A landmine deftly avoided by the CVs..kudos to them!!

sanfan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
I watched yesterday's episode with some amount of trepidation...Not so much becos of the Wednesday episode but becos of the Thurs monologue of Shravan. I felt that the CVs had scored a self-goal with that monologue...and wondered how are they going to get out of this one?

I watched Friday episode much later when it airs in the place I live...Before watching it, I wrote a message to Indrani saying all I hope from the episode is that the Cvs do not show Shravan having any immediate recollection of the Adi-Shravan convo. For me, it was the most important thing in how I perceive the serial...

I was happy that the landmine has been deftly handled by the CVs. Kudos to them!! Altho I am miffed with the monologue of Thursday...😔

Any recollection of the Adi_Shrav convo at this delicate juncture would have completely undermined the essence of what Adi's actions were and butchered Shravan beyond recognition. (if thats not already happened!!šŸ˜†šŸ˜†) Yesterday was purely a day to counter the assault on a woman. An action of this kind that Adi sought to perpetrate is a stand alone act. It deserves condemnation on its own. It needs no reflection on why it occurred, just the fact that it happened is enuf reason to be condemned strongly. Its is important to remember that there is no causative relationship to be sought here. In linking the two aspects in ANY form, we become guilty of playing into the hands of that part of society that seeks to find causative relationship to assault (of any kind) with situations, events, circumstances...and sometimes mere words. Even in the context of the make-believe world, these portrayals if wrongly, done only ensure the perpetuation of such wrong beliefs.

Therefore, I am very glad that did not happen yesterday.

If i am not clear above about the reasons on why I did not want that FB of the Adi_Shravan convo yesterday, let me say that more clearly. If Shravan was shown recollecting the conversation yesterday,especially yesterday, it would somewhere mean that Shravan thinks that he brought on the situation facing Sumo. It would give credence to the view that Shravan believes that he had contributed to "tarnishing" an "image" of Sumo and somewhere Adi's actions would go scot-free. If anyone thinks that Shravan is in any responsible for what happened yesterday, it means that in some perverse way, they are encouraging a set of beliefs in which society blames victims of sexual assault and normalises male sexual violence, a odd set of beliefs that encourage male sexual aggression and supports violence against women. We all have to stop viewing personhood from the male perspective. Once we accept that there is no reputation or image to tarnish based on these notions, we will automatically stop reacting with such outrage...of duniya kya kahegi and the like.


Admittedly a huge transgression occurred that day.Through the nature of the conversation and delivery, the CVs have arguably dug a hole for themselves. What is it that Shravan will reflect upon is key to the journey ahead, from my point of view. I told Indrani the other day that on Wednesday, Sumo was not in his periphery of vision when he had that outburst but the Thursday episode gave a googly. I think the CVs could not decide whether to keep Sumo out or in his thoughts in that monologue so they scored a self -goal by making Shravan reflect on Sumo's married life😔 making this a case for hero macho behaviour, as an afterthought.

I wrote about this on Wednesday that I felt, Shravan out of spite, spoke a huge lie and without the consent of the person involved, thereby breaching the privacy of the person he alluded to. The intention of that outburst is at the core of the issue, and admittedly it is a bit vague to me. I am not exactly clear at the moment whether it was only vindictiveness to show Adi who claimed to have a special place in Sumo's life. Unfortunately, the monologue on the next day gave an impression that given his deep-set misogyny, he was looking at it as if it was a victory of sorts that he managed to put a seed of doubt in Adi's mind. By making that conversation very explicit, and premeditated, CVs have made Shravan road to salvation very difficult šŸ˜‰.

So effectively. the CVs have avoided one landmine, waiting to see how they handle the next...šŸ˜‰ Namik's tweets have indicated the aspect of vindictiveness and the aspect of the lie that is paramount in the matter as also Sumo's reaction šŸ˜‰ (the key here!!)
So Hopefully, the CVs can make this worthwhile...

Ofc Shravan will go over that FB...many times in the coming days perhaps...that will be his private hell...i am only keen to see what triggers it!!😊
Edited by sanfan - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

68

Views

5.7k

Users

28

Likes

271

Frequent Posters

--Amulya-- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
WOW!!! just WOW!!!

thanx yaar for placing a new perspective... now I'm able to view the situation in a lot more different view

and I love your writing style
poppinss thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Depends on number of episodes sony alloted to the ph and the trps 😊
vaishu_k thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
I was so glad Shravan didn't feel guilty yesterday or else it would have given the impression of Shravan feeling himself responsible for adi's actions.
Thanks for small mercies. This gave me hopd that may be all is not lost. Shravan's character might not ruin completely.
But why do i feel it will go that way only, it's just matter of time.
All dialogues gave me that impression, jindagi bhar ka ehsaan and all.
I want shravan's guilt but for his lies only not for some molestation or character assassination.
I hope i am making some sensešŸ˜”
sanfan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: poppinss

Depends on number of episodes sony alloted to the ph and the trps 😊


Poppy,

I just hope my praise is not a case of famous last words...and all that I praised them for comes to haunt me...

I am not dreading the culture vulture brigade assault in the form of mami and chachi and sundry...that may happen...how Shravan and Sumo handle is most important...

I hope they have that many episodes necessary to handle it...šŸ˜†
Edited by sanfan - 9 years ago
PlainJane thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Great post.

I really love your angle and take on the entire situation. 😊

I highly appreciate your point of view.

The CVs did a good job with the episode. Nothing was OTT. That was what most of us were fearing. You are so right. In retrospect, I too realize that it was good call that they didn't show the Shravan-Adi bachelor night conversation in this episode, or else Adi's actions would have been undermined.

Thank you for this lovely post. It is very thought-provoking😊
sanfan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: vaishu_k

I was so glad Shravan didn't feel guilty yesterday or else it would have given the impression of Shravan feeling himself responsible for adi's actions.

Thanks for small mercies. This gave me hopd that may be all is not lost. Shravan's character might not ruin completely.
But why do i feel it will go that way only, it's just matter of time.
All dialogues gave me that impression, jindagi bhar ka ehsaan and all.
I want shravan's guilt but for his lies only not for some molestation or character assassination.
I hope i am making some sensešŸ˜”


Yes u are making sense...definitely to me..😊

As u said, it may be a matter of time lets see...Its about sensibilities too...If the larger audience does not appreciate it...I guess it will not matter how a few see it...

As I said to Poppy, that prevalent social mores will decide the next course... However, within that, there is manoeuvring space for the CVs to do something nice...Hopefully...they will!!

Joyness thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Superb...now i have decided to keep my brains aside watch EDKV and keep calm🤣
puba thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Beautifully written.

Man that monologue of his...completely broke my heart. Whatever he said was out of pure jealousy towards Adi and hatred towards Nirmala...Sumo did not even feature in his thoughts! Damn...I had really thought that those things he said were partly a result of this want to rid Sumo of Adi...since he knew Sumo wasn't happy with the alliance! But no...I was so freaking wrong!

Then about yesterday's episode...for some reason...I did look forward to it! Everything was fine...till the time Shravan's true feelings crawled back in to the shell and his hard and harsh shell resurfaced. I mean like seriously? There she was with a tray of food...FOR HIM...his only friend...who had just been physically assaulted moments ago...instead of going and sitting by her...and trying to calm her down and making her feel better...he reacted almost cruelly! Did he have to say that he would have done this for any woman?? Did he have to say that he was there for Nanu?

Some people will say he was feeling guilty or whatever...so he retracted...but at such vulnerable moments...you only think about how to make the other person feel better...and that's it! So his behavior irked me to no end! While Sumo maybe knew what Shravan truly felt and thought (though I really doubt it...because after such an incident...people are hardly in the right frame of mind)...at such times...you just have to overtly show your care for the person...even if that means just sitting by them!
an_chau thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Rekha!!!! I'm so glad that there r writers and thinkers of your caliber on this forum. Maybe the depth and clarity of your words here will get the message - that many of us have been trying to say, but in vain it seems - effectively across.
We charge Shravan with misogyny but do not realize that the moment we say his words "caused" the assault on Sumo or that he tarnished her image, we are actually filling out the same thought bubble that tags a woman's virginity as her virtue, something that only her husband has rights to, and other such BS!

It's also very sad to see people still wanting to know the reasons/circumstances that "led" Adi to assault Sumo. Does it matter? Can anything ever justify his action? Some say Shravan's words were the "trigger"... Triggered? Can Sexual assault be triggered? What's next? Blaming Sumo for leading Adi on so that he couldn't control himself? The more we discuss triggers, and what made him do it, we actually add our weight to the group that lets perpetrators get away with their crime.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".