pigbelly4myfeet thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Is it just me who wasn't that impressed with the IS scenes today? 🤔

I just felt something missing...I guess I was expecting more.

It didn't even really make me laugh....:S. I was kind of expecting a more poignant scene I guess.

Cuz yesterday we saw how much Suhana was affected by RB's story. It was kind of like a turning point for in a way too. She was kind of reflecting back on her own life and how she perceived her own life.

You know what I mean?? There was just food for SO much thought and development with this phase. And Ishaan could've played such a big role in that!!!

I mean right now, I am actually thinking ki what exactly is the point of Ishaan in Suhana's life!! You know? Like really, how does he matter to her at all??

I really think even Inder, Elesh or someone could've cheered up Suhana just as well no? And if it was about cheering her up, spending some moments with the family or something would've helped Suhana get cheered up too no?

What I was expecting Ishaan to do, was kind of get through to Suhana in some way. I wanted to see a poignant scene between them damn it!! They really could've had a good heart to heart or something about this nahin? I would've SOO loved to see some development in their characters, in their RELATIONSHIP which seriously needs a push right now!

If this was just a random sa scene I wouldn't have minded so much. But the fact that it was an aftermath of such a great track, i.e. RB and Deepak's and had SO much scope makes me kind of not satisfied.

And really, how long has it been since we saw a really poignant IS scene? Remember their past scenes and when they initially got married? Remember how Ishaan used to get through to Suhana SO well? Like you could SEE the importance he would hold in her life!

But right now it feels more like he's a clown than someone really special in Suhana's life!

I feel like Jai's acting too is kind of getting annoying for me. I don't know...something's missing for sure.

I want a better characterization of Ishaan like seriously! And I REALLY want to see him hold a special place for Suhana now, cuz frankly right now I'm so not convinced.

Thoughts? Does anyone else feel the same way??

Created

Last reply

Replies

61

Views

3.7k

Users

12

Likes

185

Frequent Posters

Shwets1502 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
pallavi..iam so sorry i dont agree yar...

ok these are my views...suhana is in shock abt hearing RB's past..yes..but ishaan does not know that..for him she is still just thinking of RB..so for now ishaan can just console her which he tried..and getting her out was not his plan bt that of badi maa's...he just followed it..and ur point abt anyone can cheer up...thats true..bt may be badi maa wanted ishaan to take her out and spend some time..and i also agree we havent got a great IS scene for so many days...bt i din think it was like the right time..may be if ishaan would have known the truth there cud have been a heart to heart talk...

and so what ishaan cud do was to cheer her up in her way..i think it was sweet of him to actually ask suhana to break the glass and all...and also i think suhana shud get out of RB's story of her own more than somebody always advicing and telling her abt all things...

and jay has been doing it perfectly well...so no prbs for me...these are just my POV...hope i din offend...

P.S:getting late for college...will log in back from college....
myvoice thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Hey pallavi, I kinda agree that it is time we start seeing the importance Ishaan holds for suhaana, but I don't think there was anything more Ishaan could have done to get her out of the gloomy mood, as he himself didn't know the truth and has no idea that suhaana is affected by RB's past....he is jus under the impression that suhaana is upset with whatever has happened between RB-Deepak. I was okay with the way they played the scene, he took her to her favorite restaurant to cheer her up, when that didn't work, he tried the next best thing to divert her, which is making her angry (doesn't need much effort here 😆), ....loved the way he said "I'll support you", anythin to get her out of the depressed state. Finally the hotel manager succeeded in what Ishaan couldn't 😆, nevertheless considering the circumstances I can't think of any better way they could have showed Ishaan cheering up suhaana.
As far as progress in IS relationship, I guess that ain't happening until the childhood friend track starts.😕
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: cute2stay

Is it just me who wasn't that impressed with the IS scenes today? 🤔


I just felt something missing...I guess I was expecting more.

It didn't even really make me laugh....:S. I was kind of expecting a more poignant scene I guess.

Cuz yesterday we saw how much Suhana was affected by RB's story. It was kind of like a turning point for in a way too. She was kind of reflecting back on her own life and how she perceived her own life.

You know what I mean?? There was just food for SO much thought and development with this phase. And Ishaan could've played such a big role in that!!!

I mean right now, I am actually thinking ki what exactly is the point of Ishaan in Suhana's life!! You know? Like really, how does he matter to her at all??

I really think even Inder, Elesh or someone could've cheered up Suhana just as well no? And if it was about cheering her up, spending some moments with the family or something would've helped Suhana get cheered up too no?

What I was expecting Ishaan to do, was kind of get through to Suhana in some way. I wanted to see a poignant scene between them damn it!! They really could've had a good heart to heart or something about this nahin? I would've SOO loved to see some development in their characters, in their RELATIONSHIP which seriously needs a push right now!

If this was just a random sa scene I wouldn't have minded so much. But the fact that it was an aftermath of such a great track, i.e. RB and Deepak's and had SO much scope makes me kind of not satisfied.

And really, how long has it been since we saw a really poignant IS scene? Remember their past scenes and when they initially got married? Remember how Ishaan used to get through to Suhana SO well? Like you could SEE the importance he would hold in her life!

But right now it feels more like he's a clown than someone really special in Suhana's life!

I feel like Jai's acting too is kind of getting annoying for me. I don't know...something's missing for sure.

I want a better characterization of Ishaan like seriously! And I REALLY want to see him hold a special place for Suhana now, cuz frankly right now I'm so not convinced.

Thoughts? Does anyone else feel the same way??



THANK YOUUUUUUUUUU! I feel EXACTLY the same way! Especially the bolded bits! Thank god I'm not the only one who felt this way after watching the epi......I wondered about the same things you're mentioning....Ishaan ended up looking kinda lame and pointless to me....seriously why couldn't they have shown a heart to heart talk b/w IS instead of these random antics to turn Suhana back into her usual nautanki machine?? I get what they were trying to do but somehow Ishaan didn't work for me today....I also found myself annoyed with Jay's acting....didn't work for me.

I caught up on the last three epis today and there was such a momentum going with the RB-Deepak scenes and suddenly beech mein this bit with Ishaan cheering up Suhana....woh bhi in SUCH a manner? Hmmm didn't work for me....there was scope for something better I felt. All he was doing was just maaroing his usual dialogues of "i'll be there for you etc.etc."....since he's unaware of the RB truth, he ends up looking even more clueless.....I feel the scene could have been much better written and felt kinda filler types to me....upar se that bemused excited laughing that he was doing in the back when Suhana went off into her rant mode....didn't really connect with me....felt kinda put on😕
Edited by nureat01 - 14 years ago
pigbelly4myfeet thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
@ Shwetha and Revathy: Ok I get that Ishaan doesn't exactly know about RB etc....but to me that is all the more reason why he should've been more involved!

It just felt like he didn't exactly care WHY Suhana was so upset you know what I mean? Like usually in SGP, they delve into the main problem!

Today's scene was more like chalo bhai let's just upar se get rid of the problem for now!! It felt too filler-ish for the lack of a better word!!

It just bugged me that Suhana was SO upset, obviously SO shaken up about this whole thing! And why wouldn't she be too? She was just a part of something SO emotional! It was just a really emotional and confusing kind of a time for her!

And Ishaan didn't even really wonder WHY she was THIS upset??? I mean even if he guessed ki ok, she was upset about Deepak and all...after everything was ok and everything the fact that someone like Suhana was THIS upset...shouldn't Ishaan as a husband, as someone who LOVES her apparently be more concerned?

Shouldn't he have a bigger role in touching Suhana's life??? In this whole thing, it was only Badi ma who really understood the extent of Suhana's hurt. Ishaan toh was totally clueless!!

I feel like there was def. a better way they could have shown this!! I needed to FEEL something! And that too after such emotional episodes we got back to back, this was such a let down.

They really needed to build up on this!

And most importantly, why does Ishaan ALWAYS take a backseat in Suhana's life these days??? Does he even CARE anymore?? That's what bugs me the most!!!

Like earlier, remember how it was always two people that understood and got through to Suhana really well- Badi ma AND Ishaan!! But I don't see that these days at all!!

Couldn't he have played a bigger role in helping Suhana deal with this than just taking her to a restaurant??

Sure I get that he was trying to get Suhana back to her 'normal' self...but that's so not the point here!! The point was that Suhana was GROWING!! There was a maturity in her character!!! And Ishaan and Badi ma have always been two people that have helped with Suhana's groW*H in character!!

This was like going back to square one!!!

After all that Suhana has experienced, hearing RB and Deepak's story...this is what came out of it?

Her yelling at some manager again??

If this was a random comedy type ka scene, it would've been ok! But we really needed some development here. This was like ok so after all that, basically NOTHING happened!

Everyone is happy and back to square one?!???

Sorry for getting really hyper here...but do you see what I mean??
minu_8 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
I agree. Not only yesterday but IS scenes over last several episodes have disappointed me.
And i have never been consistently impressed with Jai's acting. It has always been in selected scenes. Some of his mannerisms really annoy me.. but that is a different topic.
I was disappointed in Wednesday's episode itself.. when badi maa told suhaana (the rest of the scene was no doubt very good and well acted) not to tell anyone and suhaana agreeing that she will not tell ishaan also. I didnt want that. They should have shown Suhaana herself not telling anyone and badi maa should have trusted her discretion. And i would have liked to see suhaana tell ishaan.. atleast that would have shown he was different from rest of the family.. and even if suhaana didnt tell ishaan.. i would have liked to atleast see her feel depressed and want to talk about it with ishaan and then maybe think he treats radha bua like a mother.. he will be shattered knowing this truth and then decide to remain silent.. somethign atleast..
i am glad there are others who thought so.. bcos usually I over analyse scenes and very few scenes in their totality satisfy me.. i am always thinkign the scene was good.. but that one dialogue rang false.. or in one place the expression felt artificial.. and so on.
I hope they do something about IS.. Enough of Suhaana-Family
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
@Pallo: What I'm getting from the scene today is that they only wanted to see Suhana's mood lightening up so this is the route they took.....and I can even understand that Ishaan was just trying to cheer her up but like you pointed out, I so wish they had shown him trying to delve deeper to understand WHAT she was thinking....it felt very surface level for him to just dismiss it as her upset about Deepak attempting suicide....why don't they want Ishaan to know the truth at this point?? How will that achieve anything? I think it would have been amazing to see Suhana expressing this to Ishaan and him consoling her THEN.

Honestly Ishaan's "cheering Suhana up" attempts didn't cut it with me today....I felt the scenes lacking in written quality.....why don't they show Ishaan doing anything WORTHWHILE in this show other than just popping up to cheer up Suhana?! Move on!
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: minu_8

I was disappointed in Wednesday's episode itself.. when badi maa told suhaana (the rest of the scene was no doubt very good and well acted) not to tell anyone and suhaana agreeing that she will not tell ishaan also. I didnt want that. They should have shown Suhaana herself not telling anyone and badi maa should have trusted her discretion. And i would have liked to see suhaana tell ishaan.. atleast that would have shown he was different from rest of the family.. and even if suhaana didnt tell ishaan.. i would have liked to atleast see her feel depressed and want to talk about it with ishaan and then maybe think he treats radha bua like a mother.. he will be shattered knowing this truth and then decide to remain silent.. somethign atleast..
I hope they do something about IS.. Enough of Suhaana-Family



Excellent point....I agree....I really wish they had shown Suhana either telling this to Ishaan....sharing SOMETHING with him....why just leave this at a surface level?? There was potential to add soooooooo much more depth to their relationship instead of the cheering up antics which didn't really work for me.
pigbelly4myfeet thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: nureat01



THANK YOUUUUUUUUUU! I feel EXACTLY the same way! Especially the bolded bits! Thank god I'm not the only one who felt this way after watching the epi......I wondered about the same things you're mentioning....Ishaan ended up looking kinda lame and pointless to me....seriously why couldn't they have shown a heart to heart talk b/w IS instead of these random antics to turn Suhana back into her usual nautanki machine?? I get what they were trying to do but somehow Ishaan didn't work for me today....I also found myself annoyed with Jay's acting....didn't work for me.

I caught up on the last three epis today and there was such a momentum going with the RB-Deepak scenes and suddenly beech mein this bit with Ishaan cheering up Suhana....woh bhi in SUCH a manner? Hmmm didn't work for me....there was scope for something better I felt. All he was doing was just maaroing his usual dialogues of "i'll be there for you etc.etc."....since he's unaware of the RB truth, he ends up looking even more clueless.....I feel the scene could have been much better written and felt kinda filler types to me....upar se that bemused excited laughing that he was doing in the back when Suhana went off into her rant mode....didn't really connect with me....felt kinda put on😕


OMGG YAAR WORD!!!! Thank youuuu for getting EXACTLY how I feel!!! I SO hear ya with the "thank god I'm not the only one who felt this"!!!! 😆 *high five*

Exactly, that's another thing too! Ishaan was also looking really lame to me!! Seriously W*H was up with his weird faces....I feel like Jai's expressions are SO weird sometimes! Make no sense whatsoever! :S

Seriously, yaar what exactly was the POINT of this scene?? :S I feel it accomplished nothing basically!

@ Bold: Yeahhhhh exactly! This was such a great opportunity for some heart to heart between IS!!

It's like the creatives are purposely making Ishaan take a backseat in Suhana's life or something...:S

I would much rather have preferred a heart to heart in their room or something..you know when Suhana couldn't fall asleep and stuff. That was the moment right there!! What a waste of such a great opportunity to show some development in their relationship!

I mean are we crazy to think ki how could the creatives have missed this?? I was actually expecting something meaningful...something significant out of this!!

It was totally filler types yaar! Yeah exactly, they really needed to build this up somehow after the whole RB-Deepak track!

O man and Ishaan's "bemused" or whatever expressions ki toh baat hi matt kar. He was looking like such a clown honestly! I was just not convinced man. 👎🏼

I would've SO loved to see Ishaan consoling Suhana somehow...in a MUCH better way. And by consoling I don't mean simply cheering her up for the time being. I mean actually getting to her somehow! On a MUCH deeper level!!

Like remember how we've seen scenes like where Ishaan just GETS Suhana so well? Like...I think LadyM or Kavya or someone once mentioned this...but it's like he can see into her soul!! Where has all that gone? Did we just imagine all that??? :S

How come he didn't get Suhana like that today? I was looking for more understanding, more heart to heart, more significance but found nothing!

Seriously what a waste! 👎🏼
Shwets1502 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
pallavi dear i understand...no prb with ur hyper...😉

dear iam also waiting for ishaan and suhana to have a heart out convo...and they cud have had it...bt they dint and thats not a prb for me...may be another situation...see suhana has spoken her heart out to badi maa abt how she felt abt lfe and all and the least she can tell ishaan now is abt RB and ishaan is more sensitive to that topic than suhana...their relationship would not have grown there as both will be worried for RB and may be both crying...so thats my point...and one cannot change all together in a short time..suhana is still the same suhana and thats the reason she started shouting at the manager...may be she will again become sober...

and i totally agree with one point..ishaan has been staying back and has to take charge now of both their lives..i hope the CV's realise that...and abt jay's acting...i think its the character of ishaan that may be annoying...bt i think jay is acting well...




Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".