Originally posted by: Aazeen02
Dear Suja di,
The night we got to read your OS, there was some commotion in my head... I wondered how are they going to talk, they will talk, that is a must... but how? what sequences can be used? How will Dev meet Soha? What will his reaction be? Will he get angry at Sonakshi? Or is he going to be shattered seeing what he lost while he thought it is fine to move on? Lots of things in my mind and mostly-How it may be presented to us...?😕Your OS came to me like the answers to those questions, mostly like a fresh respite... Thankfully...👏And your review seems to be longer than my update Aazeen... not that I am complaining. A big big hug to you for this. 🤗Now coming step by step into your story:I don't understand, should I be blaming this guy for all the lost years, because he could not stand up in the moment of need, or I should be sympathetically standing by his side like always because this guy is suffering again and long from years, with little to huge faults of his, and sometimes no fault of his...See... at the end of the day, this is how I see it. He is an adult. A successful business entrepreneur. Yet he scribbled his signature on a paper without thoroughly reading it. Whatever the paper was. Business or pre-nup, doesn't matter. He is supposed to read. Just like he is supposed to take a stand at some point in life when the crisis is staring at his face. He did neither of those things. He is definitely at fault. Should we sympathise? In some instances, yes. But not always. For example, he gave the pre-nup papers to Vicky and told him to tear them up. Who the hell does that? Why didn't he tear them up himself? That was the single most dumbest thing this guy did for which he is now paying the price.I am not saying that Dev wasn't at fault, my sole reason for the sympathies is the backing family that Sonakshi got, and Dev never had... A support, a reason to live is a way easier means to survive... Sonakshi had her family, plus her daughter... Who did Dev have? Golu? Is that it for being able to survive the hugest losses of your life?Did he value them when he had them in his life Aazeen?? Did he really?? If he did, wouldn't he have taken a stand for his love?? At least when she was being thrown out of his house?? This loss would force him to think. And rearrange his priorities. Act like an adult that he is supposed to be.Him showing a facade of a rude, mannerless, and a jerk guy is a but obvious for me, and thus, the opening of your OS was a more reality to imagine than to say that man was sprawled insolently on a chair in front of the policeman... The arrogance is a must in his demeanor, and he is justifying it...Really glad you caught that. 🤗Him turning towards the hotel as a ball of fire, well, he wasn't actually interfering into her privacy, and the words Obhodro and Mumma's boy had triggered the same pain in him... The point where Sonakshi broke the thread of their strained love with her bare hands and had moved out... The wounds are still fresh... A confrontation was a must...But whoa! What did he see or rather whom did he meet inside?The moment he came to know it must be him, who is the father of that beautiful little girl; in the back of my mind, there came a visual of ice cold water splashing on a red hot furnace... "Beti wo hawa hai, jo mere gusse ko hawa kar deti hai..." ie. Daughter is the breeze that vanishes my anger into thin air... Same was the case with Dev... Who came like a ball of fire walked out as a statue of ice... Cold and frigid...Yes. He needed to cool down at least a little bit before his confrontation with Sonakshi because otherwise he wouldn't listen to her or even give her a chance to speak.THEN COMES THE CONFRONTATION NO.1: Dev and Sonakshi's first conversation!Honestly, I had thought a lot about their first confrontation, but trust me when I say, that I could not conjure up even 10% of the intensity what you have given to their conversation...What dialogues, what setting and what effects...Awww.. thank you ji. thank you thank youI had so wanted Dev to get really angry with Sonakshi for hiding the truth about their daughter... Because as much as I thought again and again, for me nothing justifies the fact that Soha wasn't only her own daughter, she was Dev's as well... They separated for their individual self-respect "MY" was their issue... But Soha wasn't a property/commodity to be possessed by just a mother or a father... She should have been loved by her parents...Comes the justification from Sonakshi's side as well: You didn't want to have any responsibility of any child in case of divorce as you stated in the prenup... FAIR ENOUGH!But, was that guy anywhere at fault? Did he even know about such a clause? He hadn't even heard all this from his lawyer back then... Okay, it was all Ishwari's fault... But, should that guy be punished so lethally for believing on people, to suffer the loss of his own child's childhood? I don't think so, nature, fate or whatever cannot be so repeatedly cruel to a guy, who had no fault to the limit of seeing all this...He wanted everyone to be happy. He thought his silence would give that. But he saw time and again that his silence was being interpreted as incompetence. Still he didn't change. This is the price he had to pay. Change is the only constant thing in life Aazeen. You refuse to change, you pay the price. Now experience has taught him that.Experience - the most brutal teachers of all. But you learn! By God, you learn!! - William Nicholson.And here, it calls for a further part in this story, to justify the partiality of fate done to this poor guy, who lost everything in providing for everyone's happiness, you can't do this to us!😭Sabr. 😆NOW COMES CONFRONTATION NO.:2-- Dev and Ishwari face to face!Honestly speaking, Ishwari has lost the entire charm for me, she has become as good as a background Junior Artist that nobody notices... Now even if Dev breaks the entire relationship with her, or puts the entire blame for his failed marriage to her, or leaves the house forever, or anything that pleases the sore eyes; I don't give a damn, or care two hoots about Ishwari's character... A woman who repents none in the right time; is long forgotten... Seven years and no introspection-- Forget it lady, not your forte... Please shut yourself in that damn room forever... You can never change... A hopeless character.😆 I will leave it to Divya to answer this gripe of yours. Or maybe it doesn't need an answer. She is what she is. There ain't anything we can do about it. Other than writing OS that show her redemption somehow, someway.AND ON THE CLOSING NOTE: Can we Talk?Frankly, this should have ideally been done on the separation night only... Both of you wouldn't have missed the blissful period both of these went through in solitude and gloominess...Now it sounds more like the daughter is the reason for the talk... Shouldn't have it been the love for each other, the sparks that are still smoldering under the ashes of your separation?Don't these two love each other anymore? Is it only a compromise that is laid on the foundation of giving a better life to that kid and nothing more?No Aazeen. They don't love each other anymore. Not in my OS. Trust without love is not love. And there is no trust here at this point. Contrary to fiction, in reality, people do fall out of love. Especially if the separation is a bitter one. They struggle to move on. To leave their scarred past behind. In the end they do succeed.Is it only a compromise?? Now, if I have to answer that, I would have to turn this into an FF. For now, for this OS, Dev has only one priority. His daughter. Nothing else.My questions need an answer di, can we have a continution to this to see why he wants to talk?Can I be proved wrong, pretty please?please? please? please?I hope I didn't make you yawn at this ajeeb o gareeb review of mine... If I did, Gareeb ki beti ko maaf kar deejiye Jeeji...
No. You didn't make me yawn. Not even once. In fact, you made me think. So a huge thank you for that. ❤️PS: Right since the breakup and separation happened, I am not able to justify any one of the two leads, Dev and Sonakshi... If Sonakshi had to bear all the brunt and had to keep on sacrificing and adjusting, Dev was not partying either... I cannot understand why sometimes he is shown in a light of being a total loafer, drunkard, and a loose charactered bas***d. Just because a person has a false facade, doesn't mean that person was wrong all the way wrong... I have been equally blaming and equally defending both of them, NO MATTER WHAT... (This was my thoughts from the show)
First, I don't see Sonakshi as someone who has sacrificed. She lost a relationship. Happens. Not the end of the world. She got another beautiful one. Motherhood. She rebuilt her life and is now standing tall. As Dev's equal. Her "aap" before the leap is now "tum" did you notice??Second, I don't see Dev as a loafer or characterless bas***d. He is an adult. A divorcee (At least I hope these two are officially divorced.) And he is human. I don't expect him to be celibate for seven years, especially if he is determined to prove to himself and the world that he is moving on. He is done with living for others. Now living for himself the way he wants to. If Sona had gone and done the same, I wouldn't have blamed her either. Nor would have called her characterless.At the end of the day, they both did what they thought they had to do. What they wanted to do. I don't pity either of them for the choices they have made.