*Season 2, Week 7* Analysis Thread - Page 26

Created

Last reply

Replies

284

Views

135.4k

Users

49

Likes

3.3k

Frequent Posters

gmgi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Unlike Dev's confession where he got instant gratification here after the introduction he was taken aback when he was asked to prove himself a good father. It is good because that is a challenge he will try to win at all cost. Sona was feeling so proud that her daughter was honest about her feelings. If Sona had been at least half as honest as her daughter during their marriage Dev would have tried to overcome the challenges and he would not have been forced to prove himself to his daughter. And she called him a bad husband. Pot calling the kettle black 😆

Bijoy and Dev had so many similarities where their care, concern and respect for Sona was concerned. If Sona hadn't realised it yet then Soha would.
Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Today I realized why KRPKAB is the best. 😃 😃.I know I wrote my thoughts about Dev's calling of Sonakshi as 'feminist, but somehow it did not completely gel. Then I became aware that this is a serial which targets the common notions, norms and definitions of society.
I would like to add a disclaimer that I am not against Sonakshi and not intended to hurt anyone. But really wanted to express my thoughts.

In season 1, it was said both by Sonakshi herself and Dev and Elena that Sonakshi spent more times with books. Even during her holidays when her friends were playing she focused on books. I think Sonakshi learned the definitions of words, but never really understood the meaning of them.

A Definition is a statement of the exact meaning of a word, especially in a dictionary and Meaning is what is meant by a word, text, concept, or action. A Definition is a statement of the exact meaning of a word, especially in a dictionary and Meaning is what is meant by a word, text, concept, or action. In English two words may sound similar, but when one looks closely, there is huge difference in their meanings. The best example is the words "Price" and "Value". On the face of it, both seem to have similar meanings. But something that has low price may not have similar value to a person. For the person who received that item, it might be invaluable. Similarly, an item of high price may not mean anything to a person in terms of value. The meaning of "Price" and Value" is based on the person and his thoughts.


Most of Sonakshi's smartness is bookish and she was the topper as Indian(our) education system centers around definitions rather than meaning of what the kids learn. This was also reinforced by Bijoy as that is how he is too(for most part). Here he got lucky to have Asha as his life partner who guided him and helped him overcome his inefficiency to a large extent.

Sonakshi even before registering that she loved Dev, she used to dream of love and prince charming based on what she read in books. For her prince charming was someone who comes to the rescue of the damsel in distress. A suitor who fulfills the dreams of his beloved; also : a man of often specious charm toward women. He is handsome and romantic and makes all girls go swoon. Someone who is an ideal male lover who is both handsome and of admirable character. In other words he is someone who is "Perfect and faultless".

But there is no such thing as a "perfect person". In season 1, Sonakshi saw how Dev saved her when she had the accident,went through great lengths to save her, got a sugarless cake in 4 hours when it would usually take almost a day otherwise, got her to accept the phone by following her even after she refused and started equating him to the princes she had read about and created an image of him.

Even her love for him was bookish and based on the the definition of love. I feel even now, she has not understood the real meaning of love. She felt an intense feeling of deep affection towards him. But for Dev it was the meaning of love. For him Love meant -- what you want is never important. But what the other person needs and wants is always paramount.

Sonakshi always wanted an ideal everything which matched the definitions provided in books. From her perspective Ishwari's ideal bahu was Natasha. During that track, she had seen that Ishwari had no problems with her. She had also seen Ishwari say good things about her. Sonakshi had also heard from Dev how Ishwari thought Natasha suited him(during the gardsn scene in Sonakshi's house). She never really comprehended the reality of Ishwari's acceptance of Natasha.

So when Dev told her that he loved her, she thought he was being magnanimous. That he was loving her even though she did not match him in like in status. She started to consciously make effort to overcome this gap between them by being generous and understanding.

When Ishwari came with proposal and the wedding happened, she thought she had got her fairy tale after all and it would be "happily ever after" for her. But immediately following the wedding she found it was not so. She was disappointed, but she decided to write her own love story as she thought it should be.

Even now she is heavily clouded by her idea of perfection that she has not really grasped where it is leading her and Soha. In recent episodes she has referred to herself has perfect, both as a woman and mother, Soha as the perfect daughter and Bijoy as the perfect father.

I feel that as much as Soha is questioning Dev and will question Ishwari, she will end up questioning Sonakshi and Bijoy too. Soha is going to doubt how right this perfection actually is and is going to debate that with Sonakshi and maybe even with Bijoy.

I know it is very long, but wanted to pen down my thoughts... Sorry for the long rant...😃
Edited by Shaavi - 8 years ago
Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: gmgi

Unlike Dev's confession where he got instant gratification here after the introduction he was taken aback when he was asked to prove himself a good father. It is good because that is a challenge he will try to win at all cost. Sona was feeling so proud that her daughter was honest about her feelings. If Sona had been at least half as honest as her daughter during their marriage Dev would have tried to overcome the challenges and he would not have been forced to prove himself to his daughter. And she called him a bad husband. Pot calling the kettle black 😆

Bijoy and Dev had so many similarities where their care, concern and respect for Sona was concerned. If Sona hadn't realised it yet then Soha would.


Nice post Geena. @ Bold. I totally agree with you. 😃 😛
Shaavi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
sorry double post. 😳
Edited by Shaavi - 8 years ago
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
Beautiful posts Shaavi. You are too good in analysing Dev and every other character. Loved your take on Dev's usage of feminist.
LiveLife321 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Yesterday's episode left me with many unanswered questions, need to look for the answers in the upcoming episodes. Sona's I am perfect, my daughter is perfect, my dad is perfect, my family is perfect etc etc is seriously irritating but at the same time making me think about what exactly makers are trying to present through this constant blabbering. Are they deliberately trying to paint Bose family with white and Dixit family with black or is there more story behind it, I mean through this are they trying to convey there is nothing called absolute perfect? Is really soha strong and honest as sona claims because we are seeing her getting torn between her feelings and her family happiness? Why I am seeing too many shades of ishwari in sona now a days, when she blabber about perfection and soha being strong?
I am looking forward for future episodes to find my answers.
Edited by LiveLife321 - 8 years ago
timbarucha83 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: LiveLife321

Yesterday's episode left me with many unanswered questions, need to look for the answers in the upcoming episodes. Sona's I am perfect, my daughter is perfect, my dad is perfect, my family is perfect etc etc is seriously irritating but at the same time making me think about what exactly makers are trying to present through this constant blabbering. Are they deliberately trying to paint Bose family with white and Dixit family with black or is there more story behind it, I mean through this are they trying to convey there is nothing called absolute perfect? Is really soha strong and honest as sona claims because we are seeing her getting torn between her feelings and her family happiness? Why I am seeing too many shades of ishwari in sona now a days, when she blabber about perfection and soha being strong?

I am looking forward for future episodes to find my answers.


I always feel that in every mother there is a Ishwari and in every father there is a Bijoy but the percentage matters. Sona is insure about soha as she is her sun but over the period of time if she have a guts to face her insecurities and see how they are affecting soha and try to come out it she will kill the ishu which is inside her.At this point sona is insecure but at the same time she is practical. lets see what happen. I think comming summer camp with golu and soha will help them to understand the situation and each other as mother and father.And abut to felling perfect when the truth of prenup and vicki will come out then I will not get surprise soha can ask some innocent questions to sona and bijoy abut their relation to dev. as she ask why dev has not try to contact sona. I fell they both are going to learn a lot from golu and soha in near feature.
Calvin341 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
In season 2 why am I getting the vibes of the regular TV show story where hero is misogynist and heroine is a misandrist and heroine will teach hero a lesson and then slowly hero falls in love and in the end he becomes feminist..I first of all hate such stories and second neither is dev misogynist nor sona a misandrist in Season 1..Dev truely admires Sona's independent nature and always believed in equality..his dialogue before marriage to Bijoy Bose saying "if I were working under Sonakshi we would not be having any problem" makes me think if the writers have forgotten or changed.. like LiveLife321 said looks like are they making Boses white and Dixits black..too confused..would be great if someone here tell me if what I am thinking is right..
And yes this perfect tag seems to be too much used and coming from a person who used to say "koi perfect nahin hota..feelings perfect hote hain" again makes me think what are the writers up to..
Edited by Calvin341 - 8 years ago
malikakas thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: Samanalyse


Yes, I was extremely disappointed in the writing there. If you don't know what a word means, don't use it. But then it's a reality check about how many people, even those who write pretty feminist content, are unaware of the true meaning and import of this term. 😒


Honestly the quote didn't even fit for what he was saying so its clear the writers don't know what feminism means. When Dev said that the earlier Sonakshi was independent it showed that he clearly respected that in women. He doesn't have an issue with a woman being self actualized. Dev by definition is actually a fairly feminist hero. So for him to use it in a negative sense is a bit grating. But then I'd say a lot of people now days don't actually understand what it means.

Growing up for me feminism was always a positive word. It was quite a shock to me to realize that in the last few years it has all these negative connotations that so many women/men actually shy away from labelling themselves feminist. It started becoming associated with an expectation for women/men to act a certain way within a feminist ideal. It also makes many men insecure in regards to their own role in society. If you shouldn't *need* a man then you won't *need* a father either. And I think that's where Dev is coming from. As much as I dislike the term being used negatively, I feel like Dev is right to feel some insecurity because that is what Sona is doing. She is behaving in a way that makes a lot of people weary about "feminism". The idea that you have to be so perfect that you can do it all on your own. Sona's basically negated Dev's possible contribution to Soha's life. She's perfect and her daughter is perfect so they have no need for Dev.

Somewhere along the way Sona forgot that the origins of that type of movement was with women who didn't have much of a choice about how involved a father was. They had to do it on their own. So yes women had to learn that they were completely capable of doing it on their own if needed. But this was never the case here. In this story there was always a father perfectly willing and able to contribute. To have let him "help" wasn't or shouldn't be considered a sign of weakness. Nor was Sona going to the Dixit house a "favor" to Dev. That type of feminism is negative. If we talk about true feminism then a father's and mother's role should be given equal weight.
gmgi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
In season 2 everyone is having Dual or even multiple personalities. It is like the conflicting heart vs mind is personified. It is intriguing to watch. Sona, Soha n Dev are extremes while others are milder versions. The only exception is Golu.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".