Sonu is to blame as much as the public - Page 2

I noticed one thing............this weeks GALA and result round; Sonu's behavior was completely different. He was not looking very happy........ Felt like he is upset about something.

Either it's public voting pathetically or makeovers and dancing given more importance than singing or something about Anu Malik. I think he was p***** off with Anu Malik's dumb shayari.........he said I don't know whether it's a sher or a lomadi. That must have created hard feelings between them.

I still think Sonu is the best judge. I mean his comments are really genuine and his judgment is the most accurate. But his way of telling has changed. He has become very harsh on the contestants. Hope he goes back to his own-self.........when he was sweet and at the same time used explain -ve points of a particular contestant.

sonu was harsh in this gala---but what do u expect him to do after seeing meenal n amey in the bottom3 last time round---he had to be harsh to show the public how good the 'best' contestants were....

True monali shouldnt have gone---but in no way do i agree tht sonu is to blame---id rather haev some1 who is harsh thn have useless judges lik anu n farah who just end up praising every1 w/o any basis most of the time!

Monali is out of this show for Sonu. He has to pay for it.

Originally posted by: Hridi

Monali is out of this show for Sonu. He has to pay for it.

I don't think Monali was out b'coz of Sonu...........he has talked equally bad about Sandeep and Ravi and Panna. Actually he found mistakes in every performance except Amey, Karunya and Anuj. So why Sandeep or Panna was not out of the contest? I do not think public follow judges comments. They vote for their own favorites.

I think Monali going out is public's fault......not Sonu's fault.

Originally posted by: loonytunes

Personally, I think Sonu is the only judge who actually gives CORRECT opinions. At least he doesn't praise people over-the-top when he KNOWS they didn't sing that well. If someone's good, he says it. If someone's bad, he says it. There's no fake air about him. He gives comments based on singing and singing alone and considering that this is a singing contest, I think he's perfectly right.

love,
LT

I absolutely agree with you loonytunes! Sonu is the only judge who can give accurate judgement...Monali was shaky thru out...even in previous rounds. her voice quality is good. but she is shaky...n she loses Sur many times..may be she has a kind of stage fright!

Sonu is the best and sane judge SO FAR...

exactly my thoughts!!

sonu gets rude more than required.for anuj who was completely off note in the whole song he said .is ko chance daina chayey nay ahai.naya hai tu iss ka matlab hai kai ek purana contestant who was so gud in all aspects should b kicked out.n monali was off note in sum lines which like anu said was ignorable.cuz her over all performance was very gud.sonu has gone really brutal even with his fellow judges.

I think and belive that Monali's going out is Sonu's falt.

I don't think SONU is to be blamed for this. He gives bad comments thru out to sandeep,& RAVI & always criticises singing quality of PANNA.. sTill wat happened? they were safe all the time.. Just becos he said bad about monali once, we are slating him for that.. very unfair..

When he praised KArunya in last gala, still KArunya landed in bottom 3. So why are we not saying about it?

THE BLAME SHOULD GO TO US- THE so called JANTA... we didnot vote enough to support monali.. thats the final...
Sandeep, Ravi & Panna's fans are very loyal to them, even after listening to SONU, ANU & FARHA's bad comments, still they vote for them...

I don't think Monali is out because of Sonu. What he said about Monali on the GALA day was right. yesterday
also he repeated himself that Monali did not have 'SUKUN' and SUR was here and there. which is true. Even i felt that Monali gave too much attention to her performance(thanks to Farha, who is permoting looks and all more then singing) that she was loosing out a lot in SUR.Not just last gala but before that also. Sonu talked equally bad about Sandeep, Ravi and Panna. Actually he found mistakes in every performance except Amey and Karunya. About Anuj his comment was right that it was his first performance and he needed that little space.

I think Monali going out is part of the game and public's fault(who is public)......not Sonu's fault.

__________________

Monali was perfact on the gala day. Anu is a music directer, he knows better than Sonu. Farah alaways loves Amey and Karuny's singining. Even she is keep on sanying to Antara to put concentrate on music.