My two cents - spoiler * - Page 5

Originally posted by: nandinidev

hey...😊 i'm not saying that you're singling Karan out...i know you're not, in any way...i rased this particular point only because there had been a similar discussion on Hard Kaur's Paso Doble as having been copied...and most people raised objections based on the Bullfight theme...i have not seen the performance Karan's is said to have been copied from, so i can't comment fairly until i have...i had seen the DID one HK's was compared to, though, and that was very different...😊 i appreciate the neutrality of this post, and am commenting in the same spirit, as i have always attempted to do...

Originally posted by: hope4u

see that's the point.. how long will you keep making exceptions for one contestant because he or she is not related to this field.. this makes sense in the first few rounds.but not after the wild card..after that, u enter into the final stages..and in the semi finals and finals its absolutely unpardonable.. what is the use of giving the trophy to a performer who need his choreographer to mask him and give him the simplest of steps..who choreographs in such a way that the judges fail to see anything beyond it.. we talk scores, the statistics show baichung is a better dancer than hard kaur and gauhar.. it really reflect horribly on the judging and i have no words to express how appaled i am.

FOR me Gauhar stole the show she was the best!!! THE greatest!!!! VOte for Gauhar only!!!! Karan n bhutia r bad dancers no where near gahuahr! gauhar rocksss

Originally posted by: xaneroyxx

It's true but doesn't that also speak volumes not just about scores but also about popularity and votes? HK got perfect scores every week but still got eliminated..so we could say that yes, the judges are playing a role in keeping him , but his fans are also contributing to making him reach the finale..so we're back at square one we can't tell people who to vote for, we can just try to rationalize the basis on which the judges are making their judgments and giving their feedback.

that's true, but with the 50-50 format we are having, the judges have to be a bit more..lets say judicious while giving marks.. last week, in the semis, hard kaur should've deservingly been the highest scorer.. if she has got that, then we might;ve seen a different result for then HK andBB would've been 1 and 2 respectively..and karan would've not been able to displace HK from the 1st position based on votes alone.. again, this week, they've completely nullified any advantage which gauhar would've got based on being the highest scorer which she honestly deserved. do u think it is even possible for her now to beat baichung in votes? there might've been a chance earlier , if there are people who are voting strictly based on dance..
that's all im trying to say.. the judges have done nothing which was in their hands to save the best. .the 50% which was in their hands, they totally waste.. what is the point in going on complaining about the rest of the 50 which is not in their control?

Originally posted by: xaneroyxx

It's true but doesn't that also speak volumes not just about scores but also about popularity and votes? HK got perfect scores every week but still got eliminated..so we could say that yes, the judges are playing a role in keeping him , but his fans are also contributing to making him reach the finale..so we're back at square one we can't tell people who to vote for, we can just try to rationalize the basis on which the judges are making their judgments and giving their feedback.

Agree with both of you to some extent...and i'd also like to add that this is the point some people have been attempting to make over so many weeks of bashing either Baichung for Judges being partial to him or Karan for the Janta being partial to him...and the judges appear in both lines of argument, in keeping BB safe and wanting KSG out...😛...so evidently, they do have a role to play...

as far as rationalising the basis for their decisions is concerned, that's quite a complicated point of reference too, since the basis happens to be different for every contender, every time...go figure...i'm not raising questions over their credentials, let me clarify first...they're established personalities, and know what they're talking about...but that does not, unfortunately, make some of their decisions any less inscrutable...😳

At this point, raising questions over their judgements wouldn't be unrealistic. Just because the majority of us aren't trained dancers or choreographers by profession doesn't mean that their opinions should be accepted as a given at all times (Anu Malik from Indian Idol, Himesh SRGMP), it doesn't take away from their credentials just perhaps help explain what exactly in their pov the performances are lacking.

k-babes r getting jealous like hell! why? See this :

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWBZd8R7oC8[/YOUTUBE]

I think I have already addressed your "concern" before..after seeing several of your other posts I think this is more of a hobby for you..so enjoy!