rohans letter went un noticed...Ashni process of understandin didnot go accordingly their age shud hav been well handled..then i think the separation track was not at all well handled...i also feel that the understandin between the lead pair is nil the communication gap is huge between them which has not been catered till now...n now khushi track where nidhi is potrayed wrong n khushi being dis respectful to elders...so lot cud hav been done but not done...n yes the 1st hero of the ship the writer who is kamlesh ji has to b given all the blame coz when there is a problem in the team the captain has to take the initiative n take all the blame n lead from the front so thats y the blames comes on him rather than any1 else...this is how i feel n purely my POV ppl can differ to it

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Debaparna

@debaparna77

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

Agar aap bura na mane to ek baat kahein? hum to us wall me unko 24/7 buddhi dene wale janta ko responsible mante hain 😆 😆

Quote

rayafan17

@rayafan17

Stunner

Posted: 13 years ago

Bulls eye Sujathaji.
Great insight on the subject - no We cannot blame him for everything. Its just that this was to be a hatke show different genre and its like so close to reality that we are attaching more importance to it and forget that at the end of the day it is fiction.

Quote

Sujatha.rao

@Sujatha.rao

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: debaparna77
Agar aap bura na mane to ek baat kahein? hum to us wall me unko 24/7 buddhi dene wale janta ko responsible mante hain 😆 😆

.main kyun bura manoongi..waise aap seedha bhi keh sakte te...tab bhi main bura nahi maanti... all of us have a right to a pov...😆

Quote

Sujatha.rao

@Sujatha.rao

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: mahwishsolanki
i think 1st thing is coz he is the only one who interact wid us n secondly he is the 1st hero of the ship so watever he writes comes to the actor...i feel somtimes show didnot go the path it shud hav gone mallikas conspiracy went un noticed which shud hav com up ok not when SK had surgery but 2nd time it cud hav...rohans letter went un noticed...Ashni process of understandin didnot go accordingly their age shud hav been well handled..then i think the separation track was not at all well handled...i also feel that the understandin between the lead pair is nil the communication gap is huge between them which has not been catered till now...n now khushi track where nidhi is potrayed wrong n khushi being dis respectful to elders...so lot cud hav been done but not done...n yes the 1st hero of the ship the writer who is kamlesh ji has to b given all the blame coz when there is a problem in the team the captain has to take the initiative n take all the blame n lead from the front so thats y the blames comes on him rather than any1 else...this is how i feel n purely my POV ppl can differ to it

Mahwish,..your first answer is right...he is the only one available to blame...and a writer is never the captain of the ship...a director is..he or she takes ultimate responsibility for how a product shapes up...however in TV , even that is not true...since directors keep changing with every episode...th channel is the ultimate decision maker when it comes to any TV show!

Quote

Sujatha.rao

@Sujatha.rao

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: deepali1772
Bulls eye Sujathaji.
Great insight on the subject - no We cannot blame him for everything. Its just that this was to be a hatke show different genre and its like so close to reality that we are attaching more importance to it and forget that at the end of the day it is fiction.

Deepali..we are right in our expectations...my only point is he alone is not responsible for fulfilling or destroying them...

Quote

Debaparna

@debaparna77

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao

.main kyun bura manoongi..waise aap seedha bhi keh sakte te...tab bhi main bura nahi maanti... all of us have a right to a pov...😆

hai raam , seedhe keya bolein..aap toh sab jaante hi ho ji 🤣

Edited by debaparna77 - 13 years ago

Quote

mahwishsolanki

@mahwishsolanki

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao

Mahwish,..your first answer is right...he is the only one available to blame...and a writer is never the captain of the ship...a director is..he or she takes ultimate responsibility for how a product shapes up...however in TV , even that is not true...since directors keep changing with every episode...th channel is the ultimate decision maker when it comes to any TV show!

sujatha ji u r rite but i hav jus quoted Kpji line where he once said Writer is the 1st Hero...so if he is believes that way then he is the one to blame...otherwise i feel he is not the only one to blame the whole team has to be blamed y only him..somtimes we r un happy wid the story somtimes wid actors somtimes wid director..somtimes we blame rselves for being more demading so every1 is too blamed

Edited by mahwishsolanki - 13 years ago

Quote

Sujatha.rao

@Sujatha.rao

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: debaparna77

hai raam , seedhe keya bolein..aap toh sab jaante hi ho ji 🤣

Sirf main hi kyun, Deba...hum..donon ek doosre ko bohot acchi tarah se samajte hain..isiliye main sab kuch seedha hi bol deti hoon ...waise actually zaroori bhi nahi...kyunki aap bhi bina bole hi samaj jaate hain 😆

Edited by Sujatha.rao - 13 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 ... 7

Is KPji the only one to blame?

Related Topics

Explore Topics