'If Aishwarya was unprofessional, so was Abhishek' - Page 5

Originally posted by: sheee

Well. She didn't even tell madhur to give him time and discuss all the problems, which were going to come with this news. So everything is useless.

Actually nothing needed to be discussed. All she had to do was, sign a clause citing anything that happens to her during shooting, only she is fully responsible for it and would've continued with shooting. Believe me, it would've been completed without any menace.

Originally posted by: VanityGirl

Actually nothing needed to be discussed. All she had to do was, sign a clause citing anything that happens to her during shooting, only she is fully responsible for it and would've continued with shooting. Believe me, it would've been completed without any menace.

But why are you expecting Madhur to go to her to sign a clause when she didn't even tell him this news personally? She was working for him, with him on this project and she didn't bother to tell him a news, which was going to affect the way, they work? she was very unprofessional, and stuck up in this matter. They could work things out, if she had being truthful, or if she gave him any importance, and wanted to work things out or discuss this matter with him.

Frankly in this whole issue... Timing is the key... Before it was announced to the world Ash shld have taken Madhur into confidence and discussed how they could have handled it better... Now it has become a case of mudslinging against each other when clearly both are at fault, maybe one more than the other... But yes I do blame both of them...

Originally posted by: sheee

But why are you expecting Madhur to go to her to sign a clause when she didn't even tell him this news personally? She was working for him, with him on this project and she didn't bother to tell him a news, which was going to affect the way, they work? she was very unprofessional, and stuck up in this matter. They could work things out, if she had being truthful, or if she gave him any importance, and wanted to work things out or discuss this matter with him.

lol maddy, after reading the news somewhere else, I don't expect him to go to her and start talking about it. Madhur is absolutly right here. It doesn't work this way. You shouldn't be allowed to walk all over people no matter you are aish/pregnant or a woman.

Originally posted by: VanityGirl

How can it hurt her baby when enough precautions are taken? Plus it is HER risk, not the director's. On top of that it is not even an action film.

Originally posted by: masakaliii

True it is ridiculous to ask someone to loose that kind of weight, but we must take into consideration that this is the filmi world. Directors can ask anything of their lead and the lead must comply to make it work, unless otherwise. The same requests have been made to Vidya, Rani, etc. And sometimes they follow through, sometimes they dont.

Again, her body in Cannes was one that Madhur could work with but probably also expected her to shape up for Heroine. Shape up a lot more. Aishwarya is a beautiful woman but she has certainly gotten bigger, and this is a harsh industry. If your going to represent a 'face' that millions will love you need to follow the rules the masses lay out, and especially for a film like this one.

I feel as though madhur probably expected the shoot to lengthen but just made some bakwas announcment about it being 40 days.

There are things about this whole situation that are murky, i can't say i support Aishwarya on this one, she made a very bad call, but i think madhur could have salvaged the project or atleast i hope he still does.

If he expected her to shape up and lose a 15 pounds, he would've told her. And Ash, in her state would've flatly refused it citing her state. But that clearly didn't happen considering how she showed up on the first day of the shoot. Her body looked the same just as in Cannes. That means her weight was clearly not a problem.



However, in his latest interview, Madhur said he is not in a state to imagine this film with anyone else other than Aishwarya. Also rumours are on that he will be making DTBHJ 2 next and Heroine later when she is back.

I have a strong gut feeling that matters would be resolved. Plus, the kind of publicity the movie generated, I would be surprised if UTV wouldn't capitalize on it.

Originally posted by: sheee

But why are you expecting Madhur to go to her to sign a clause when she didn't even tell him this news personally? She was working for him, with him on this project and she didn't bother to tell him a news, which was going to affect the way, they work? she was very unprofessional, and stuck up in this matter. They could work things out, if she had being truthful, or if she gave him any importance, and wanted to work things out or discuss this matter with him.

I think she didn't tell Madhur for one simple reason: If she told the director before she passes her saftety 3 months period and what if it gets leaked (like it usually does) and then god-forbid she got miscarried? The media would've ripped her apart. I'm sure she didn't want it to be discussed which is why she didn't divulge the fact.

^ God forbid, but can miscarriages only occur within that 3 month period?