Was Baabul a better movie than Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam?

I am in love with Salman now. His performance in that 2006 movie Baabul was shockingly cute and underrated. His chemistry with Rani was off the hook and I even think it is better than Miss Rai. The concept of widow remarriage was pretty interesting and made HDDCS seem like an artificial movie.

Which movie is better? Baabul or HDDCS?
Vote and make your voice heard

https://youtu.be/DpYCXyO0Kg8?si=QqoU9OfL6iqG5A6h

Oh god!Baabul was a total trash ..How are you even comparing it to a cult classic like HDDCS!!

Originally posted by: Elvis12

Oh god!Baabul was a total trash ..How are you even comparing it to a cult classic like HDDCS!!

HDDCS was good, but I felt Baabul was excellent and Rani knows how to act and not Miss Rai.

both were trash

In Baabul, Rani was forced to do second marriage, jab ki woh karana hi nahi chahaati thi. Just Like in HDDCS, Aish was forced to marry with Ajay Devgan. But I will prefer HDDCS than Baabul. But I agree that Salman's chemistry with both actresses were mind-blowing.