Why Anushka couldn't save JHMS? - Page 8

Originally posted by: dietcoke1

^^^lol deepika fans simply CANNOT get over the fact that anushka didnt do tamasha...they bring it up in every thread that they can...plz jus get over it... rather than using it to bash anushka everytime. She didnt like tamasha and did the right thing by not doing it. She liked JHMS and agreed to do it. Sometimes a character doesnt turn out the way u expect it to but that doesnt mean she shudnt have done the film...you dont know until you try.

Originally posted by: dietcoke1

^^^lol deepika fans simply CANNOT get over the fact that anushka didnt do tamasha...they bring it up in every thread that they can...plz jus get over it... rather than using it to bash anushka everytime. She didnt like tamasha and did the right thing by not doing it. She liked JHMS and agreed to do it. Sometimes a character doesnt turn out the way u expect it to but that doesnt mean she shudnt have done the film...you dont know until you try.

Originally posted by: TheBoss

I think the golden era of Bollywood has just begun. I have always wanted to see where good movies get appreciated and bad movies fail. I think people have collectively risen up and broke down barriers and unilaterally said NO to shit movies loud and clear...

Originally posted by: dietcoke1

^^^lol deepika fans simply CANNOT get over the fact that anushka didnt do tamasha...they bring it up in every thread that they can...plz jus get over it... rather than using it to bash anushka everytime. She didnt like tamasha and did the right thing by not doing it. She liked JHMS and agreed to do it. Sometimes a character doesnt turn out the way u expect it to but that doesnt mean she shudnt have done the film...you dont know until you try.

Tara >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Sejal.
Thanks to Anushka for not taking up Tara otherwise sensible Tara would turn to bubbly Tara.

Btw if Deepika was offered and took up Sejal opening would be easily 25-30 crores. SRK - DP together only can generate this high opening.

Originally posted by: -Sujal-

Nowhere in the league of Kat/Deepika? Anushka made her own way to the top!! Katrina would not be where she is if it was not coz of nepotism!! Katrina Kaif is like a wooden stick on screen, her expressions are so annoying!! Anushka performed better than her in Jab Tak Hai Jaan!! I think Anushka has potential & is talented, that is why she is up there!!😛

everyone is comparing Anushka in her top phase ( supposedly now) to Katrina's weakest time ( BBD etc). , that's not a fair comparison. Like I said I'm not questioning whether she can act , we all are aware she can. Hell when JTHJ failed people even blamed Kat for it, even though it was a srk movie. When tamasha didn't do well, people questioned deepika's star power even finding fanny. When shaadaar bombed even Alia's BO pull was discussed.

Just that she is never held accountable atleast in this forum for success or loss of any movie. It's like she is just there in terms of screen presence. Imagine BV happened and she slipped under the radar like she wasn't even in the movie!

I hope her fans don't believe this should be her prime. Every person should be held responsible and sorry if she's a top actress now so should she!

Originally posted by: HawasKaPujari

Wow the comments are amazing! 😆😆

How is Sultan more female-oriented than Tamasha? Why comment on films you've rejected--she's being sly and slighting DP by saying anyone would do well in a film by Imtiaz. No need for the rudeness, Deepika's never openly criticized/attacked Anushka, Anushka seems hypocritical. Anushka used to be my favorite but after she being friends with the RK-Karan camp she's become less genuine. PV Please Post

So she turned down Tamasha as it focused mainly on the male protagonist but picked DDD and Sultan coz these were female oriented!...Who is she trying to convince?

She's throwing low-key shade though. By saying that any actor will be good in an Imtiaz Ali film, she's taking away credit from what Ranbir and (especially) Deepika brought to the table as actors in Tamasha. Imtiaz is a great director, of course, but the actors in Tamasha took the film a step further (the story wasn't particularly gripping). Neither Nargis Fakhri (Rockstar) nor Giselli Monteiro (Love Aaj Kal) were good or received praise for their acting even though Imtiaz directed those movies too. It takes a good actor to get the kind of praise that RK-DP got for Tamasha. In fact, I don't know if Anushka would've excelled as Tara in Tamasha at all. Deepika (while being a limited actor herself) surprisingly brought a deep sense of vulnerability, effervescence, and radiance to Tara, which would've been lost in Anushka's limited repertoire of wide smiles, unintended frowns, and superficial bindaas girl act.

Originally posted by: bafflingtulip

everyone is comparing Anushka in her top phase ( supposedly now) to Katrina's weakest time ( BBD etc). , that's not a fair comparison. Like I said I'm not questioning whether she can act , we all are aware she can. Hell when JTHJ failed people even blamed Kat for it, even though it was a srk movie. When tamasha didn't do well, people questioned deepika's star power even finding fanny. When shaadaar bombed even Alia's BO pull was discussed.

Just that she is never held accountable atleast in this forum for success or loss of any movie. It's like she is just there in terms of screen presence. Imagine BV happened and she slipped under the radar like she wasn't even in the movie!

I hope her fans don't believe this should be her prime. Every person should be held responsible and sorry if she's a top actress now so should she!

Originally posted by: -Piku-

Tara >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Sejal.
Thanks to Anushka for not taking up Tara otherwise sensible Tara would turn to bubbly Tara.

Btw if Deepika was offered and took up Sejal opening would be easily 25-30 crores. SRK - DP together only can generate this high opening.

Ehh Anushka is fab in the movie. I feel it's somewhat her best acting so far otherwise is a bad story