My few reasons for Geet's adamancy.. - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

37

Views

3.5k

Users

19

Likes

164

Frequent Posters

evasumi thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: undisclosed

i'm actualy liking geet's stance...i think that until they talk about what exactly made her leave...then she realy can't move on...btw....what is the english translation for "gunha"? ...it would really help me a lot..

The simple would be sin and not mistake...
Geet said she would have forgiven any mistake but not this sin...
Cause Geet has forgiven many of his anger outbursts.. and with the last one she told dadima that she is just faking her anger as she cannot be angry at Maan for a long time..
But this time It was not only Maan's anger but It was his mistrust and his partial doubt... It may not be regarding her fidelity or loyalty but it could be that at the same time... and I think that would make it sin that he doubted her..
Because if you listen when Dev was talking to Maan after Geet left... He said bro I know that you have harbour many doubts in your heart... but Geet did not do it for me she did it for you..
It means Maan had doubts that Geet could go soft on Dev becasue they had history????
But all these needs to come out with heart to heart talk with Maan and Geet then only the audience would understand Geet's POV with her perspective..
We are just speculating everything... and try to understand what could be the real issue..
Edited by evasumi - 14 years ago
undisclosed thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: mechantefille



Yeah Sylvie sooo true...I hope the CVs look into that. Talk/communicate/critically appreciate the topics to bits if thats what it takes to get things clear.

Gunah is ''the biggest sin!''

ooohhh...so does it translate to the "the biggest sin" ...or does it actualy mean what the biggest sin is?...what is the biggest sin?
undisclosed thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: evasumi

The simple would be sin and not mistake...
Geet said she would have forgiven any mistake but not this sin...
Cause Geet has forgiven many of his anger outbursts.. and with the last one she told dadima that she is just faking her anger as she cannot be angry at Maan for a long time..
But this time It was not only Maan's anger but It was his mistrust and his partial doubt... It may not be regarding her fidelity or loyalty but it could be that at the same time... and I think that would make it sin that he doubted her..
Because if you listen when Dev was talking to Maan after Geet left... He said bro I know that you have harbour many doubts in your heart... but Geet did not do it for me she did it for you..
It means Maan had doubts that Geet could go soft on Dev becasue they had history????
But all these needs to come out with heart to heart talk with Maan and Geet then only the audience would understand Geet's POV with her perspective..
We are just speculating everything... and try to understand what could be the real issue..

thanks so much for explaining....yes, i always felt that maan was doubting geet and devs relationship towards the end...because they had been intimate...where maan and geet had not been...i feel that is why his words overstepped the bounderies...i would love to see geet's thought process...i hope they show more of her internal thoughts on the matter....
DMKJ_VB thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#34
i understand eva u wanna defend geet at any cost, but surely that does not mean,u put sm false blames on maan-from whatever the cvs hv shown,it is clear that maan never doubted geet for a moment,he was angry becoz geet had forgiven dev,not becoz he thought she had a soft corner for him!thats the reason he told himself and geet that tum use nahi janti,why should we speculate whats on geet's mind?becoz this is a show,not real life, here we shall see and accept whatever is shown to us,not try and imagine geet's point of view! if what u r saying is right,the cvs should hv shown that,when they haven't, we audience will definitely think that geet is being adamant and unreasonable! and pls how long will geet's every mistake be overlooked beocz she has gone through so much in life?maan has also gone through a lot with her.and u said he separated himself from her?i mean thats the strangest thing hv heard!geet left home without once looking back at maan-may be u don't remember! and before that, she had dstanced herself from maan,becoz she was incapable of understanding why he had cleared the nursery even after he explained everything in detail and apologized to her!
evasumi thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#35
Yea I think Maan have always felt vulnerable with the past history of Dev with Geet as it was not just superficial but Geet trusted and loved him to surrender to him..
And if you see all the incidents in that sequence... Dev proved right in understanding Geet's situation then Maan as what ever he suggeted had more meaning then Maan's plan of actions..
So ultimately Dev was the one to pull Geet out of her sadness and sorrow.. but he was able to do that only using Maan... but Maan did not know that and so he assumed that Geet came out of sorrow and was happy again due to Dev and that was making him madder and madder
So this meditation on all the possiblities made Maan's anger turned in to volcanic irruption and he lost all the focus on Geet and her love and her loyalty and his mind only believed what he saw instead of what was in his heart and in his being..
His mind lost the trust on Geet and thought that she forgave Dev and allowed him to touch her... A man who violated her innocence and trampled her dignity... So what was the cause of this tremendous change that Geet would do so... and he rushes downstairs and grabs Dev's collar and tell him that he has ulterior motive and wanted to beat him up but Geet requested with her eyes and he just turns to her and all his anger his dobut and his insecurites came out and he said so tell me Geet what did Dev do to you that you played holi with him?? Geet was aghast with that question and then if it was not enough he used the words like begairat and safed khoon... literally telling Geet that if you do not have self respect to associat with Dev then it is not my probelm means Geet lost respect and honor in his sight and he thought so low of Geet and thought that she associated herself with Dev so he said that my Khurana blood is not that cheap and will not stoop so low as you...
So those hurtful words were not just the words spoken in the spur of moment of anger they were premeditated words. He would not have spoken it if was in control but it came out of his uncontrolled mind and Geet knew at that time that he believed those words and that killed Geet and burnt her love and she completely lost her trust in him becasue if those words came out with such a anger and contempt and disgust that Geet just could not stand there for moment... She lost her dignity her respect in Maan's being if it was someone else she would give 2 cents about if but this was Maan her Maan who knows her inside out and to hear those things from Maan was just that she died with a fatal blow right there...
evasumi thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: ria_sengupta

i understand eva u wanna defend geet at any cost, but surely that does not mean,u put sm false blames on maan-from whatever the cvs hv shown,it is clear that maan never doubted geet for a moment,he was angry becoz geet had forgiven dev,not becoz he thought she had a soft corner for him!thats the reason he told himself and geet that tum use nahi janti,why should we speculate whats on geet's mind?becoz this is a show,not real life, here we shall see and accept whatever is shown to us,not try and imagine geet's point of view! if what u r saying is right,the cvs should hv shown that,when they haven't, we audience will definitely think that geet is being adamant and unreasonable! and pls how long will geet's every mistake be overlooked beocz she has gone through so much in life?maan has also gone through a lot with her.and u said he separated himself from her?i mean thats the strangest thing hv heard!geet left home without once looking back at maan-may be u don't remember! and before that, she had dstanced herself from maan,becoz she was incapable of understanding why he had cleared the nursery even after he explained everything in detail and apologized to her!

Ria... You have misconception about me defending Geet... For me Maan and Geet make Geet HSP and I love them both equally. and people who know me personally knows that I have always loved Maaneet. Yes you rightly says this is the show and one should not analyze it too deeply but personally I watch any shows not just as the show but I loved to see how a character is developed and what could be their reasons for their actions.. that is why I do not watch many shows only few which interest me..
Yes it could be possible that the creatives of the show may not indulge in that deep thinking but what ever I have seen in Geet so far I think the creative teams have always tried to show the indepth of Character..
And I love to see why a person so deep in love would say those things and equally a person so deep in love would leave the house and would not want to go back. So it means it should have deep root of hurt which is not being over come by love so what could be the reason... and you know that is the meaing of the FORUM... where we can express our POV and see others and conclude something and discuss it at any length. and this show is all about Geet and Maan... not them individually... so I would think the action and words of Maan and Geet would effect them to the maximum.. Not what other think about them but what they think about each other...
It is also not the point what Maan has done for Geet.. Yes he has done more then anything. What Geet got in her life was may be all becasue Maan was there for her but that means that he only has the power to make or break Geet. even when her brother called her Kulta on her wedding day, it did not affect Geet but she challanged him because Maan was with her all the way.. but if Maan says begairat to her... that has too deep impect then that heavy word Kulta...
You said I am trying to defend Geet but then what I see in your writing you are trying to condemn Geet... ... many may agree or disagree with my pov and I have no problem with that in fact I would love to know why would they think so.... So anyways every one is entitle to his or her POV and You are entitle to your POV and I am to mine.
Edited by evasumi - 14 years ago
Mounchy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#37
agreed eva!! the words he chose to express his anger were wrong👎🏼..... totally agree wid u👍🏼... a very good post.👏.... and begairat is a very big gaali to someone's self respect...... begairat means gira hua ya jis ki koi izzat nai hoti🤢... or geet ne to devil ko maan k liye hi maaf kiya na!!! to yaar main to kehti hun chaddo iss sub ko😉 or agay aanay waaley moments k baray main socho or mazay lo!!! 😆 😆 😆heheheheheheheheh
=P 😛

evasumi thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#38
Yea absolutely...
Agge jane mei maza hi kuch aaur hai... right?

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: heart882 · 2 months ago

Hey Guys! I’m excited to be back after a long break and to dive back into my story. The Prologue is now posted, and Chapter 1 will be coming...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 1 years ago

OLD PART LINK https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127 https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5009334 new part on blog who want please...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 4 years ago

Do dil.....

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts · 7 months ago

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".