Vineet's elimination is justified.. - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

78

Views

8.4k

Users

43

Frequent Posters

silverspike thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: Gauri_3

I am a Harshit fan and I absolutely adore him but I will acknowledge the fact that I have seen him using his dadi for emotional effects on voters both during asvoi and during jjws.

See, the way these shows' format is, the contestants have to appeal to voters. Thye can't just bank on their singing. If singing alone was sufficient, Aishwarya and Amey would not have left so early in the show, Ishmeet would have left after vinit and vinit should have left after toshi and debo would have been in finale while rahul should have been out in debo's place. But it doesn't work that way.

This is why getting the voters on your side is equally important as good singing. Some do this by immature acts, feigned crushes, inconsistent emotional stories about getting a key board that becomes guitar in one show and god knows what in the other show. Different contestants aim to please different strata of viewers.

Vinit's tactics worked with some young ones but Debo's heartfelt appeal got across to many more viewers than Vinit. Don't know how that makes Debo a cheater.

As far as Debo and Vinit's age difference, as I see you sarcastically call him "uncle" pretty much all the time, well, Vinit should have known this before participating in non-chhotey ustaad singing contestant. Definitely not Debo's fault😊

Debo won fair and square in each and every contest so far. He won over vinit because he is a better singer and also a better human being. The attitude does come across on the screen😊 Now who among them makes more money via playback or selling albums is an altogether different thing and only time will tell who will be more successful. Going by the voting patterns so far, Debo has won far too many hearts than Vinit😃

Vineet's only fault is that he dosent belong to East...if he would have been from East he should have won each and every contest hands down...Debojit uncle can never become a playback singer becasue he dosent have voice of of his own....we have better voice than him in the industry...he copies Kisore Kumar where we have better voice like Kumar sanu, Shaan, Abhijeet, Babul supriyo etc so he or even Harshit will never become good playback singer because they dont have original voice..Even Toshi has better edge on them because he has voice of his own....

I am very happy because Vineet ended up on high note by becoming superstar of the week twice not like debojit chacha ...debojit's performance was pathetic 2 say the least....he killed such a fantastic composition & beautiful rendition....he lowered the scale....his sur slipped in many places....his wordings were hay wire....& he actually dedicated that horrendous performance 2 Himesh & Vineet....that performance wud hav been the worst but was 2nd worst thanks 2 Toshi !...So he rightly deserves to go or can say thrown out...

Edited by silverspike - 17 years ago
200467 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: ~*indian doll*~

well thats all ur oppion😳
vinit iz a far better singer then debo in my oppinion, thtss whyy while even debo waz in da competition, vinit waz most of the timee superstar of the week 😃 even before he got eliminated, which is why hiz elimination iz not justified at all. nnn vinit is the best accordingg to mee n waz alwaiz better then debo unclee. Vineet will findd lots of song offerz infact already haz, poor debo, he needz all the luck he can get.

of course it's my opinion that debo is a better singer and that vinit's elimination was totally justified just like his losing out to Debo twice before. My post was in response to you saying over and over hos debo cheated. If appealing for votes is cheating then all contestants are equally culpable. Why bring only one of them down... *****

Moderator's Note:

Post edited.. Please do not use abusive or profane language in the forum..


Edited by Anuradha - 17 years ago
200467 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#73

😆So, according to you if someone's appeal clicks with the audience, they are cheaters😆

btw, for us Debo fans - Vinit getting eliminated before debo da once again was like cherry on the top 😛 Kiddo must be sleeping with an ice pack under his butt now a days...kafi sore hoga na..getting kicked three times in a row😉😆😆

I am so glad we got our Rahul Vaidya back too. Dude has improved so much after vinit's elimination. Looks like company does matter...eh😉

Edited by Gauri_3 - 17 years ago
-Akanksha- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: Gauri_3

😆So, according to you if someone's appeal clicks with the audience, they are cheaters😆

btw, for us Debo fans - Vinit getting eliminated before debo da once again was like cherry on the top 😛 Kiddo must be sleeping with an ice pack under his butt now a days...kafi sore hoga na..getting kicked three times in a row😉😆😆

I am so glad we got our Rahul Vaidya back too. Dude has improved so much after vinit's elimination. Looks like company does matter...eh😉

actually some debo fans here liked vineet also 😉 . but it's a reality show, things like this keep on happening. they cant make everyone in the world happy at the same time.

200467 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: abhilasha2179

actually some debo fans here liked vineet also 😉 . but it's a reality show, things like this keep on happening. they cant make everyone in the world happy at the same time.

exactly my point. This is a reality show. Contetants have to appeal for votes. How fair it is to blame someone's elimination on some other contestant's vote appeals or defend the elimination by giving umer ki duhaee😉 Don't knoe about making everyone happy, they sure made me happy three times in a row so far😊

silverspike thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: yung S.K

Finally Vinit's gone



Finally Debojeet Chahcha is also gone to his oldage home....LOL
TheRowdiest thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 17 years ago
#77

Gauri bad news for u....once again u have to bear Vinit in Finale😆

sh_shivani thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: Gauri_3

😆So, according to you if someone's appeal clicks with the audience, they are cheaters😆

btw, for us Debo fans - Vinit getting eliminated before debo da once again was like cherry on the top 😛 Kiddo must be sleeping with an ice pack under his butt now a days...kafi sore hoga na..getting kicked three times in a row😉😆😆

I am so glad we got our Rahul Vaidya back too. Dude has improved so much after vinit's elimination. Looks like company does matter...eh😉

Gauri, you have to admit that you truly love Vineet and is biggest fan of his. You never stop talking about him. R U OKor a Physco.

jimhawkins thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#79
Please refrain from personal attacks on each other... Enough has been said and done here... No use pondering over the same thing again and again... Topic is being closed and this is a warning to refrain from any instigating posts or mud slinging towards each other...

Topic Closed

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".