Raising questions as Viewers of YHM to Child actor's Parents. - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

131

Views

12.9k

Users

37

Likes

291

Frequent Posters

victo thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Yes I accept the fact adi's character is full of negative but if it doesn't affect his real life then doing the same there is no harm in it. If we see as only acting and not real then there is no problem in it.
mayu1982 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
Then Gautam bashing is justified in some way if he is too matured to understand his character/making fun of his character ?Means he understand difference b/w real and reel . Then he is responsible like Divs /KP / like any actor who is showing/doing character which gives any wrong/negative vibes/ message to society?

Then we should consider it as Gautam is kid and he should not be bashed?

Adi character is not giving good message to the society rather it is showing how kids can be so evil that they can harm himself to take revenge.
Edited by mayu1982 - 10 years ago
mayu1982 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: victo

Yes I accept the fact adi's character is full of negative but if it doesn't affect his real life then doing the same there is no harm in it. If we see as only acting and not real then there is no problem in it.


I am not saying we should question him only when it is affecting him?
Rather am saying why their parents are allowing him to do this? Definitely it is not pleasant feeling to show your kid doing such type of role/
Atleast for me, as mother never encourage my kid to do such type of heinous thing..

Adi character is psycho kid who harm himself to take revenge from adult. His role is like psycho criminal kid, even ashok/param role is better than him..

I am against of this role and not of CV/writer to write such degrading role for any kid.Against of his parents( don't care whether gautam is effect or not) for allowing his kid to do this type of role who is sending wrong message to the society..
serious thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
nice post Mayu 👏

just stating...
playing a negative character by a kid is quite challenging, its the reason we don't get to see many kids adorning the roles of a negative character in any of these 4 mainstream channels (ignore the kid specific shows). I feel this is the reason, Gautam has been let off playing Aadi character even with his poor acting skills for quite a long time, they might haven't got kids to replace him 🤔
1024659 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
I agree with you. Nice post.
mayu1982 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: serious

nice post Mayu 👏

just stating...
playing a negative character by a kid is quite challenging, its the reason we don't get to see many kids adorning the roles of a negative character in any of these 4 mainstream channels (ignore the kid specific shows). I feel this is the reason, Gautam has been let off playing Aadi character even with his poor acting skills for quite a long time, they might haven't got kids to replace him 🤔


Thanks 😊
But what is the need to write such degrading thing for this character?
I am fine with shagun doing planning and plotting and doing devilish act to Ishita character but Adi harming himself to take revenge from Ishita is bit tooo much..

Am against of writer to writing such degrading thing for so called 12 yrd old kid character..
mayu1982 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: StunningS

I agree with you. Nice post.


OMG you agree with me😳
Edited by mayu1982 - 10 years ago
victo thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: mayu1982



<font color="#990000">I am not saying we should question him only when it is affecting him?</font>
<font color="#990000">Rather am saying why their parents are allowing him to do this? Definitely it is not pleasant feeling to show your kid doing such type of role/</font>
<font color="#990000">Atleast for me, as mother never encourage my kid to do such type of heinous thing..</font>

<font color="#990000">Adi character is psycho kid who harm himself to take revenge from adult. His role is like psycho criminal kid, even ashok/param role is better than him..</font>
<font color="#990000">
</font>
<font color="#990000">I am against of this role and not of CV/writer to write such degrading role for any kid.Against of his parents( don't care whether gautam is effect or not) for allowing his kid to do this type of role who is sending wrong message to the society..</font>



Society need to know what is good and for that a person need to know what is bad.then only they can differentiate it. With only positive things are shown then how can we come to what is wrong in it. The world is full of rights and wrong and the person who live in it has to identify the correct thing for which we has to know what is wrong
mayu1982 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: always_a_TV_fan


Oye Mayu... tum sorry kyon bol rahi ho yaar ???😲 you havent said anything rudely or offended me in any way... come on...please. 🤗

LIke button ka aur mera purana story hai... 90% of times main bhool jaati hoon. is chakkar mein joote bhi khaaye hain maine 😆 I did hit the Like button now 😳


coming back to your comment

see what I am saying is, Gautam seems to be taking it better than the most. I do know playing negative characters makes people sad/angry in real life. and that is just a kid. But my point is, he seems to be taking it in his stride, and I do admire his personality for that. I live in a society where kid actors are so into their roles, where even their interviews seem rehearsed, and they seem to live what they play on screen.

But like I said, since I have no experience/expertise, I cannot support/disagree with a generalised statement that kids should not be allowed to play negative roles... & I think you did not get the most important part of my comment.😳

while you are focussing on Gautam because the Adi character is negative, I am saying, you should focus more on a YOUNGER child being made to hear/say things that are clearly 15 years ahead of her age. I think I didnt make it clear.

Gautam ko negative role karna chaahiye ki nahin, (i am not saying he should, or if his parents are right). I just commented saying he seems to be smart enough to know the difference.

I am saying you should be more outraged by Ruhi's portrayal, she is what 6 years old ? and they are making her say things like Baanjh, they are making her participate in a love letter reading between her parents, they have given her dialogues that are borderline-lecturing... if she is saying all of them by memorising and not understanding a word, it may be OK. but dont you think she may go back home and ask her mother some very difficult questions ???

about the tweets - that has nothing to do with this post as far as I know. Ruhi's account is managed by her mother, and she made comments on people not liking Gautam's acting (not Adi's character). That's the message I got from it.


done... i think that's all i wanted to say 😳


@ Lucky : heheh Revenge time..

OK got it Gautam is matured enough to understand between real and reel 👏👏

Hatss off to his parents - don't know how they manage to explain him👏👏.. Main toh apne baccho ko fight maat karo - mein bhi struggle karti hoon..😆

Then if as viewers am asking questions to Divs how can she can even justify her such stupid role?

Then gautam is also answerable for his degrading/pathetic character.

In fact my main question - why his parents allowed him to do this kind of role? even if they are fine with their son doing this role, why they are not opposing with cv/writer/mgmt writing such violent stuff for this character.

Already some much violence in real world, it is disgusting to see 12 yr old fictional kid doing such abnormal thing on screen.🤢

I am against of writer, cv/mgmt to writing such stuff for kid character and parents to allowing his kid to do this stuff. It is painful for me atleast for me to watch ( if not for anyone)

Now
Ruhi character was good initially more like a kid , it was butchered after mani's entry only.😃

But even for ruhi - i raised my voice it is not that i am not asking questions for ruhi character.

I agree that I am more concerned for violence /negative character ( Adi) than positive character ( Ruhi)








mayu1982 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: victo



Society need to know what is good and for that a person need to know what is bad.then only they can differentiate it. With only positive things are shown then how can we come to what is wrong in it. The world is full of rights and wrong and the person who live in it has to identify the correct thing for which we has to know what is wrong


@ Bold: No need to show kid with so much negative thing..And you mean to say that even kids are categorised as wrong and right.😕Omg psycho kids percentage is very less as compared to normal kids. Psycho kid usually becomes psycho becomes of some extreme condition and not because of divorce.

Wrong As a mother I am strictly against of showing such psycho kid.
No need to show realistic thing only with a kid.

Kids taking revenge - is a sick concept with so much extreme violence .A kid because of the divorce of the parents , took such such extreme steps to take revenge from step son🤢 How logical it is?

If they want to show realistic thing then why can't they show lead character more realistic than a psycho realistic kid.🤢


Edited by mayu1982 - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: ChanChanMan · 4 years ago

I dare you to post a thing about anyone other than DivAn.

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: --PriyaRay-- · 1 years ago

This is gonna be a fun thread! Do you know, YHM -as popular as ever- is full of symbolisms - gesture, expressions, dialogues, scenes even...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan · 9 months ago

Anita Hassanandani Says She Was Always Offered Negative Roles During Her 5 Year Hiatus Due to Yeh Hai Mohabbatein's Massive Success! In a new...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: TheStranger · 2 years ago

Divyanka Tripathi Estimated net worth is around 37 crore Property: apartment in Mumbai, house in Bhopal Cars: Mercedes Benz E- class sedan 75...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: Aditi_X · 5 years ago

My retelling of the iconic show Yeh Hai Mohabbatein. Four separate souls -- Raman, Ishita, Ruhi, and Adi -- in four separate cities But somehow...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".