Vineet's elimination is justified.. - Page 4

Originally posted by: abhilasha2179

vineet deserved to be out because of his antics and age? 😕 now i wonder whether people consider singing at all when they vote

you are right
the show is not about the age it is about singing ........ so please think about it and tell me if he sings bad ..... dont make an excuse of his age

Originally posted by: shohratali

How irrelevant! He doesn't deserved to be out because of his age! Sorry but that is just a very lame justification. You are simply saying he deserve to be out because of his young age? Please! He has proven that he can sing MUCH better than many of the contestants. Since Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2005 he has proven how good a singer he is, and it's just plain unfair that people are putting his age on the matter. Many people show there talent at an early age, which is not BAD! He was one of the few that actually deserved to stand in the position of the top three. And you said it yourself, he is young, which can justify his actions and "antics" as you call it, with Rahul. They are young lads trying to have fun, and the umbrella scene wasn't that alarming. They where just showing sense of humor, and if you call THAT corrupting the minds of young children then that is just plain stupid. Children these days watch worse things than that, and EVERYONE knew they weren't kissing. If you are so alarmed about that then don't let them watch shows like these at all, after all they show skimpily dressed girls dancing all the time.
PS: Would you care to explain HOW Vineet's voice is average compared to his peers...lets just say Toshi? (I'm
Muslim and I won't show racial partiality by saying he is singing awesome because he is not).

Please let me know what improvement do you see in Vinit from C2005 days..??

I never said he improved, but he is much better than almost all or many of the contestants. Also, his confidence has clearly grown, something you need in a field like this one.

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

In C2005 he did not have any guts to disclose about his mysterous girl friend while in this show he openly accepted about his boy friend.... I saw this as improvement...

😆😆, jokes apart no one is perfect, and yes Vinit really needs to focus on riyaz.

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

😆😆, jokes apart no one is perfect, and yes Vinit really needs to focus on riyaz.

come on we all know that toshi and harshit need riyaz more than vineet and they are still in the competition 🤢

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

In C2005 he did not have any guts to disclose about his mysterous girl friend while in this show he openly accepted about his boy friend.... I saw this as improvement...

🤣

come on we all know that toshi and harshit need riyaz more than vineet and they are still in the competition 🤢

kya karoge .......😆Toshi and Harshit ko junta zyada pasand karti hai, but I still say Vinit needs riyaz badly and probably more than other...😆

I agree Vinits stupid gay act pissed me off . There was certainly no need to show all this stupidness especially since he was already a great singer . But after last weeks episode his act was pissing me off and I couldnt care less about his performance anymroe.

Originally posted by: MizzSoni

i dont know if his elimination was justified
since it is a singing show n he sang better than others last week
i think wut led to his elmination was
1. his drama with rahul etc. ppl watch the show for singing right , everyone here (vineet fans) are saying that he is a good singer then why did he do this
yes he is maybe just that type of guy but he should not do those things on the show since ppl of all ages watch this show n im sure most of them consider these antics quite pathetic n not needed for
2. farahs favortism, im sorry but no one likes wen a judge openly supports sumone that much it makes ppl think that why is she doing that n turns them of from his singing
my 2 cents 😊

I agree with you and the himesh imitation in every darn episode was getting boring oh and also hitting on Mandira was just ridiculous.

his elimination was not justified at all...n pls...its high time dat ppl start sayin dat he cant sing cox of his age? excuse me...he reached to the top two in saregamapa wen he was 17...dat itself proves dat his age has got nothin to do wit his sing...n abt dat stupid 'antics' sum ppl r referin to...i dont find anythin wrong in dat..i find it rather humorous n cute..Rahul n Vineet r d life of d show for me...Debu is maried so he cant obviously flirt wit Mandira or anyone else....Abhi is too..as for Toshi, Harshit, Ishmeet...they have been quiet always...so dat leaves to d only tw youngsters of d show who also happen to be best frnds...they were just havin fun but unknowingly givin dere haters a reason to point fingers at dem...n abt Vineet's himesh imitations...im sure if Himesh minded he wudnt do dat n it was Fara who made him do dat mostly...n I for one enjoy it...rather dat makin fun of his mentor...i wud say he was rather promotin him n provin dat his mentor has his own unique style...he might be not d best out of d rest but he definitely did not deserve to be eliminated at dis point....i think he atleast deserved to be in the top 3...