imagine if madhuri and kareena would have a great sense of script

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

CeaselessBanter

@CeaselessBanter

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: beboholic
@meri- Yes she does enjoy being a star more than being an actor. But I disagree that her being a star overshadows her work because majority of people know she's a good actress and consider her one of the best.

She is very talented, had it easier and more opportunities to do better films than Lolo. She also squandered it away IMO. Her resume does not justify her talent, she could have been a Ranbir.

Quote

Tanya

@tanya.91

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: beboholic
People like to,complain about how many good projects Bebo rejected but I honestly don't think she was the best choice for all the films she rejected. Honestly, I think she knew she wasn't the best choice for those films too.

Fashion..PC was the better choice because PC is a model in real life. Kareena was the best choice for Heroine.

RL- I just can't picture bebo in that film. I feel a younger actress was needed there and plus Bebo is not good at Indian classical dances. To be honest apart from giving her a hit and probably another best actress award..I don't think Leela was a good role. DP's Coctail was a better role. No one is going to remember RL years from now.

Kal Ho Na Ho- I think this was her biggest mistake. PZ was really good in it but I think Kareena could have pulled it off too. But look at where PZ is today and look at Kareena. Bebo has JWM which was a much better role than KHNH and had a better imact for Bebo than what PZ got from KHNH. I think Bebo still gaining from the success of JWM Bcause Geet was so likable and memorable.

what else did bebo reject..I can't remember them all. lol..I don't think she was offered Queen if she was..she lost big time there.

Having said that..I do wish Kareena picked good films like Kahaani, English Vinglish and Queen. These are really good films esp EV. But am proud of her for being part of Talaash because that's also a really good film. We need more films like that Bebo. Not to bring down these actors.because I really do like them...but Kangana and Vidya in Kahaani and Queen weren't really brilliant in terms of performance..what made them look good was the their choice in script..the film made them look good. So yes..being part of good films is really important even more than the performance.

beboholic ji, u have some good pointers here... but who knows, maybe bebo would have pulled off these roles with even more finesse and could have given them a new dimension.

kanagana also had no modelling experience, but everyone stated that she came across some super model in fashion, and had a true killer attitude of a ramp model...she even got a national award for this movie.

bebo also rejected kaho na pyar hai and imagining bebo in knph scenes and songs, i think she would have looked much better as compared to ameesha in her debut if she had chosen that film to start her career with.

bebo also rejected black ... and few other very important and mega hit movies.

Edited by tanya.91 - 11 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Koiza

@-koiza-

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#43

im not sure about madhuri's acting skills but kareena is a much better actor than her anyday...very natural!! I don't care about madhuri but I wish kareena had a better script sense

Quote

.khoobsurat.

@.khoobsurat.

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#44

What exactly does Ranbir have that Kareena doesn't though..except his dancing skill and better script sense. I don't think he's any better than Kareena in terms of acting. I love Ranbir but none if his perf made me go..wow his brilliant. Kareena is much better than him IMO. I haven't seen Rockstar and I think his perf in Rajneeti and Barfi is overrated. But that's just my opinion.

Quote

sara rafeek

@Ooolalala

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: beboholic
What exactly does Ranbir have that Kareena doesn't though..except his dancing skill and better script sense. I don't think he's any better than Kareena in terms of acting. I love Ranbir but none if his perf made me go..wow his brilliant. Kareena is much better than him IMO. I haven't seen Rockstar and I think his perf in Rajneeti and Barfi is overrated. But that's just my opinion.

He is overrated, his only good performance was Barfi but even in that movie PCee completely overshadow him. He was horrible in some movies too. Kareena on the other hand is a natural actress and she can easily do all types of roles.

Quote

Koiza

@-koiza-

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#46

KAREENA would have become a ranbir? lol

what a slap on kareena's face..she is a lot more talented imho and has achieved way more than biru so far

and ranbir's script sense is not so mindblowing either- he did a besharam!

Quote

gilmores

@gilmores

Stunner

+ 8

Posted: 11 years ago

#47

Hmm...we still talk about Madhuri 20 years later. Let's see if we'll still talk about Kareena 20 years from now.

Quote

CeaselessBanter

@CeaselessBanter

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#48

Originally posted by: beboholic
What exactly does Ranbir have that Kareena doesn't though..except his dancing skill and better script sense. I don't think he's any better than Kareena in terms of acting. I love Ranbir but none if his perf made me go..wow his brilliant. Kareena is much better than him IMO. I haven't seen Rockstar and I think his perf in Rajneeti and Barfi is overrated. But that's just my opinion.

I am very partial towards their grandfather. His movies have made me / make me weep, I seem to run randomly into old Russian people who like him a lot and sing his songs with them 😆. Very weird experiences

I saw Raj Kapoor in Lolo because well she looks like him. That is one of the reasons I like her..😳. I see his talent and his drive to make movies in Ranbir. Raj Kapoor loved cinema. Ranbir loves cinema, the art of it from what I have read him say and what people say about him. He went to Lee Strasbourg one of the best acting schools in the world when he could have traded on the Kapoor name. I believe he will have a multi-faceted career like Raj Kapoor. And the film that firmly and finally pushed me into liking Ranbir was Barfi. I am not a weepy person and not every movie makes me cry But Barfi made me cry. I don't see a lot of Raj Kapoor in Bebo at all, more her dad which is not a good thing.

What Ranbir has that Bebo does not is drive and ambition IMO. She will only be an actress, I will be shocked if she directs though I pretty sure she can. Ranbir is hard working, Bebo comes acorss like she does not care. Talent wise they are matched IMO, it is how they choose to use it is where Ranbir is rings around Bebo

Quote

991876

Hibernated

Posted: 11 years ago

#49

For me Bebo's acting prowess is limited. She is very good at playing the hyper, bubbly girl parts like in Jab We Met, I don't know about others but I can't take her seriously in serious parts like in Kurbaan because for me she doesn't do them justice. When you ask people their fav Kareena film or role most probably say Jab We Met or something along those lines because for Bebo she's memorable when she plays those bubbly fun characters as they play to her strengths, that's her specialty in my opinion.

Whereas with Mathuri, I know she's made some shitty choices in films and item songs recently, but for me she's good at playing the fun bubbly girl as well as being good at the serious scenes too. Like when she cries or is happy it translates on the screen so the audience are able to relate. Plus you have to give credit where it's due, even now Madhuri is still one of the famous BW actresses and she hasn't achieved that status doing nothing. My dad likes her ok 😆

Quote

Lalalalost

@Lalalalost

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#50

[Quote=meribaat] I don't see a lot of Raj Kapoor in Bebo at all, more her dad which is not a good thing.

What a huge insult to Kareena 😆
he was never even a successful actor (alcoholism part of it)
How do you see that in her? Shes survived 14 years and is still in the top 5. I wouldnt insult her by comparing her to him.
Shes achieved alot more than that.

Edited by BindaasReena - 11 years ago