Should someone be held accountable if they lead someone to suicide? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

2.6k

Users

12

Likes

11

Frequent Posters

Viswasruti thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#21
Though looking mysterious , now while the facts are coming out , it seems it was a meticulously planned murder . All revelations by her friends and family members after her demise and her bank account statements are indicating that he swiped her crores of rupees and emptied all the bank balances , then slapped her in full public glare and left her there and went away !
In spite of torture and mental agony , why she continued that relationship -- many are asking this question time and again ! Who knows , in what way he threatened her and kept her in his captive ? May be there is any video or any other such thing which any girl on earth never like to show to the world ? Keep aside the love relationship for a while , not even an ordinary offender ever dare to eat chips while his lover"s dead body was there ! Later disappeared with her mobile from the Hospital and surfaced after 24 hours !
Why Mumbai police are not arrested him at that time and not yet now ?
Why Neeraj, his ex- lawyer stepped back from this case . A lawyer can't afford to tell lies before the media .
Loving and believing is not a crime , though live - in relationships are not fully acceptable and feasible in our country , yes hers was an immature decision . Having faith in her lover is not her fault , he made her to believe his every act and word as affectionate as possible to deceive her ! Many young girls are dying every now and then in such manner in the world in general and in our country in particular because of the traditions and societal norms .
She was cheated by that leach , and murdered by him . Sorry , this is not my allegation , it is a fact the entire world is believing including the Magistrate , except the Mumbai police . Reasons one has to explore !!!
Edited by Snehamadhuri - 9 years ago
Viswasruti thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#22

Pratyusha Banerjee's on-screen mother-in-law Smita Bansal remembers her laado

Sumitra and Anandi were inseparable on Balika Vadhu, on screen as well as off it. Smita Bansal opens up about the Pratyusha Banerjee she knew in an exclusive interview.

She called her laado, and portrayed one of the most loving mothers-in-law we have ever come across on-screen. Sumitra and Anandi were inseparable on Balika Vadhu, on screen as well as off it.

Smita Bansal, who played Sumitra--Pratyusha Banerjee's doting mother-in-law on Colors' popular show Balika Vadhu, is shell-shocked with the news of her suicide, as she remembers her as a "happy and loving girl" who adored life. "It's beyond me; what could have lead her to take such a drastic step," she tells us in an exclusive telephonic conversation, as she struggles to come to terms with her sudden departure. "We were good friends. We (Pratyusha, Neha Marda and I) used to spend every minute with each other, while being on the sets and even used to go out together," she says, adding, "Pratyusha never showed any signs of depression at that time."

"Pratyusha liked being happy. She wanted happiness in her life. She didn't like being low. She would snap out of it even if she felt low at times," says Smita. In an exclusive conversation with India Today online, Smita Bansal opens up about the Anandi she knew.

Pratyusha literally grew up in front of us
Pratyusha was absolutely new when she joined Balika Vadhu. She literally grew up in front of us. . It was her first major show; she had come from a small town. She was very loving. For us (Balika Vadhu team) the transition was a little tough, with new Anandi coming in, after Avika Gor's exit. Avika was very popular and the expectations were very high from the new Anandi. But she met all the expectations and in fact rose above all of them. She was a good performer, she made herself Anandi which was commendable. We spent a lot of time together in all these years. We had a nice on-screen chemistry. And naturally so because w
Pratyusha liked being happy

She was a very happy and loving child. And when you are happy and loving, you attract happiness also. We were working together for 20 hours in a month and spent so much time in the make-up room. Neha Marda (who played Gehna), Pratyusha and I particularly shared a very good bonding. I was the senior-most, but they never made me feel like a senior. Pratyusha used to say--let's go out together, and all three of us hung out a lot of times.

Pratyusha liked being happy. She wanted happiness in her life. She didn't like being low. She would snap out of it even if she felt low at times. People are saying, she had depression, but when she was working with me, I could not see any signs of depression. She couldn't have hidden it. She used to discuss all the details with us. She wasn't the kind of person who would hide her woes. Even if she had a small argument with somebody, she used to discuss it and get her out of the system. It is difficult to believe that she had depression. But as they say, anybody could get a depression. It could be possible agar usey suddenly ho gaya ho. But she wasn't depressed at all and a happy person when she was working with me.we were very good friends off screen also.

She loved life
I never thought she would do something like this. I would not like to comment whether she could or could not have committed suicide. Because I have come to believe that anybody can do anything. But there has to be some reason behind it. She loved life. She was the kind of person who used to start singing out of the blue. She was always updated about the latest movies and songs.

I left Balika Vadhu two years back, and Prayusha left the show way before. We were in touch on and off, but not constantly. In our industry, as we move on to other soaps, we don't have much time to hang out with friends. Even when we talk, we don't really discuss our lives in detail. I don't know how her nature has changed in all these years.

Maybe it was a moment
I considered her a very good friend of mine. She didn't give me any hint about it. If she would have made that one call to any of her good friends who could have put some sense into her. Maybe it was a moment and later she also must have thought--what the hell I am doing.

I knew Kuljeet Randhawa (another TV actress who committed suicide) and I had also worked with her. I had done a show with her and had spent a lot of time with her also. It wasn't the same like Pratyusha, but we shared a good equation. I never felt that she could commit suicide. But as we see in the past two-three cases, it comes from the most unexpected people.


Don't think there was any financial trouble
I don't think she had monetary trouble. I have been in the industry for 20 years. Paisa to aata hi rahta hai. She was constantly working. She did so many shows. After Balika Vadhu, she did Bigg Boss, Sasural Simar Ka, Jhalak Dikhhla Jaa etc. She used to do events also. How could she have no money? Even if you are doing one event in a month, there's enough money for a month. She was a very big name, she wasn't a nobody.

Pratyusha was excited about her wedding

She was offered a lead role in &TV's show by Vikas Gupta, but she rejected it. You don't refuse work, if you have financial trouble. She wanted to take a break, get married and that's the reason why she didn't want to do another show probably. The last time I spoke to her, she was discussing what she wanted to wear on her wedding. Kahan par karenge..kaise karenge..wo bhi Jamshedpur ka hai, main bhi Jamshedpur ki hoon and all that. She wasn't the type who would get depressed about work. She wasn't insecure. And why would she be? She saw the heights of success. She became a star overnight.

Pratyusha was very close to her mother
She was loved by her mother. I have seen them together. She was so close to her mother. And she didn't even call her before she took that step. I find it very strange. What mental condition she must have been, is beyond me.

Message for actors: it is most important to be sane in life
But there is a message I want to give to the new breed of actors. Work is important, money is important. But it is most important to be sane in life. A family keeps you grounded and bounded. I am saying this because I feel sad. Our families are very important. I have been married for 14 years and even then if I have the slightest of problem, I call my mother. In Pratyusha's case, I never saw it coming. I have spent so much time with that girl.

Only if she had been with the right people...
I read in a paper that Sara Khan said she tried to commit suicide two times earlier too. If somebody knew about it, somebody should have done something about it. If she had been with the right people, this day wouldn't have come.

She was cut off from the world when she was dating Rahul
A lot of my industry friends were telling me that after Rahul came into her life, she was cut off from the world. Though I understand that when somebody is in love, it happens, you tend to distance yourself from others.

Need for a proper investigation
There should be a proper investigation in her case. There was no suicide note, nor any last messages found. In cases of suicide, generally there is at least one last message, in her case there was nothing, no message, no note."


Viswasruti thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#23
Thank you Nado for this link and thank you Vibha for the WU .❤️🤗
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kVdqo7DV_FQ[/YOUTUBE]



Here is the WU of Prats' parents interview on India TV:

Prats' mom wants him to get the severest punishment, so that no other girl meets her fate. Father does most of the talking, he says he will not blame the Court for not doing its duty, the problem is with the police who has not put up proper evidence to the court. Her time of death as given by the police, before that there was a conversation between her and Rahul where she calls him a cheater, accuses him of separating her from her parents, accuses him of death threats to her and her parents, why was this not considered? the police report itself proclaims that Rahul is a drug addict and possibly a drug peddler too, he takes her cell phone and runs away, must have deleted a lot of other evidence, moreover, the police has only taken one phone of Rahul's, nowadays youngsters have more than one phone!

Also, he would tap Prats' phones, she would call up her parents and ask, why do I feel as if the CBI is after me, everyone knows what I am talking, she meant Rahul would get to know her conversation with others, so he would have been tapping her phone calls. And it is not he alone, there are others too who are with him in this deadly act because all those from the industry and her family and friends who testified against him, are receiving threatening calls.

If Prats does not get justice, we will kill ourselves or file a petition in the Supreme Court seeking euthanasia rights, to kill ourselves!

Her mother sobbingly narrates, he told lies and came into her life, when i saw he was lying, I tried to caution her, neither Prats or we knew he was married earlier,his friend, Saloni sharma, tortured and hit Prats lots, he asked Prats to ask me to go from the house for now, we will call you later during the marriage, the conditions were not right for me to stay in the house, so on January 12th I left.

He is now questioning, why we did not file an FIR against him on the first day itself, I had left behind a living child and you give me her dead body, we were so devastated, and he expects us to file an FIR on the day of her death! We hate the name Rahul too, though there must be many good children with that name.

Regarding her abortion, we got to know of it only on April 12th or later, when it was reported in the Times of India. Back home, we run a charitable institution for underprivileged children and have brought up so many children, so why would we not take care of our own blood, he did not let it live too!

We never met his family but his father was claiming on television that she had loans over 50 lakhs, the truth has emerged from that she actually had loans of about 10 to 15 lakhs which was a small sum for one of the highest paid actresses in television industry. I know Rahul and his family took a lot of loan from others, so they were trying to put that too on Pratyusha.

The whole world is shocked at her death, a girl so much in love with life cannot commit suicide, this is murder and it should be probed!

373577 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#24
Could there be a common factor underlying the celebrity deaths like that of Jiah khan, Divya bharti, model kuldeep randhwa and many more --Failed relationships, depression , financial mess, waning stardom ---- make for a deadly combination.
arsneh thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#25
regarding legally i dont have much idea about it bt morally i do feel the person should be held accountable coz nobody has got the right to play with ones emotions like this that they give up their life
now the question arises why was she continuing with such a person when she was a strong and independent girl
well it clearly shows how deeply she was involved with him that she continued the relation with all his flaws and gave up the life when lost hope
so i feel pushing a person to such an extent that she gives up on her life is definitely wrong
also i want to mention when a person commits suicide its not just for one reason bt he or she reaches to this conclusion only when they lost all hopes of betterment so even if she was getting betrayed by her bf or upset by him still her family was there if she would b having her family support in no way she would have taken such step so i feel not only her bf bt her family is responsible as well

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".