Chinese plagiarism hurt ARR page 14 - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

132

Views

10.6k

Users

25

Frequent Posters

HalleNJ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
Indradhanush, your points are valid and so true.......but in todays entertainment business, majority (audience) just look at the output, not many go into detail like you......if the song is good, they give a thumbs up and vice versa. I was suprised to read some comments here saying Jab We Met should be awarded for best music despite knowing that the songs were 'inspired' by some other asian songs. You see most people don't bother about how the music is created, they just want to hear good music.....I think nothing wrong in using software or editing (I mean the assembling the bits and pieces as you mention above), they are just utilising the latest technology to do their work.......and singers are the ones benefiting from it..........
Edited by niruba - 17 years ago
Indradhanush thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
@niruba

Will have to agree with you. Actually the output is what matters. I have heard A R Rehman has software which brings out the best tonal quality of a singer eg Shankar Mahadevan said in an interview he was surprised to hear urvasi urvasi when it came out, it was sounding very different than what he sings.
Similarily Asha ji marked that yai reyai re was not in the track she had recorded, as far as this doesn't distort the original singing or applied vocorder etc to correct sur this is justified.
It is now not practical to talk of a giant 100 piece orchestra for the reason instrumentalists are themself busy and working at various places.
Indradhanush thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago

Chinese plagiarism hurts Rahman

.fullpost{display:inline;}

Gone are the days when Indian musicians composed music albums drawing inspiration from other sources. It's time now for us to share the limelight. Not so long ago, lovers of international music would come up with the name of the original version as soon as they heard an Indian film song; and this is not confined to Tamil songs alone. Now it is the other way round.

With the advent of the internet and the likes of Rahman at the helm of Indian music, it has been ensured that their tunes reach far and wide. This deserves special mention as it has not only spread our music across the continents but has even created awareness about Indian music in general. On the flip side, it has also ended up as 'inspiration' for other music composers. This is true in China where popular Taiwanese singer Kelly Poon has recorded Rahman's 'Shakalaka Baby' in her latest album, in Mandarin. Yao Chien, the composer and producer of the album claims his company, Ursa Major, has sought permission from Universal music, which takes care of the copyrights for Rahman's works. Kelly Poon on the other hand had stated that if she were to take the legal route to obtain the rights for the tune, it would have been tough to release the album. She added: "As it is a popular Indian song, I am just adapting the song and introducing it in China." Kelly might have her intentions right; just that the law happens to take a different view. Kelly Poon was a Project Superstar Champion 2005, a reality competition for singers across China, which is similar to the Indian TV show, Super Singer. This number especially has catapulted her to the status of singing sensation among the Chinese. So much for what was not hers! As for Rahman, he wasn't available for any comments. Guess success comes with its share of problems.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".