Sonu is to blame as much as the public - Page 4

Originally posted by: madhy

i totally agree wit u.. sonu only luves monali nd meenal..except amey nd karunya.. specially he luves meenal.. annu nd faraha is gud..

I don't agree with you because he gives right comments only. He didn't like Meenal's performance in previous gala and he said openly that Meenal this time i didn't like ur performance, although she sang well but Sonu was not happy this time. Atleast he is the only judge who gives honest opinion unlike like Anu, As anu always try to please every contestant with a boring shares. and Sometimes he says"Antra u r best" and yesterday in result round he said that Antra u are lucky but u have to improve ur singing. What the hell is this? Sometimes he scold Ravi and sandeep and sometimes he says"Ravi and Amey both are good" Man think before you say anything. In the result round when Aman called Karunaya in bottom three then Panna was ready to come and when Aman asked about it then Anu said "panna, you should not be here in bottom three" What is this?

Originally posted by: Hridi

First Sonu had gone after Neha and the result neha was out then he went after Monali and she is out. Now he will go after Antara. Actually allready he started about Antara's pronunciation.

I don't agree with you. Sonu's favorites are Amey, Meenal, Karunaya and if he always praises for them then what is the reason that we see them in bottom three specially Meenal although she always gives 100% and she is a good singer. Sonu always gives bad comments about Sandeep, Ravi, Panna but they are never seen in bottom three. So please try to understand he always gives honest comment whether it is Meenal or Ravi.

I don't think the public gives a rat's posterior about what Sonu thinks or comments. He's praised people and they've turned up in the bottom three. He was severely critical of Panna and instead Karunya landed in the BT.

Sonu is the ONLY one who knows what's going on. However his criticism of Sanjeev was a little misplaced.. he could have voiced it differently. It was meant to be a suggestion but came out as criticism.

With Monali his criticism was just; how can u expect him to praise an off key performance (and annu malik won't know what's in key or off unless he rips it off someone first).

If u want to blame anyone, blame the people who ignored the weaker performers and dragged in Monali.. Anuj, Ravi and that third girl were better suitd for BT.

Originally posted by: Hridi

Monali was a big threat for Meenal and Sonu Knew it.

Hey man, don't say this. Monali was one of my favorites. Even I am sad if she is out. But don't blame Sonu if she is out. If you think janta do according to what Sonu says then Why We see Amey/Karunaya/Meenal in bottom three specially we see Meenal always in bottom three although she is a good singer. Sonu always gives bad comments about Sandeep/Ravi/Panna then why we never see them in bottom three. Sonu gives honest opinion whether she is Meenal or anyother contestant and How janta votes You can never say because always good singers are seen in bottom three. Whether It is Meenal/Monali/Amey/Karunaya. Sandeep, Ravi and panna are seen safe.

And one more Sonu didn't like Meenal's performance in previous gala and even he gave bad comments about it.

Originally posted by: Hridi

First Sonu had gone after Neha and the result neha was out then he went after Monali and she is out. Now he will go after Antara. Actually allready he started about Antara's pronunciation.

Sonu was not against Neha he was against Sony because they were selecting ABCD kind of songs for good singers. Even Farha had the same complaint and what both were saying "Neha u r not blamed for this we are blaming Sony for this. If you see Sonu was wrong then u should see Farha wrong too.

If Sonu found a problem in Antra's pronountiation then so did Farha. Then according to it both should be wrong.

Then why only Sonu, not Farha?

Originally posted by: Bittersweet

The only thing the janta looks at is how CUTE the contestant is. Pretty sad bcuz singing ability is at the bottom of the list in priorities. 🤢

I agree with you.

Originally posted by: purva

I don't think Monali was out b'coz of Sonu...........he has talked equally bad about Sandeep and Ravi and Panna. Actually he found mistakes in every performance except Amey, Karunya and Anuj. So why Sandeep or Panna was not out of the contest? I do not think public follow judges comments. They vote for their own favorites.

I think Monali going out is public's fault......not Sonu's fault.

I totally agree.

Originally posted by: pams309

I absolutely agree with you loonytunes! Sonu is the only judge who can give accurate judgement...Monali was shaky thru out...even in previous rounds. her voice quality is good. but she is shaky...n she loses Sur many times..may be she has a kind of stage fright!

Sonu is the best and sane judge SO FAR...

I agree with you. I am sorry for monali because She was cutest among all contestants and was not fake and was a good singer and she was a deserving candidate for top 5.

Monali was a deserving candidate for top 3. Because of politices she had to go out. Now I wish all the best for Amey and Karunya.

BTW, anyone knows Sonu ka itna mood kharab kyon tha?

And how come Mini and Aman are not seen together ?