YRKKH Banner Contest Issue - Page 5

Originally posted by: vijay

Well it was done this way cause when we resize the whole banner that small.. you wont be able to see much of the characters.

And neither we want that we have a system where the banner maker have to create multiple version of the banner.

The same thing is followed by Youtube Channel banners also. Where you upload one banner and based on the device screen size it crops. So one have to plan the banner in a way where we keep the most important part in the centre so that it does not gets cropped in smaller devices.

I am certain that the Moderators will find an amicable solution to the issue.

@bold Thanks for validating our concern.

This is the whole point that was being raised in our posts that the banner isn't representing the characters rightfully. And center stage has just been dedicated to two characters, while rest all are pushed to the sides, which is a totally unfair representation of the show's narrative.

Sorry if I've disturbed you. Saw your post and found it an apt clarification for the original intent of our complaints (since the whole topic got deviated by a bunch of people).

I have faith in mods to resolve this issue.

Originally posted by: vijay

Well it was done this way cause when we resize the whole banner that small.. you wont be able to see much of the characters.

And neither we want that we have a system where the banner maker have to create multiple version of the banner.

The same thing is followed by Youtube Channel banners also. Where you upload one banner and based on the device screen size it crops. So one have to plan the banner in a way where we keep the most important part in the centre so that it does not gets cropped in smaller devices.

I am certain that the Moderators will find an amicable solution to the issue.

Originally posted by: R.G.C

Yeah, I don’t think all of it was about the banner alone, so its not just the technical team to support in there. Its also about people getting free pass to mock others.

About the banner, I do understand its not a possibility to shrink the same such that its hardly visible. So the other part of the concern where the rules should be more clear and winners be decided based on those rules, not sure whom to address those concerns to, such that these concerns are taken into account for a better and more fair competition next time.

..... Deleted

Originally posted by: vijay

Well it was done this way cause when we resize the whole banner that small.. you wont be able to see much of the characters.

And neither we want that we have a system where the banner maker have to create multiple version of the banner.

The same thing is followed by Youtube Channel banners also. Where you upload one banner and based on the device screen size it crops. So one have to plan the banner in a way where we keep the most important part in the centre so that it does not gets cropped in smaller devices.

I am certain that the Moderators will find an amicable solution to the issue.

Aah. FINALLY. The highest authority speaks and clears things for us. So a banner should be made as such that the most important part which I presume are the leads of a show [ALL LEADS] are visible regardless of the device screen size.

Yes, now that you've made things crystal clear : how a banner should be, am sure the Mods will have to.

Originally posted by: vijay

Well it was done this way cause when we resize the whole banner that small.. you wont be able to see much of the characters.

And neither we want that we have a system where the banner maker have to create multiple version of the banner.

The same thing is followed by Youtube Channel banners also. Where you upload one banner and based on the device screen size it crops. So one have to plan the banner in a way where we keep the most important part in the centre so that it does not gets cropped in smaller devices.

I am certain that the Moderators will find an amicable solution to the issue.

@BOLD:

Why can’t the Winner be told to make multiple versions of their banner? 😕

Originally posted by: OnTheBlock

Aah. FINALLY. The highest authority speaks and clears things for us. So a banner should be made as such that the most important part which I presume are the leads of a show [ALL LEADS] are visible regardless of the device screen size.

Yes, now that you've made things crystal clear : how a banner should be, am sure the Mods will have to.

Having leads in the center was already part of the rules. And mods haven’t deviated from it. The main point of contention for the banner dispute is who are considered as the main leads of the show and this is no hidden fact that everyone has a different opinion on it. Hence we saw different banners having different characters in the center.

I wasn’t around for last banner contest or upload so I have no info what transpired then, but when you look at the previous banner, Arohi wasn’t in the center even though story revolved around three of them for a while.

Originally posted by: Chaitu.V

Looks like the rules are only meant for us!

Who ever replied here about BC were very polite and up to the point ! No one is against the winner or the banner! Really appreciate the efforts put by all makers !

But here I failed to understand how it is fair for other banner makers who put the same efforts n hard work in making ,just because a few ppl cheated and the actual show Viewers and contributors did not get a chance to vote and select their banners which r representing the present story line ? It is also unfair with the regular visitors and contributes of Yrkkh forum who cannot select the banner for the show they r watching regularly just because the rules were not stipulated before and foul play by some ?

But here others opinions n concerns are indirectly and also openly being bullied and mocked which is clearly violating the coc rules ,it’s been more than half day still no action being taken proves how this forum is actually working and backing one section!

Anyway who really cares who is beside Ak in the banner when Abhinav is beside Ak in the show😆! They r a couple ,so keeping someone else beside Ak doesn’t change the storyline unless the makers wanted to ,so that’s ok!

We're trying to be fair to all. But by being fair to all, sometimes some people will feel it is unfair. At the end of the day that happens in every area. I know it sucks for those who wanted to vote fairly, but our style of BC voting is clear and direct. In the past we would completely close out voting and do it with mods only. At least here a group of people who just looked at aesthetics and nothing else voted and they were regular members, not mods only. I feel like that should count for something.

I will say that the team of mods in YRK forum are doing the best they can in keeping the forum clean. There's a lot going on and the mods need to work with reports so it does take time but they are doing the best they can. All I can say is keep reporting and if at any time you feel that the mods are not doing enough, then come to me in PM and I will do what I can.

Thank you for creating space for members to voice their issues in civil manner

Originally posted by: NomadicWonders

Having leads in the center was already part of the rules. And mods haven’t deviated from it. The main point of contention for the banner dispute is who are considered as the main leads of the show and this is no hidden fact that everyone has a different opinion on it. Hence we saw different banners having different characters in the center.

I wasn’t around for last banner contest or upload so I have no info what transpired then, but when you look at the previous banner, Arohi wasn’t in the center even though story revolved around three of them for a while.

Was that really the issue the whole time.. Cause that could be easily solved though. Facts dont care about feelings and personal opinions. The showrunner Ranjan Shahi has talked about 3 MAIN LEADS when he gave that interview about how the show would have shut down if not for the leap since they didnt have mass reach. Boom. Done.

Arohi wasnt centre but she should have been,atleast in the early days. But clearly she didnt have half the forum as her fans. She was also negative which changes things on ITV. There's hero,heroine and villain. A demarcation. Here there are two heroes and one heroine. Things are definitely different.

Originally posted by: NomadicWonders

Having leads in the center was already part of the rules. And mods haven’t deviated from it. The main point of contention for the banner dispute is who are considered as the main leads of the show and this is no hidden fact that everyone has a different opinion on it. Hence we saw different banners having different characters in the center.

I wasn’t around for last banner contest or upload so I have no info what transpired then, but when you look at the previous banner, Arohi wasn’t in the center even though story revolved around three of them for a while.

@bold Pal it doesn't matter who has what opinion!!

I can believe in and wish for 10 things and you can believe in and wish for another 10 things... That's not the pt. of contention here..

THE POINT IS WHAT'S SHOWN IN THE SHOW!

This is the current montage of the show under discussion on National TV.

There are 4 people here & in the next one there's Abhir too... so as per show's narrative these characters are leads/ protagonists whatever one likes to call them.. and all 5 deserve to occupy the central stage on any forum banner.

I too wasn't here before.. so don't know why Arohi wasn't included in the previous banner... Maybe because the banner won through the votes of forum members or Maybe because people didn't raise their voice..

But here clearly many are voicing themselves regarding the unfair representation & we haven't got our say in the banner selection.. Therefore, the issue needs it needs to be addressed this time.