Chapter Judaai. Let's take a look back! (Part 3) - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

3.2k

Users

11

Likes

115

Frequent Posters

danshula thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: viraf4u

yes you are absolutely right about VO- without them this show would be like any other show.. and totally not relatable to any other generation... the VO and its connection to today makes it so much more lovable... I do have complains about Naina's VO- I understand when we look at past we laugh on the stupidity we did... but that laugh when we are actually witnessing the incident just feels out of place...laughing after the incident makes it ok but during the event happening just makes us loose the very intensity of the event happening..

Coming to our Sameer- I see this unfolding as the class hospital showdown between naina and Sameer... I have never felt Sameer had the guts to ever express or take a stand.. he has always been a bystander... and a reacting person... I don't think he will be the one to tell Naina to go away-- he will be the one to act aloof and it will be Naina to confront and strongly express her feelings and have a major showdown.

I hope that happens- because I think the leads are due for one- where the whole year comes out in tears.. and anger.. and they sort it out and conquer it and pass it together to start something new going ahead...and somewhere we are due for it too-- we have been confused, angry and disappointed with this track as much as them as well. We need that closure just like them.

The upcoming letter that Munna has- would be just that I feel- asking her to concentrate on studies as board exams are approaching and he is going to do the same-- so he might not write that often..and she should not.. to give her time and pace to get her priorities completed ...I would be very surprised if he breaks up with her in the letter- bcoz the precap for the week shows Naina very happy...

I love how you write down the VO's they make it all the more better ...I look forward to more of our discussions going forward 😊


@Bold: Thank you! Same here!

Oh yes, there are times Sadiya's laughters are not needed into the scene. I think with the drama factor during Judaai the need is less for sure. Otherwise before judaai it was fine imo.

Yes the letter will be like what you said, break up not on the cards..

Yes, I am expecting a confrontation by Naina too!! Its going to be all her. Not Sameer. She is gonna open that taala acchse!! Not only that she is stronger emotionally, but Sameer is not in that state at all to take the initiative. When he is emotionally stable and has someone around he is fine to speak up. Like he had MunDit during heartbreak phase while pursuing Naina.

And while Naina is confronting him, she will make him breakdown and blurt out everything he has been bottling up inside him for the year. Similar to MtAbu, when she refused to go and he blurted everything. But this time they are in deeper love and this time it will be on larger scale (He'll mention Dadi at some point, she met her for a reason) Like I mentioned dil halka can only happen with Naina. He wanted to do that when Nanu passed away, when he went to Ahemdabad to meet her.. and he'd want to do that now as well but jinx thing has clouded his mind. Its coming a full circle. Its gonna be emotional reunion with all sorts of emotions I swear.. this is all where this is heading towards. Whole fandom yearns for this!! High time!!
Edited by danshula - 7 years ago
viraf4u thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: danshula


Thanks for reminding me about Maa having doubt about Naina. Added that bit, forgot to add. Yes its coming up real soon for sure.

Yes, judaai was great way to look into Somani dynamics, while I dont defend this track in any which way I was only analysing.. not sure if Dadi was really needed during Judaai coz thats where show took a hit Imo but now that we have got that, I guess its time to look back at it and understand what was given to us & why.


Thank you!
Agree! Like I said myself, I was not expecting it to be this long. I totally feel it could be 1 or 2 weeks shorter. Especially the initial 2 weeks were torture seeing all that KeDi plotting. But am also sure, with Judaai ending, this drama factor also ends. Its happy times ahead! As Ahemdabad the essence wasnt lost I felt, its only Delhi which took a hit for me too.


Like VO said, "Unhe dekh kartoh apni kismat pe ghamand ho raha tha mujhe"
When was this aired? I don't remember hearing this.

danshula thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: viraf4u


Like VO said, "Unhe dekh kar toh apni kismat pe ghamand ho raha tha mujhe"
When was this aired? I don't remember hearing this.


When MunDit visited Delhi, 160th ep, after they shoo'ed the guys away! It continued with.. "..aise chipku aur ghoonghrale wale dost bhagwan sabko de" haha this is easier to recall!
Edited by danshula - 7 years ago
viraf4u thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#34
I am not sure what to even write about this current track and acting chops? IS it just me or everyone- that are feeling the same way?
The track is stretching nonsensically and Randeep is totally not connecting to the track... and that is making it all the more difficult to watch the track unfold..Rohit is amazing and Naina is enacting this track and all tracks soo beautifully...

How long can we take this? I understand its just this week but has this whole Delhi track hurt us viewers more? What would it take the CVs and show do to revive our love in the show again?

Hope you can make some sense of this track because I am completely lost and confused- of course I have a thread going exactly that..
danshula thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#35
Added main bits in original.
#Ep172 thoughts:

I liked today's episode a lot actually! Felt a truly balanced episode of YUD after so long! Sameer's VOs were positive. What VO said was not only mentioning his last days in Delhi but also that sehne ke din emotionally too!

"Lekin woh kehte hai na, insaan jab tak sehta nahi hai, usko apni himmat ka pata hi nahi chalta, ya phir yeh koi signal tha ki sehne ke din khatm hone ko the"

Loved the letter leap! This week so far has seen the two sides of love, as VO said, "Dono ka pyaar ek-sa tha, bas pyaar ka swad.. alag-alag." During dance comp, he saw himself as weakness, but she saw him as strength. During letter leap, the more he tried to distance himself, the more closer she got to him. He can't resist Naina with letters, what he will in person. The moment she is out of sight, he looks out for her.

Letter leap gave Naina lots of hints about him struggling emotionally, adhoori chhittiyan, stopping radio job, not talking on phone, (Dadi came up here too) and finally precap.. crying on radio. His last radio show, he gave hints. Two women of his life, noticed his sadness. Maa & Naina. For Maa it will make him go back to Ahemdabad, for Naina.. its all leading up to her connecting the dots when she comes face to face with him. She can read his face just like that! Naina's rose makes me believe they come face to face on last day of school. Lets see!

Its a growth in Sameer emotionally they are showing imo and their relationship! Naina was always strong but he wasn't so now its high time this happens before any major responsibilties come to him. As eps air I connect the dots & this is what I read from his VOs from Mon-Wed! Its somewhat the rise of Sameer Jaiprakash Maheshwari, before zimmedariyan this is needed. He needs to get emotionally matured, he can't be always emotionally dependent. Yes he has NaMunDit, but will he have them 24x7? No. Nanu's words will come back about responsibities as track shifts back. Not immidiately, but thats where this is all heading. Growing up Sameer Maheshwari this is.

As for Naina, I see growth in relationship as now she is shown as his strength. Her faith in him will become his strength. She will also learn to support Sameer, emotionally or otherwise. Both will learn big time along with their reunion.

I have noticed as Delhi track is ending and its transitioning to full Ahemdabad track.. CVs are slowly toning down the drama factor and bringing in the old charm of YUD back one by one! Started off with Shefjun and today that Sunday VO! I was completely nostalgic & taken back in time! Now, thats truly Yeh Un Dinon Ki Baat Hai!
Edited by danshula - 7 years ago
viraf4u thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: danshula

Added main bits in original.
#Ep172 thoughts:

I liked today's episode a lot actually! Felt a truly balanced episode of YUD after so long! Sameer's VOs were positive. What VO said was not only mentioning his last days in Delhi but also that sehne ke din emotionally too!

"Lekin woh kehte hai na, insaan jab tak sehta nahi hai, usko apni himmat ka pata hi nahi chalta, ya phir yeh koi signal tha ki sehne ke din khatm hone ko the"

Loved the letter leap! This week so far has seen the two sides of love, as VO said, "Dono ka pyaar ek-sa tha, bas pyaar ka swad.. alag-alag." During dance comp, he saw himself as weakness, but she saw him as strength. During letter leap, the more he tried to distance himself, the more closer she got to him. He can't resist Naina with letters, what he will in person. The moment she is out of sight, he looks out for her.

Letter leap gave Naina lots of hints about him struggling emotionally, adhoori chhittiyan, stopping radio job, not talking on phone, (Dadi came up here too) and finally precap.. crying on radio. His last radio show, he gave hints. Two women of his life, noticed his sadness. Maa & Naina. For Maa it will make him go back to Ahemdabad, for Naina.. its all leading up to her connecting the dots when she comes face to face with him. She can read his face just like that! Naina's rose makes me believe they come face to face on last day of school. Lets see!

Its a growth in Sameer emotionally they are showing imo and their relationship! Naina was always strong but he wasn't so now its high time this happens before any major responsibilties come to him. As eps air I connect the dots & this is what I read from his VOs from Mon-Wed! Its somewhat the rise of Sameer Jaiprakash Maheshwari, before zimmedariyan this is needed. He needs to get emotionally matured, he can't be always emotionally dependent. Yes he has NaMunDit, but will he have them 24x7? No. Nanu's words will come back about responsibities as track shifts back. Not immidiately, but thats where this is all heading. Growing up Sameer Maheshwari this is.

As for Naina, I see growth in relationship as now she is shown as his strength. Her faith in him will become his strength. She will also learn to support Sameer, emotionally or otherwise. Both will learn big time along with their reunion.

I have noticed as Delhi track is ending and its transitioning to full Ahemdabad track.. CVs are slowly toning down the drama factor and bringing in the old charm of YUD back one by one! Started off with Shefjun and today that Sunday VO! I was completely nostalgic & taken back in time! Now, thats truly Yeh Un Dinon Ki Baat Hai!




Thank you for that analysis- and the optimism... I simply love it.. yes I agree the big reunion is coming.. but the point I struggle with is again execution and the dragging of the story line...why cant all this be shown in say 2 episodes with time leap?? why drag it? it some how dulls that whole emotion quotient we have with the leads.

Yes SJM definitely needs to happen and Delhi was the foreground for it... and it has served its purpose...so y the drag now.. yes we are going to see him leaving today.. but I am still not happy.. Is it just me? or the track has put a big dent on our enthusiasm that might be difficult to lift??

Of course they need to show their union and outburst as soon as possible- because its not fair to naina to suffer bcoz he is being a baby this long... what do you think?..

We all know they are going to get married and have a happy every after... but the journey is what makes us fall in love with them.. if more Bus stand- dance sequence Hit and miss we get... last day is also a hit and Miss?? you think we can survive?

I loved the VO and the indication of the dark age ending... but when... it all now hinges on this WHEN... bcoz we already know its suppose to always happen...

Thoughts?
danshula thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: viraf4u



Thank you for that analysis- and the optimism... I simply love it.. yes I agree the big reunion is coming.. but the point I struggle with is again execution and the dragging of the story line...why cant all this be shown in say 2 episodes with time leap?? why drag it? it some how dulls that whole emotion quotient we have with the leads.

Yes SJM definitely needs to happen and Delhi was the foreground for it... and it has served its purpose...so y the drag now.. yes we are going to see him leaving today.. but I am still not happy.. Is it just me? or the track has put a big dent on our enthusiasm that might be difficult to lift??

Of course they need to show their union and outburst as soon as possible- because its not fair to naina to suffer bcoz he is being a baby this long... what do you think?..

We all know they are going to get married and have a happy every after... but the journey is what makes us fall in love with them.. if more Bus stand- dance sequence Hit and miss we get... last day is also a hit and Miss?? you think we can survive?

I loved the VO and the indication of the dark age ending... but when... it all now hinges on this WHEN... bcoz we already know its suppose to always happen...

Thoughts?


Oh deffo! I don't get the drag part either. Till shaadi, any problems would get solved within 2-3 episodes, but during Judaai, its a weekly thing I have noticed. I dont know why thats the case. As much as I liked ep172, ep171 could be skipped. ep171 didnt serve much purpose as compared to 172. The letter leap was more meaningful. I guess 171 was basis of 172.

But yes, the drama factor has been so much these past 2 months that I think it feels too much for us now, that also could be the case. Like a friend of mine was like Sameer is hiding from Naina from 2 weeks now, and I reminded her no, he is doing that only from this Monday. So, I think this is the thing. Like you are saying when when when, this is how its making us feel. We are impatient.

Based on Rohan's live chat, today Sameer's Mama-Mami family are also going to be mentioned. Naina's rose makes me believe the reunion is on last day of school itself! End of any track gives hints for new. Like Nanu's last words hinted towards Somanis & business. And they're promoting last day of school as, "End of a chapter or a new beginning" So both is happening! Last day is promoted as important! So they should be coming face to face on this day.

Today starts last day of school, I think we will be fine from today. We have seen 1 day shown in 3 episodes, but because of PVKM never felt the drag coz of the light heartedness. So, it should be good from today I feel. Am always optimistic in general, so I try to bring it here too! :)


Edited by danshula - 7 years ago
viraf4u thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: danshula


Oh deffo! I don't get the drag part either. Till shaadi, any problems would get solved within 2-3 episodes, but during Judaai, its a weekly thing I have noticed. I dont know why thats the case. As much as I liked ep172, ep171 could be skipped. ep171 didnt serve much purpose as compared to 172. The letter leap was more meaningful. I guess 171 was basis of 172.

But yes, the drama factor has been so much these past 2 months that I think it feels too much for us now, that also could be the case. Like a friend of mine was like Sameer is hiding from Naina from 2 weeks now, and I reminded her no, he is doing that only from this Monday. So, I think this is the thing. Like you are saying when when when, this is how its making us feel. We are impatient.

Based on Rohan's live chat, today Sameer's Mama-Mami family are also going to be mentioned. Naina's rose makes me believe the reunion is on last day of school itself! End of any track gives hints for new. Like Nanu's last words hinted towards Somanis & business. And they're promoting last day of school as, "End of a chapter or a new beginning" So both is happening! Last day is promoted as important! So they should be coming face to face on this day.

Today starts last day of school, I think we will be fine from today. We have seen 1 day shown in 3 episodes, but because of PVKM never felt the drag coz of the light heartedness. So, it should be good from today I feel. Am always optimistic in general, so I try to bring it here too! :)




Thats what I love about your posts-- optimism is perfect.. Yes I am optimist myself that's what my journey on this discussion started as.. trying to decipher the Sameer character and to make heads and tails of it...and it brought so much enthusiasm that I was so ready to tackle this week.. whatever it may be...

But Boy was I surprised.. as to how low they can go... with the dance sequence had poor dance steps.. and didnt see the connection and the manhoos phase...and Sameer pulling back... dragging along for esp no reason...

I am so ok with this Judai track-- I totally know its needed but ... this... phewww still am sighing at the whole execution...

Yes it seems new chapter is beginning.. but how do you think they are going to show this old chapter getting over?? just meeting and show down you think? and what will be the showdown about??? I feel Sameer needs to bounce back not in the track but also with his acting chops.. his graph has gone down considerably and that is why this track has become a little more of a drag.. would you agree?

maybe I am just too attached or still watching the wedding re-runs make me crave for that chemistry and sizzle between the fab 6..

Hoping for a big bang to happen soon ...
danshula thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: viraf4u

Thats what I love about your posts-- optimism is perfect.. Yes I am optimist myself that's what my journey on this discussion started as.. trying to decipher the Sameer character and to make heads and tails of it...and it brought so much enthusiasm that I was so ready to tackle this week.. whatever it may be...

But Boy was I surprised.. as to how low they can go... with the dance sequence had poor dance steps.. and didnt see the connection and the manhoos phase...and Sameer pulling back... dragging along for esp no reason...

I am so ok with this Judai track-- I totally know its needed but ... this... phewww still am sighing at the whole execution...

Yes it seems new chapter is beginning.. but how do you think they are going to show this old chapter getting over?? just meeting and show down you think? and what will be the showdown about??? I feel Sameer needs to bounce back not in the track but also with his acting chops.. his graph has gone down considerably and that is why this track has become a little more of a drag.. would you agree?

maybe I am just too attached or still watching the wedding re-runs make me crave for that chemistry and sizzle between the fab 6..

Hoping for a big bang to happen soon ...


Oh totally! I think you are just missing the fab 6 together! Everyone is!

As for Randeep, his growth as an actor is fab! He is portraying all vulnerabilities of Sameer so brilliantly! His eyes emote so much. Not sure what makes you feel so.. Randeep has become a natural in emotional scenes. Earlier he wasnt. Chemistry is like old still, its just we are missing it now thats all.

They are rushing to fit in everything in episodes to end Delhi track this week themselves. I have felt it myself since past week. With Delhi ending, editing will be back on track! And execution will feel smooth! :)
viraf4u thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: danshula


Oh totally! I think you are just missing the fab 6 together! Everyone is!

As for Randeep, his growth as an actor is fab! He is portraying all vulnerabilities of Sameer so brilliantly! His eyes emote so much. Not sure what makes you feel so.. Randeep has become a natural in emotional scenes. Earlier he wasnt. Chemistry is like old still, its just we are missing it now thats all.

They are rushing to fit in everything in episodes to end Delhi track this week themselves. I have felt it myself since past week. With Delhi ending, editing will be back on track! And execution will feel smooth! :)



Totally Optimistic... Yes Rds graph had grown leaps and bounds since the angry young man phase.. and absolutely there is a an awesome growth... I cant say enough about the hospital scene or the ILU scene.. they were brilliant..I was hoping this judai track would bring out that hospital emotions... when he broke down completely or that boy on the hill in Mt Abu completely broken down by the ignorance form his mom.. he has given us such brilliant performances.. that the past couple of weeks have been very bland..

Teh simple hugs to Deepika yesterday couldnt emote or feel that big brotherly love.. or the hug with Rohan on getting the letter from him... the pat on the back... whereas Rohit emoted so much better ...

Yes I guess I am missing that chemistry too much.. bcoz we have seen that and when we know what they can do... its just a heartbreak to see something even remotely a notch down...

Aashi has nailed any and every scene in all these episodes... any track any scene... I have never felt she didnt do good justice..

I am hoping going forward our exchanges would be full of chirping birds and roses.. :)

Amen to that phase coming soon...

So you think they are meeting tomorrow or Monday??? well the Delhi meeting happened on Monday... so we will have to wait till monday.. and the showdown coming right after ... or still some ignorance and manofy track after the initial meeting?

I vote for meeting and huge showdown- to keep in track with lets begin the new chapter together...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".