My few reasons for Geet's adamancy..

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Hahaha! As if I'm going to tell you that!

@rahmona_pakswe

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

Brillaint post Eva! You have described the situation and the feelings beautifully. What I couldn't put down in words you did it and I completely agree with you. Wish only the CVs had executed it better.

Every now and then I wish someone with Geet's experience could show their point of view. It would be interesting to know how she would have reacted to the situation that Geet is in now.

Quote

dewdropred

@dewdropred

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

nice post eva ...... so U pulled out a reason why she is so angry with maan .... may B U have a point .......

but i always felt that maan never thought geet was disloyal to him .......

he never suspected her loyalty .....

but may b his words on the holi day made geet to think like that ..... that maan suspected her loyalty ......

coming to the cv's ..... i am super mad at them😡😡😡 ....... can't forgive the cv's for what they are doing 2 my fav show😭😭😭😭me sad & mad at the same time 😭😭😭😭......

i 2 want 2 know how the cv's will justify now after yesterday''s dialgoues & the holi episode ....... I really want to know why barry used those dialogues ...... & how they will give an answer for what ever they are showing now a days ......

me thinking that there might b a reason why they are showing geet so stubborn ...... coz we really don't know what the cv's have in mind ......

all i am worried is hope coz of the frequent change in story writers will not mess up our fav show .......

i will forgive the cv's only on 1 condition if they give me a gud explanation for the way they are treating maaneet after the holi episode ........

I am totally not happy with the way the story is shaping now a days .....

Edited by dewdropred - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Maddy

@iMadz

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

Well, eva, your post has always made sense, but this time, i don't agree with you completely, i can't not close my eyes and ears, and this is the fact, that CVs have ruined her character, completely, whether you agree or not !

You can't justify all her act, every time ! And, one more thing I want to say is that, even if geet, is so right and there is much more strong reason for her ' Stubbornness ' then, CVs have failed to shoe her POV completely ! Basically, on the big picture, and a very first sight, even a fool and blind can say is that geet is being stubborn and over reacting now !

And, yes Maan never suspect her love or respect, i don't know, how she interpreted things ! I agree, Maan said those words in anger, but what she did was equally wrong ! I would never leave my husband's home, no matter what !

"Words does not matter, only and only when, we know that the person who said those words, love us so much and unconditionally"

Geet has failed to understand this, and Maan has failed to control his anger !

Geet may be right, but then, she has to speak up, all she is doing is crying and utter only one line, 'Go Away Maan ! ' In the beginning, her tears reached me, but nowadays, i really don't care, coz she always cry and do nothing ! If she is right and there is a reason behind her stubbornness, then why the hell she is not speaking up ? Does she lacks Communication skills ? Maan has come all the way to solve the problem and all she is doing is that, asking him to go away ! She got a chance to save her relation, but it looks like, she does not want it !

Everyone said, wait and watch, geet will speak up, and justify her current illogical behavior, but i waited for ages, almost after she left home, and still, she is there, where she was ! I don't understand, she is confused ! Very much confused !

It's a very thin difference, you can't expect people to understand it like few sensible viewers and whose, who understands geet very well ! I'm out of it, coz i never understand her character, coz i did not follow her from beginning, i started it after Maan's entry ! So, i do not claim to understand geet better, but all i can see is that, she is over reacting !

At first, i was also sad watching her sad after MC, but post MC, it was limit then ! And, this track is, people find it funny, well on funny part, it is better, but on serious issues and social message, it completely sucks and failed !

I'm so sorry, if I have made rude or blunt confessions and opinions, but that is what i feel !

Quote

Princess DD

@Amoureux

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

Nice Post Eva 😊 I agree with you. Thanks! The only issues is i guess its high time the CVs show some more self talks from Geet and try to clear her POV. We are trying to understand it and know that it will take time for her to heal but the CVs are failing to highlight it and thus all the fuss around...

I hope the CVs get this that Geet's silence is just killing the essence of her character which we all love so dearly... 😊

I said this before somewhere in some post and and i'm saying it again... i still have this feeling that Geet is doing this purposely. There seems to be some reason for this. I hope i'm correct but again that all depends on how the CVs portray it..

Edited by Azmatazz - 14 years ago

Quote

Binge

@Binge

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

Eva, loved reading your POV.👏👏 It makes sense and there must be a reason for Geet's erratic behaviour.

Hopefully, CVs give an insight into her dilemna through self-thoughts and introspection in some way soon. 😊 Cuz if they dont write it properly causing confusion amongst the fans, that means they should make it more lucid for the audience to understand and connect with the main protagonists. 😊

Edited by shreya- - 14 years ago

Quote

evasumi

@evasumi

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

Thank you all for you inputs. Yea so many thoughts do put a light on so many grey areas.

All you have raised a point that we need somthing solid from the CVs is the right thing.

Many have said that Maan never suspected her loyalty... Yes that could be a right. But for Maan to raise a question like so tell me Geet what did he do to you that you played holi with him??? and then add the words like begairat and white blood and also say that if Geet does like that it is her problem but I would not do that way as I have the Khurana blood in me. And when he came in the kitchen and grab Dev's collar he used the word your ulterior motive. and when Geet wanted to stop him from hitting Dev he exploded at Geet asking the question about what did he do to you... In all this time he was reading Geet in totally different way... he was not trusting Dev but he was not trusting Geet also... His thinking when he came down rushing that I need to save Geet as she is innocent... means he thought that she was swayed by Dev's sweet talk. HIs this thought process was not the spur of the moment decision but he was meditating without giving chance to geet for explanation.

He should have trusted Geet that Geet would not take this big decision without any solid reason. But he has made up his mind and that is that. Dadima has been pleading him to consider and be a brother to Dev but he was adamant in his views.

His volcanic anger has the premeditated issue and that is only because he was not ready to listen to her and when they met for the first time after the break up he told her that he said those words in anger and Geet then asked really or you meant those words...

It also shows that even if he said those words in anger it were not said blindly they were spoken to hurt the target and they did pierce deep because they were from Maan to his Geet. After that Maan realised that how deep the hurt is.

and if she is behaving normally around her family is that she is pretending to be normal as she does not want to let them see her innerself and hurt but she does not pretend in front of Maan as she never could but her natural instict to protect him and honor him comes to her naturally when she was running through the corridor with him and when he asked her to go... the first thing came to her mind was and what about you??? That made Maan realise more that even though she is hurt she still cares for me the same way... and that also gave him the determination that I will do anything to bring my mishti back..

Edited by evasumi - 14 years ago

Quote

prst

@prst

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

thanks eva for such a nice explanation as m totally diasappointed wd geet's behaviour these days but dont u think these days cvs r not able to demontrate d impact of geet being hurt n it s irritating us she just keeps on repeating same sentence

Quote

maankigeet

@maankigeet

Beginner

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

Lovely post. You wrote all the points I felt. Geet never reacted in this way when Sasha, Naintara called her names. Becoz they were no one to her. But Maan questioning her self respect was unbearable to her. Becoz he is the person who saw it all, her leaving the family. Fighting with her family, world and even maan( misunderstanding phase before leaving KC). He questioning her is making her think is this what maan thinks of me. I know maan did lot of good things to geet. But it is the tendency of a human to remember one shattering moment then the sweet memories. Whenever she feels the love for maan, immediately she remembers those words thy take over her emotion of love. So maan needs to something nice that would have stronger impact and get back all the sweet memories. I know he will do that. All the gals be in her position and think, don't think of maan( hot GC) but imagine your loved one doing that to you. You will understand how it feels.

Quote

evasumi

@evasumi

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: maankigeet
Lovely post. You wrote all the points I felt. Geet never reacted in this way when Sasha, Naintara called her names. Becoz they were no one to her. But Maan questioning her self respect was unbearable to her. Becoz he is the person who saw it all, her leaving the family. Fighting with her family, world and even maan( misunderstanding phase before leaving KC). He questioning her is making her think is this what maan thinks of me. I know maan did lot of good things to geet. But it is the tendency of a human to remember one shattering moment then the sweet memories. Whenever she feels the love for maan, immediately she remembers those words thy take over her emotion of love. So maan needs to something nice that would have stronger impact and get back all the sweet memories. I know he will do that. All the gals be in her position and think, don't think of maan( hot GC) but imagine your loved one doing that to you. You will understand how it feels.

Absolutely loved your POV about how a person remembering the most shattering moments given by the most beloved person. and in that hurt all the love all the good times all the times when only Maan was with her gets wash away. The situation is like the broken glass... though one try to mend but it does not mend the scars remains as the reminder...

When during the time of their engagemnet when Geet left Maan and there were some volatile moments as Maan dragging her out of the office and they both go their separate way.. at that time also there was not a question of love between them it was the question of misunderstanding of one's behavior and when Geet was asking the forgiveness she told aapko maine galat samza. Maine Suraj per andhera ka ilzam lagaya.. (i misunderstood you. I made misjudgement of and thought you as the darkness but you were bright like sun) That time also there was not the question about one's love and Maan understood her perfectly saying that itne dhokhe khane ke bad to koi bhi galti kar sakta hai (after deceving so manytime any one can make mistake) and I also did not try to correct your misunderstanding...

So it was alwasy misunderstanding between them and not the question of one's love or integrity..

But here the allegation from Maan has totally different view. When he separated himself from her there was a contempt and disgust in his manner and action and he did not feel at all feel that he did anything wrong even when he saw cupboards empty of Geet stuff... even when Dev was forcing him to listen to him... He told Dev... you being of all people would teach me what is love???? and Dev had to stand firm and said yes I will as I know being the most unlucky person the value of true love and you do not...

Those harsh jolts from the man like Dev who has no moral values in eyes of Maan opened up Maan's eyes until then he had no idea that why in the world Geet had to leave him as he never thought that with those words he has condemn Geet of her loyalty.