Chapter Judaai. Let's take a look back! (Part 3)

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

danshula

@danshula

Explorer

Posted: 7 years ago

#41

#Ep173 thoughts:

"... mujhe kya pata tha ki Swati ki baat sach karne, Sameer Ahemdabad aane wala tha. Par usne hum dono ke bhavishya ko badalne ki thaan li thi."

I see this as, Sameer had decided to stay away from Naina but Naina had not!!! So she will pull him back! Its still a positive VO!

"...par un dinon.. un dinon logo ke zindagiyon mein sadgi thi aur isiliye gehrai bhi. Bina dekhe hi, Naina ne aur Maa ne mere aawaz ke halke se badlav ko bhi samajh liya tha.. yeh un dinon ki baat hai!"

Nothing much to add today. What I have been predicting that Naina & Maa will be connecting the dots.. in today's episode it just happened.

There are two things happening which is making Sameer-Naina is increasing "Dil ki dooriyan" as Naina said.

1) Distance coz of cities

2) His fears & emotion struggles

Maa is solving one of his problem, distance.

Naina will solve his another problem, fears & emotions.

---

Otherwise today's episode, they are clearly trying to fit in what has been shot already & hence editing is an issue. But as Delhi ends it should be ok am very sure. Tomorrow last day! :)

Quote

danshula

@danshula

Explorer

Posted: 7 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: viraf4u

Totally Optimistic... Yes Rds graph had grown leaps and bounds since the angry young man phase.. and absolutely there is a an awesome growth... I cant say enough about the hospital scene or the ILU scene.. they were brilliant..I was hoping this judai track would bring out that hospital emotions... when he broke down completely or that boy on the hill in Mt Abu completely broken down by the ignorance form his mom.. he has given us such brilliant performances.. that the past couple of weeks have been very bland..

Teh simple hugs to Deepika yesterday couldnt emote or feel that big brotherly love.. or the hug with Rohan on getting the letter from him... the pat on the back... whereas Rohit emoted so much better ...

Yes I guess I am missing that chemistry too much.. bcoz we have seen that and when we know what they can do... its just a heartbreak to see something even remotely a notch down...

Aashi has nailed any and every scene in all these episodes... any track any scene... I have never felt she didnt do good justice..

I am hoping going forward our exchanges would be full of chirping birds and roses.. :)

Amen to that phase coming soon...

So you think they are meeting tomorrow or Monday??? well the Delhi meeting happened on Monday... so we will have to wait till monday.. and the showdown coming right after ... or still some ignorance and manofy track after the initial meeting?

I vote for meeting and huge showdown- to keep in track with lets begin the new chapter together...

I think its Monday they come face to face in school, lots to air for tmro.

As for what happens, I think he will try to run away from her in school, like MtAbu but she won't leave him and will finally confront. Something like that. A full hit&miss is not on the cards.. as its already done. But initially he will run but she will eventually catch him in real as she feels his presence.

The hugs are done well I thought since he is lost in his own thoughts, he is not fully with his siblings but struggling, so hugs are half lost in his own world types. So nicely done I felt. For me its the opposite, since Nanu's eps I have just seen growth in Randeep. I had liked MtAbu more than Ep90 breakdown realisation. But with Nanu ep, I was like wow he improved.

I hope I am active post Judaai phase! I usually post less, but come to write when get the urge to write my thoughts on YUD & Samaina emotions. Track ending or start I usually make posts to make sense of what we got or can foresee. With Judaai I really wanted closure myself, and hence this thread happened! I guess my closure will finally end with their breakdown.

Edited by danshula - 7 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

viraf4u

@viraf4u

Navigator

Posted: 7 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: danshula

I think its Monday they come face to face in school, lots to air for tmro.

As for what happens, I think he will try to run away from her in school, like MtAbu but she won't leave him and will finally confront. Something like that. A full hit&miss is not on the cards.. as its already done. But initially he will run but she will eventually catch him in real as she feels his presence.

The hugs are done well I thought since he is lost in his own thoughts, he is not fully with his siblings but struggling, so hugs are half lost in his own world types. So nicely done I felt. For me its the opposite, since Nanu's eps I have just seen growth in Randeep. I had liked MtAbu more than Ep90 breakdown realisation. But with Nanu ep, I was like wow he improved.

I hope I am active post Judaai phase! I usually post less, but come to write when get the urge to write my thoughts on YUD & Samaina emotions. Track ending or start I usually make posts to make sense of what we got or can foresee. With Judaai I really wanted closure myself, and hence this thread happened! I guess my closure will finally end with their breakdown.

yes nanu's death scene was enacted awesomely... that range and growth was soo awesome that I still get goosebumps when I watch the reruns..

I hope that we get our closure quickly on this phase as well...and be in Monday or Tuesday we are done with it.. and we can definitely start the next chapter... on a happy note..

I hope you keep doing the weekly analysis bcoz your expressions of VOs is bang on and a pleasure to read...

I am sorry for the hint of pessimism and disappointment... I am hoping to be over the moon soon :)😊

Quote

danshula

@danshula

Explorer

Posted: 7 years ago

#44

Ep174 thoughts:

"Jaise hi kacha dhoodh peene se acidity ki saari jalan shaant hojati hai na, theek waise hi feeling ho rahi thi mujhe, jab Maa ne mujhe Ahemdabad jaane ko kaha tha. Lekin uss waqt mujhe yeh nahi pata tha, main wapas jaake kitnon ka haajma kharab karne wala hoon"

A relief VO! He knows Ahemdabad is his home, thats where he belongs. So he is happy and relieved. But the end of VO is fun one haha, so Naina & Sameer will come face to face but he is going to be acting aloof a bit, making NaMunDit restless a bit, that why is Sameer being this way! Lol Chalo fun days are back from Monday. Bye bye drama, hello old YUD! Trust NaMunDit to make it all fine super soon (few eps) in coming week.

Vishakha mentioning Mama & family, assures me they arent negative anywhere close to Dadi since she promised Sameer, he won't ever cry again after today. So, Maa knows what she is doing, if she is sending Mama to live with him. They must be trustworthy.

--------------

Judaai ending thoughts:

Absolutely love the growth of all characters in Ahemdabad. So gradual and perfect at all bonds, NaMunDit, Preeti-Naina, SwaMun. Its just Delhi that got screwed up for me and the weekly stretch for each theme of Judaai, Loneliness & adjusting with fam. (2 weeks could be saved here, 1 of which could be saved from Mission Naina in Delhi, point was to meet Dadi, could be done like MunDit visit imo) And I wished for a lil more sibling scenes. Sameer-Maa saw good growth!! Lovely parallels. From start of track, Maa not being able to speak in front of Dadi to today, speaking and voicing her opinions in front of everyone. Vishakha came a long way.

The thing was ..the combo of good-bad-good-bad-good episodes effed up the watching experience overall. First 2 weeks negative to show vulnerability were enough, after that should be a smooth experience but the good-bad eps combo, ruined the Delhi parts experience. Ahemdabad was great, since they are old characters.. and well established with CVs.

My thoughts on Sameer's growth are in my original post! It's long enough to make me not repeat here again lol

Love all the letter phases, love how each letter phase portrayed something about Judaai. From the excitement of first letter to the latest one being about how to read the other, even with minimal communication.

With this I end this thread of mine. Atleast for now.. until I feel like coming back. I will write back at their breakdown & confrontation for sure. Since I need a closure big time from the track. I will be replying anyone who posts here though! Cheers guys! Sameer has left for Ahemdabad!! Happy days!

Have summarised Week of Ep170 and edited in original post!

Edited by danshula - 7 years ago

Quote

viraf4u

@viraf4u

Navigator

Posted: 7 years ago

#45

Thank you for coming full circle with this track.. but you think this track is over?

I feel maybe you should continue this until they are back on love track.. just a suggestion..

In either case I love your analysis and VO- explanations.. they are bang on...😊

Quote

danshula

@danshula

Explorer

Posted: 7 years ago

#46

Originally posted by: viraf4u
Thank you for coming full circle with this track.. but you think this track is over?
I feel maybe you should continue this until they are back on love track.. just a suggestion..

In either case I love your analysis and VO- explanations.. they are bang on...😊

I feel there won't be much to talk about now, keeping in mind its gonna go back to being the combo of emotional-light heartedness. But if I feel the need to write something on a VO or dialogues, I will surely write.

My prediction is they come face to face last day of PVKM eventually but Naina thinks she is dreaming & leaves until it happens couple of more times and she starts doubting & they plan to catch him and then breakdown. Nothing to write till the breakdown imo. But if so, I will surely write! :)

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

Chapter Judaai. Let's take a look back! (Part 3) - Page 5

Related Topics

Explore Topics