YRKKH Banner Contest Issue - Page 7

Originally posted by: OnTheBlock

Was that really the issue the whole time.. Cause that could be easily solved though. Facts dont care about feelings and personal opinions. The showrunner Ranjan Shahi has talked about 3 MAIN LEADS when he gave that interview about how the show would have shut down if not for the leap since they didnt have mass reach. Boom. Done.

Arohi wasnt centre but she should have been,atleast in the early days. But clearly she didnt have half the forum as her fans. She was also negative which changes things on ITV. There's hero,heroine and villain. A demarcation. Here there are two heroes and one heroine. Things are definitely different.

I haven’t seen the interview, but I have seen a thread on here talking about 3 main leads and it was disputed as coming from non-reliable media sources. So no, based on that, I don’t think it is a done deal and no hence it is not a fact. It is social media news!

Also having supporters on forum or not should not dictate if a certain character is main lead or not of the show.

Having said that, I do however believe that banner is for this particular site, and should take into account the view of all forum members. But also that banner contest rules and actual banners were up for quite a while on the site. All the discussions/objections happening now should have happened then to arrive at appropriate resolution!

That was the time Mods could have done something about it. May be updated the rules to specify name of the characters they wanted in center either based on a poll or their veto power! That would have been fair but trying to change it now is not!

Tagging verve as reply to your post as both would have been the same.

In addition, I would just like to point out that even though Arohi is on the montage but she was recently given the award for supporting actress, not a lead. Hence the same applies for Abhinav. However Akshara and Abhimanyu are constantly being nominated and awarded for best jodi awards!! So considering both conveys a very different picture. However see last 2 paras above.

If u guys want example about inclusivity of main lead or parallel leads in banners then look at ghkkpm forum…even though satya adikari character is of few months..they included him in centerstage because of storyline….their mods or fans r not like this and saying we will have competition again after 3 months….why they a fair competition with inclusivity not us

Originally posted by: MinionBoss

We have spoken about it and we have come to a conclusion that we can't be unfair to the current makers and the winner. But we also can't be unfair to everyone here who pointed out valid issues with the BC.

We will hold a new BC in 3 months and we will ensure that there are better rules for making the banner. But we ask that you all don't hold off with your complaints or problems until the end. It takes away from the winner. Instead if you have a concern or complaint, raise it in PM to me directly immediately.

Thanks.

How are you being unfair to the current makers. Can you please clarify.

Originally posted by: MinionBoss

We have spoken about it and we have come to a conclusion that we can't be unfair to the current makers and the winner. But we also can't be unfair to everyone here who pointed out valid issues with the BC.

We will hold a new BC in 3 months and we will ensure that there are better rules for making the banner. But we ask that you all don't hold off with your complaints or problems until the end. It takes away from the winner. Instead if you have a concern or complaint, raise it in PM to me directly immediately.

Thanks.

No offence MinionBoss, what if Abhinav exits from the show in that time period? Who can take that guarantee. What will be the point then,who will the banner makers put on the banner? And half the forum will exit. Nobody will watch the show from the other half without him.

Am baffled.. that for the mistakes of the banner contest organizers, you are denying half the fandom their side of representaion. This is completely and utterly unfair. They are literally here cause of Abhinav,their male lead. How can you completely other and not take into consideration their concern.. especially when they waited for 6 months to have this?

Also Vijay clearly said banners should be such that important part takes centrestage. So clearly this aint the ideal banner.

We dont want to diminish the effort taken by winner but how is that overriding the misrepresentation of the show and exclusion of the Male lead for whom the other part of the forum exists... all cause of someone else's mistakes. How is this the solution.

Originally posted by: MinionBoss

We have spoken about it and we have come to a conclusion that we can't be unfair to the current makers and the winner. But we also can't be unfair to everyone here who pointed out valid issues with the BC.

We will hold a new BC in 3 months and we will ensure that there are better rules for making the banner. But we ask that you all don't hold off with your complaints or problems until the end. It takes away from the winner. Instead if you have a concern or complaint, raise it in PM to me directly immediately.

Thanks.

Hi Minion,

Our faith in PMing mods have been shaken to some extent. But our fellow members had raised this via PM in the past and were given different idea about fairness. Based on our observations so far, we believe that questioning mods and contest publicly is more effective than PMing. Nothing against any mods or you, but at this point we are accused of not raising it earlier which isn't true- albeit that was via PM.

We do not know which foul play was reported and there are claimed evidence for but sincerely hope it wasn't for the banner that won.

Thanks.

Originally posted by: NomadicWonders

I haven’t seen the interview, but I have seen a thread on here talking about 3 main leads and it was disputed as coming from non-reliable media sources. So no, based on that, I don’t think it is a done deal and no hence it is not a fact. It is social media news!

Also having supporters on forum or not should not dictate if a certain character is main lead or not of the show.

Having said that, I do however believe that banner is for this particular site, and should take into account the view of all forum members. But also that banner contest rules and actual banners were up for quite a while on the site. All the discussions/objections happening now should have happened then to arrive at appropriate resolution!

That was the time Mods could have done something about it. May be updated the rules to specify name of the characters they wanted in center either based on a poll or their veto power! That would have been fair but trying to change it now is not!

Non reliable media? He literally shared it on instagram lol 😆 Even credible gossipTV shared the article. I think it was a Bollylife one.

Actually it does affect things.. I mean if we werent here for Abhinav, lots of banners would get a free pass to project him as a sidey,which he aint.

What matters are the facts. The content of the banner denies a male lead centrestage. Thats all.

Originally posted by: OnTheBlock

No offence MinionBoss, what if Abhinav exits from the show in that time period? Who can take that guarantee. What will be the point then,who will the banner makers put on the banner? And half the forum will exit. Nobody will watch the show from the other half without him.

Am baffled.. that for the mistakes of the banner contest organizers, you are denying half the fandom their side of representaion. This is completely and utterly unfair. They are literally here cause of Abhinav,their male lead. How can you completely other and not take into consideration their concern.. especially when they waited for 6 months to have this?

Also Vijay clearly said banners should be such that important part takes centrestage. So clearly this aint the ideal banner.

We dont want to diminish the effort taken by winner but how is that overriding the misrepresentation of the show and exclusion of the Male lead for whom the other part of the forum exists... all cause of someone else's mistakes. How is this the solution.

Rajan Shahi, a producer of #1 and #2 ITV show won't give interview to tabloids If he had to give an interview, he would give it to a reputable news channel. News channels would be lining up to get a single byte from him, he doesn't have to rely on some online articles for interview.

These are PR articles written to create buzz for clients, if there's a video of Rajan saying that then we'll accept it otherwise I can pay TC to write an article saying "NoraSM is the writer of YRKKH" 😆

Let's state facts, If he was lead he would have been tagged by the channel on their social media posts but they don't tag him because he is not a lead. They tag Karishma Sawant but not him

Harshad and Pranali win Best Jodi awards even after 5 months of leap and Rajan sends them to these award shows together, when did he send Pranali with Jay?

Karishma Sawant won award in supporting categories because she is parallel lead and even on Star Plus montage Harshad and Pranali are in the front, the other montage has Abhimanyu and Akshara with Abhir.

And if really cared about "Inclusiveness" then they wouldn't be voting for banner #19 which doesn't have Karishma Sawant in the center.

Originally posted by: PeacefulLove

How are you being unfair to the current makers. Can you please clarify.

The current makers made banners based on the rules we provided them. We can't just cancel a BC because they followed rules. That would make them feel like their creativity isn't appreciated. Same with the current winner. She made a banner after a lot of hard work and should be appreciated for it.

Originally posted by: mickeym

if he is going to exit before 3 months , then y u need to keep him in the banner for 3 months ...😆 .. we dont need to keep a cameo i guess ... and if he desnt exit before 3 months , we can think about the contest again ... 😊that time ... not now

what if abhim exits in 3 months….then y him in new banner? Even that is possible but we r asking inclusively to everyone….like i said in previous comments in ghkkpm forum they included satya even if he is cameo not like abhinav currently one of main lead….