Chapter Judaai. Let's take a look back! (Part 3) - Page 2

Originally posted by: viraf4u

i cant help but post again.. thank you so much for bringing out the inherent flaw in Sameer;s character out...

he like to run away from things bcoz of the short comings from his childhood- nanaji saying he always used to pout if things would not go his way instead of solving it himself...

he has always need support in growing up- nothing wrong with that- but that is our Sameer... when the headboy competition didnt go his way- he took up the bet and didnt realize he would find naina.. and fall for her...

when the bet was disclosed- he chose to run away and not face her.. and when he saw her in the hospital he ran away- bcoz he got scared- that it was him that did that to the one who loved him... but there were mundit that brought him back and made him realize to own it and take responsibility...

when he was sick and naina came to the hospital and told him the fact of what was making him say sorry- it all came out and he realized that he had fallen head over heels for her from a long time ago--- he never realized it bcoz no body made him realize it- mundit tried and prodded him but he always let it go...

but when he realized it he owned it and committed to make her happy even at the expense of his own love for her...and he took on the weeding and the taunting and beating from her family...

when he was all alone in delhi-- he took to wrong ways bcoz no one made him realized what he was suppose to do..

after meeting naina and taking out his frustration on her- and that phone call after that - made him realize what he did was wrong and he needed to own his actions and be stronger... that made him accept his mistake about running away...

the bad boys gang--no one said stop-- if Rohan would have stepped up at that time dont know if that would have helped him as he needed someone to tell him to stop bcoz he knew he was wrong...and thats when mundit came and brought him back to love..

now this whole people dying bcoz of loving him track- will have to end with them meeting-- bcoz that is the flaw of the character... If they dont meet for whatever reason- that would throw him a world of fear and chaos-- where it might be impossible to bring him back... bcoz this time he will run away not bcoz he is angry on himself or someone else.. but bcoz he is scared for his loved ones.. and that is the true growth of the character...

So If this is what CV really want to portray.. then naina needs to pull him back and make him feel safe and secure to grow...

bcoz naginmam very rightly said in her interview- its Sameer that has struck gold by loving naina and not the other way around..

let me know what you think...

Originally posted by: dilse99

Very nice and detailed analysis Anshu! 😊

Love your week to week descriptions of the track - it really helps to look back and analyze it more closely.

Yup, the worst part of the track was KeDi for sure. Still cannot understand what the makers were thinking by including these two characters. A strict, disciplinarian would have worked, but the childish and one-note Dadi, always plotting with only one agenda on her mind was a major turn-off. It really did ruin the track for me. I mean, you can't watch the episodes in their entirety because of Dadi, unlike in the previous tracks where episodes were really watchable from beginning to end.

Other things I didn't like - I get it that Rohan is a quiet and more observant character, but imo, no excuse for not showing any gradual progress between him and Sameer. They could have added a few scenes here and there, and it would have been so much better. Also, was not a fan of Sameer taking his anger out on Naina and returning to Delhi. I get he was angry, but the fact that he just left after that made no sense to me. And the Rajiv Gandhi angle also was unnecessary to me and could have been omitted.

Lafangey track - Even if I can justify Sameer falling into wrong company and losing track of himself, I would still say these scenes were very uninspired, except for Sameer's VO's.

Speaking of the VO's, I like that you mentioned the noteworthy ones in the track. In fact, many a times they became the strongest points of the episode. I do have to agree that despite the awful scenes of KeDi, there was nice progress in Samaina's relationship, through their phono convo's and letters. Also, yes the individual character growth/journey for Sameer and Naina was overall written well.

Other things I DID like - NaMunDit bonding was excellent. Was so glad to see gradual progress in this area, and it was one of the positive aspects of the judaai, also Naina-Preeti. Like you said, Ahem track was overall still good.

Coming to the last episodes of this track, unfortunately they have decided to stretch things even further and have really upped the emotions and drama. Definitely this entire track could have been shortened by a week or two - really am hoping these next three episodes end the track in a positive way with Samaina's reunion.

In conclusion, for me the negatives outweighed the positives in this track. Am really glad it's finally over, and am looking forward to the new track, regardless.

I think I rambled way too much here, sorry if I was all over the place. 😆

Originally posted by: Avan_s

I simply loved your post. Thanks for cheering us up. It is really very beautifully written.

Originally posted by: danshula

So according to the new spoiler on last day of school.. seems like hiding from Naina thing doesn't get resolved till he comes to Ahemdabad? Or what I made out from him running away from Naina on last day of school on SBS. But its deffo getting resolved soon and in this week itself I think (going by the weekly trend of theirs) & what I perhaps understood still stands true.. its still gonna result in their Milan. Am looking forward to how now. Very curious what CVs have planned since we don't have much episodes left of Delhi.

I also don't get how 92 leap happens if unlucky thing sticks with Sameer. Would he not distance himself from Maa too?

Ah! This week is gonna be interesting. Am still positive.

But he was shown happy coming back to PVKM in first shot of the segment lol. So maybe he was just running as he came back to Ahemdabad as giving a surprise to her. Lets seee!!

Added this part in my original post as well.