{| SPK: Episode Discussion thread #2 |} - Page 12

Poll

Who do you think has been least butchered by this serial so far?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

84.5k

Users

32

Likes

2k

Frequent Posters

amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Probably they will show her later with Abhimanyu...

I am just curious...where is Vrushali?
Has Karna forgotten that he is married? Where is Supriya?

Or will we see nine sons popping out of nowhere in the war- Vrishasena n eight more senas(if I am not wrong) just like we saw five Uppandavas on Star Plus?
Edited by amritat - 9 years ago
aanvi98 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: amritat

Finally watched the episode...the full episode n I am 🤣

I am practically clapping when Sony Draupadi called Sony Duryodhan Pot-putra...😈
From wat I see Sony Draupadi is nice but if somebody pinches her...she knows how to pinch back...
Now that is a Draupadi I would die for...😉

I hated the unnecessary arrogance in Star Plus' portrayal but this one is tit for tat.
Even the Andha Ka Putra Andha was an outcome of Duryodhan's taunt...👏

I actually felt bad for epic Duryodhan...He is butchered like anything everywhere...
Atleast in this part in the epic...he had done nothing wrong n here too they added his parentage insult to justify BR Chopra's invention Andha Ka Putra Andha...Poor epic Duryodhan!!
He gets butchered everywhere...

Nonetheless...now I am loving Pankhuri...n Saurav's serious portrayal has won my heart.

However...wat I just cannot digest is this Govind-Karna scenes n Karna's undying love for Govind.
CVs...just spare us the horror...

Granted they respected each other but this fake friendship is bothering me. And Karna started crying bcoz Shishupal insulted Govind!!
CVs...just spare us the horror...

And the ever-righteous Karna is really bothering...Teary-eyed...over-righteous...over-chivalrous...impressing Panchali with his chivalry every now n then...draped by Kanchivaram sari...n always screaming on top of his voice...CVs...now just stop fooling us.
Gautam Rode is a great actor n his talent is getting wasted...
I am so missing Aham Sharma's dignified portrayal...n his silent killer looks n subtle smirk.

We all know Karna was great...but then show his real greatness with his charity...his prowess as a warrior...his dilemmas...his loyalty...n not this Go-Ka amar prem gatha n Karna jumping in at EVERY wrong deed as the knight in shining armour...like he with Lakshagriha n now with Shishupal.

This is called butchering gloriously...courtesy Krishnaa_Nair...😉





REALLY DI, THEN IT IS A MUST TO WATCH... i jus don't wanna talk abt tht ka-kri angle...🤢🤢 just made my parav apart and made arjun stand lyk a dummy doll... gawd man com'n give sum action!! Drau here is not main!! If sumone would hv been in her place then it should be arjun!!! God we were okay with cashew nuts... nd ab kaju badam se pura badam bana dia inn logo ne... 🤢🤢

Nd di, as anu said, what if there's ny karna VH??😉😉 u know, all perfect... a kanchavaram saree!!!

nd seriously the most flop show of the year should be SPK...

Nd tht karna 'glorious butchering'... such glorious butchering tht karna must hv been cursing kalyugis frm heaven...😆 firstly movie on karan-arjun, then such high pitch voice nd always in daily soap rona dhona mode...😆 bta nhi iss janm mein hume vijaya darshan phir kabhi milega ya nhi... nd include gavinda also...
aanvi98 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: amritat


Probably they will show her later with Abhimanyu...

I am just curious...where is Vrushali?
Has Karna forgotten that he is married? Where is Supriya?

Or will we see nine sons popping out of nowhere in the war- Vrishasena n eight more senas(if I am not wrong) just like we saw five Uppandavas on Star Plus?

we may see the nine sons popping out of fire just like their father's new buddy😆 nd the buddy doing their yagya...😆
amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
It is possible.
In this show Karna n Draupadi have an underlying friendship...

Like Jamy said...Sony Draupadi looks at Sony Karna with pride n admiration everytime he says 'Stri ka samman'...n Sony Karna, though he says he wont forgive her, ran after Shishupal to save her honour n even gave 'Stri Ka Maan' dialogues fifty times...

So yeah...Sony Karna n Sony Draupadi have a chance of being bosom friends...
Who knows... Govind might tell Ka to save Draupadi's honour on his behalf...
Anyway Sony Karna wears a Kanchipuram sari himself...he can take it off n give it to her...
And then give everyone a lecture on 'Stree Ka Samman'...😉
And instead of Arjun, Govind might decide to give Bhagavad Gita Gyan to two new shishyas...Sakha-Sakhi...aka chivalrous Sony Karna n Tit-for-Tat Sony Draupadi...

Poor Sony Arjun will stand in background like he is doing now. 😭
Edited by amritat - 9 years ago
Ramya_98 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: amritat

Yes...most of the facts u mentioned are right.
In KMG...clearly Kunti was worried about her sons n all that...
However if one reads the previous chapters the motives are clear.

In Southern Recension Karna fails to hit the target...

I think all previous birth stories are later additions to justify the situations.
In fact I feel all curses n boons are always added later to justify something or the other.
But this is strictly my opinion.

And speaking of the promise they had made in Ekachakra...was it for life or just for Ekachakra?
Coz if they did vow to share everything for life...then Subhadra, Chitrangada, Valandhara, Vijaya n Karenumati should also have been shared right?
So I am slightly confused about the sharing vow...
Could u pls provide citations?

And finally...I think there is a misunderstanding with my words here.
Bcoz...I did not say Kunti wanted Draupadi for her eldest bcoz eldest should marry first.
I meant Kunti wanted Draupadi for her eldest bcoz the eldest is the HEIR to the throne.
So if a powerful kingdom like Panchal has matrimonial alliance with the HEIR...then it's an advantage.

I am well aware that Bhima n Hidimba were already together.

In fact this is the part which confuses me. Arjun clearly says that 'If I marry before Yudisthir I will incur sin.'
Why did he say that?
Clearly Bhima was married to Hidimba...so y did Arjun find it a sin to marry ?

It is bcoz of all this...that I think it was preplanned n ALL Pandavas n Kunti knew it.
Maybe the Panchalas also had an idea. Nobody was innocent here.


Yes agreed that kunti had political motives and so maybe she was not that innocent. Can't say because i still have a mixed opinion.
Sorry ,but if you don't agree to all the previous birth stories and the boon stories, probably you must not even agree to the origin and existence of the pandavas and kauravas because both of their births were driven by boons and boons alone that were bestowed upon the mothers. Duravasa's boon to mother kunti and ved vyasa's to gandhari. (Sorry,if i sounded a bit rude😛)
I think the vow was confined to life in ekchakra. I cannot provide any proofs now.I am still not sure about this one.
'Incur sin' in the sense that he doesn't abide by his vow of the sharing thing. In the epic yudhishtira asks arjuna to wed drau first because he was the one who won her but he refuses saying that he should wed her first because that was what their code of conduct said and the eldest should marry her first because vyasa had already told them she was to be the wife of them all and now even kunti had said the same.
In SPK they showed yudi saying that mother's words are supreme and must be kept,come what may. But in the original MB kunti herself asks yudi how her words can be kept even as drau is saved from any dilemmas. Correct me if i am wrong but the original vyasa's mahabharat does talk of vyasa coming to visit them and he telling them about shiva's boon and all of them marrying her. Am i right?
Ramya_98 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: amritat

It is possible.

In this show Karna n Draupadi have an underlying friendship...

Like Jamy said...Sony Draupadi looks at Sony Karna with pride n admiration everytime he says 'Stri ka samman'...n Sony Karna, though he says he wont forgive her, ran after Shishupal to save her honour n even gave 'Stri Ka Maan' dialogues fifty times...

So yeah...Sony Karna n Sony Draupadi have a chance of being bosom friends...
Who knows... Govind might tell Ka to save Draupadi's honour on his behalf...
Anyway Sony Karna wears a Kanchipuram sari himself...he can take it off n give it to her...
And then give everyone a lecture on 'Stree Ka Samman'...😉
And instead of Arjun, Govind might decide to give Bhagavad Gita Gyan to two new shishyas...Sakha-Sakhi...aka chivalrous Sony Karna n Tit-for-Tat Sony Draupadi...

Poor Sony Arjun will stand in background like he is doing now. 😭


Everything is possible and fair in love and war! In this case, the undying love of sony karna and sony krishna and the war is of course kurukshetra!😛😆😉
KURT15 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
@amrita, spk Duri wears so much Kajal coz SpK Gandhari does not need Kajal and her portion is going waste. 😆
@parav lovers, be grateful that that horrible SpK Kri is nowhere near Navi!! His looks at SPKarna looks downright lecherous and SPKarna's looking at him looks equally indecent. I am glad Navi is spared the ordeal of casting adoring looks at this Kri! 😆
I would do just about anything to take this Kri's attention off Ka!! 😆 😆
amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: ramya06


Yes agreed that kunti had political motives and so maybe she was not that innocent. Can't say because i still have a mixed opinion.
Sorry ,but if you don't agree to all the previous birth stories and the boon stories, probably you must not even agree to the origin and existence of the pandavas and kauravas because both of their births were driven by boons and boons alone that were bestowed upon the mothers. Duravasa's boon to mother kunti and ved vyasa's to gandhari. (Sorry,if i sounded a bit rude😛)
I think the vow was confined to life in ekchakra. I cannot provide any proofs now.I am still not sure about this one.
'Incur sin' in the sense that he doesn't abide by his vow of the sharing thing. In the epic yudhishtira asks arjuna to wed drau first because he was the one who won her but he refuses saying that he should wed her first because that was what their code of conduct said and the eldest should marry her first because vyasa had already told them she was to be the wife of them all and now even kunti had said the same.
In SPK they showed yudi saying that mother's words are supreme and must be kept,come what may. But in the original MB kunti herself asks yudi how her words can be kept even as drau is saved from any dilemmas. Correct me if i am wrong but the original vyasa's mahabharat does talk of vyasa coming to visit them and he telling them about shiva's boon and all of them marrying her. Am i right?


Ur right...I dont believe in those supernatural births but that is irrelevant here.
Actually...there is slight discrepancy between wat is given in KMG n CE about wat Arjun says regarding sharing.

Yeah Vyasa tells a lot of stuff...but here my point is different.
Wat I believe is...Vyasa assured them that she will be won...
So...in a way, they all knew the outcome of the contest n wat would consequently follow. That is wat I suggested.
And if possible then lets discuss in AT coz I dont want to ruin the fun in this thread...


Ramya_98 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: KURT15

@amrita, spk Duri wears so much Kajal coz SpK Gandhari does not need Kajal and her portion is going waste. 😆
@parav lovers, be grateful that that horrible SpK Kri is nowhere near Navi!! His looks at SPKarna looks downright lecherous and SPKarna's looking at him looks equally indecent. I am glad Navi is spared the ordeal of casting adoring looks at this Kri! 😆
I would do just about anything to take this Kri's attention off Ka!! 😆 😆


Maybe you are right about sony parav. 😆
I want to see srj and navi together as parav. I think they would be perfect. 😳
amritat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Actually Kunti too is glorified here...I mean she is shown completely innocent n least butchered...😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".