DOTW - Support Your Mentor - Bappi Lahiri - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

78

Views

3.4k

Users

14

Frequent Posters

Prenz~13 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#11
m here only.. 😳
yup..against team can begin wid d debate.. 😊
Anuradha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#12
There is a proverb - Pehle aap, Pehle aap karte kahiin gaadi choot na jaaye.. Someone begin with the debate please.. Im too curious to read the replies 😆
spian thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#13
Hi
Anu: reporting Mam! 😛
Just got busy and didnt check here.

Lets see who wins but taking into account Bappida's golden hits its kinda obvious ,naaa 😆

so "against" team may begin......
advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#14

The for team is telling the against team to begin, that means whatever the against team will say, the for team will say against that, which means the for team will be against the against team that make them also an against team. In that case who is for? Ufff utter confusion !!!😆

ChameliKaYaar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

The 'For' team seems intimidated by the 'Against' team's overwhelming aura 😉

Bappi da ki badai karte karet unki kalam sookh gayi hai😆

ChameliKaYaar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#16

I notice that nobody has anything for or against Bappi Da.

I declare the Winner.....
and the prize goes to
BAPPI DA
😆 😆 😆 😆

spian thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: ChameliKaYaar

I notice that nobody has anything for or against Bappi Da.

I declare the Winner.....
and the prize goes to
BAPPI DA
😆 😆 😆 😆

😆 yes most definitely and that implies "FOR" Bappida😊

Morgoth thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: advil

The for team is telling the against team to begin, that means whatever the against team will say, the for team will say against that, which means the for team will be against the against team that make them also an against team. In that case who is for? Ufff utter confusion !!!😆

The against team will argue for themselves, while the for team will do the same for their namesake (which is for, not bappi for the confused). Don't worry, arguments are forthcoming. 😉

rocker1 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#19
Tish dear.. hum chup ke nahi, saamne se vaar karte hain! Chalo main hi narial phodta hoon. 😛

Bappi Lahiri, as a mentor, needs to stand up for his gharana members. He needs to ensure that their flaws do not overshadow their plus points. His silence can hurt his shishyas.

Case in point - Koyal in the episode she was eliminated. She was criticized for her song selection (Rock me baby) and a comment was also passed on her dress sense by another mentor (Ismail Durbar).

Fault #1. Bappi da should a) have known what song she had selected, and b) advised her to choose a better song for that episode, seeing that Ghulam Ali saab and Asha ji were present.

Fault #2. Assuming he did know about her song and he approved the song, he should have spoken up when she was being blamed, and said that he had indeed approved the song, and taken the responsibility upon himself, so to speak. He did not do that. Or he should have defended the song, and he did not do that either (Himesh did).

Fault #3. When the Veerappan-esque music director was accusing Koyal of lying and saying that she had selected the song herself, he should have spoken up for her. He should have demanded that it be cleared once and for all who does the song selections. He did not do that (again Himesh did).

Fault #4. Bappi da should have stood up for Koyal when Ismail commented on her clothes. He should have brought up the fact that many singers (including one from Ismail's gharans in C2005 - Twinkle) had worn such clothes before, and nothing was said. Furthermore, such clothes were provided by the Zee creative team and hence deemed wearable. Also, he should have let Ismail know that his prerogative was only to comment on the singing aspect. He did not do any of that.

By keeping quiet in this scenario, and only showing a confused/embarassed/guilty look, it seemed that he could do nothing to save his gharana member. This reflected badly on Koyal, who came out of the episode looking like a girl who wore revealing clothes and sang risque songs - in short, a girl with loose morals. This was very unfortunate, and even if she had moved on to the next stage, this would have left a bad mark on her, as far as the public is concerned. Not to mention, it would have shaken her confidence.

It's clear that Bappi da has been very subdued in his reactions, whether it be praise when his contestant sings well, or keeping quiet when they are criticized. He needs to constantly let the public know how good his contestant is, or else, his gharana will be out soon in public voting rounds - as happened to JL in C2005.
ChameliKaYaar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Tish dear.. hum chup ke nahi, saamne se vaar karte hain! Chalo main hi narial phodta hoon. 😛

Bappi Lahiri, as a mentor, needs to stand up for his gharana members. He needs to ensure that their flaws do not overshadow their plus points. His silence can hurt his shishyas.

Case in point - Koyal in the episode she was eliminated. She was criticized for her song selection (Rock me baby) and a comment was also passed on her dress sense by another mentor (Ismail Durbar).

Fault #1. Bappi da should a) have known what song she had selected, and b) advised her to choose a better song for that episode, seeing that Ghulam Ali saab and Asha ji were present.

Fault #2. Assuming he did know about her song and he approved the song, he should have spoken up when she was being blamed, and said that he had indeed approved the song, and taken the responsibility upon himself, so to speak. He did not do that. Or he should have defended the song, and he did not do that either (Himesh did).

Fault #3. When the Veerappan-esque music director was accusing Koyal of lying and saying that she had selected the song herself, he should have spoken up for her. He should have demanded that it be cleared once and for all who does the song selections. He did not do that (again Himesh did).

Fault #4. Bappi da should have stood up for Koyal when Ismail commented on her clothes. He should have brought up the fact that many singers (including one from Ismail's gharans in C2005 - Twinkle) had worn such clothes before, and nothing was said. Furthermore, such clothes were provided by the Zee creative team and hence deemed wearable. Also, he should have let Ismail know that his prerogative was only to comment on the singing aspect. He did not do any of that.

By keeping quiet in this scenario, and only showing a confused/embarassed/guilty look, it seemed that he could do nothing to save his gharana member. This reflected badly on Koyal, who came out of the episode looking like a girl who wore revealing clothes and sang risque songs - in short, a girl with loose morals. This was very unfortunate, and even if she had moved on to the next stage, this would have left a bad mark on her, as far as the public is concerned. Not to mention, it would have shaken her confidence.

It's clear that Bappi da has been very subdued in his reactions, whether it be praise when his contestant sings well, or keeping quiet when they are criticized. He needs to constantly let the public know how good his contestant is, or else, his gharana will be out soon in public voting rounds - as happened to JL in C2005.

wah wah..👏...Tumne to sone ki chidiya ke pankh kaat diye....wah wah...."for" team ko bilkul niruttar kar diya tumne Shadab!!..Kya baat hai...main sideline se sirf mazaa leta rahoonga...😆...Lekin ladai shuru ho tab to...😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".