Ammu,
thanks as always. Appreciate your taking the time. Pretty soon, you will be the only one left providing feedback, seeing how anemic the feedback thread is becoming with every progressive round 😊. Oh well.
BTW, I thought one of the ladies might sing the Lata version of 'Rim Jhim Gire Saawan'. I really like that one too. It has got a different beat from the male version. In fact, the female version is the one that used to be shown more often on Doordarshan. I vividly remember the picturization - Amitabh and Moushumi getting soaked in the Mumbai rains. Some other good dual versions by RDB - Tum bin jaaoon kahaan, Chanda o Chanda, Mere naina saawan bhaadon, Hume Tumse Pyaar Kitna.
Oky, here is my feedback, unfortunately haven't listened to all of them as I'm studying...😉
First of all i really like this round, as it gives the participants shoo many choices on what to sing with two fantastic Music Directors.... a wonderful round from what i have heard so far!!!
Ashish ji - Haila.. i started shaking my head to this song, Ashish ji like i've said before, what a melodious voice you have.. "Rimjhim gire saawan".. one of my favourite songs, and so wonderfully you have done justice to it..!! Only some parts where i heard just a slight vibration or shrill, but wow, it was really great... Great job!!
Lavanya ji - Really liked the "tan tan tan"'s in this song, it sounded like you had some fun with it..!! Very good effort with the song, however sometimes when the notes get a bit higher it sounds like it's kind of strained.. but it sounded like you enjoyed singing this song and it was cute, like it should be ! :)
Cindu ji - This song really matches your voice..!! And i really like this song well, you have sung it beautifully..... only thing is that the "Chalka" part, sometimes the beginning is sung just a bit too high than normal, and then when you do "kaka ... jage nahin", those parts, just make sure that for each part you go down in that it stays consistent, sometimes you got it perfectly and other times it kind of waivered... but it was really really good...... great job!!!
Seema ji - Oh wow wow...... what a beautiful voice, i think this is one of my favourites that you have sung so far..!! Wow, just the words, from "raina" to "jaaye", that scale that goes down, it's so beautiful, and like Ashish ji you have a really rich, melodious voice... very very good!!
Raju ji - Ahh, chala jaata hoon main, such a fun song!! Everytime when i listen to you it's as if you are smiling and singing it.. which makes me smile and enjoy it as well.... it was sung really really well, just when you do the "oooh" parts, in the beginning and middle was really good but towards the end when you did it again, just make sure that it is consistent... but it was just great!!
Sarita ji - Oohh, another song which I like very much!! You have sung it very well, some small places which i can't quite pinpoint were a bit off but it was sung cutely and very well.... great !!
Pawan ji - Another song which i like, they keep growing😛 and what a dhamakedaar entrance you gave!! The way you started kind of jerked me in my seat, it was really good.... but i wish that you had kept this energy throughout the entire song, sometimes it went off and the sur just a tad as well..... it's a fun song to sing, and you gave such a good beginning that i really hoped for it to stay throughout the song !! But really very good effort..!!
Aparna ji - nice new ID😉 This song i did not expect you to sing actually, but i really like this song, one of my favs, so sad but so beautiful.... and wowww, you have sung it with the perfect emotions, i can feel the sadness in your voice and it just sounds so beautiful... may be my next fav after "Chain Se humko kabhi"...!! Only thing i will say is the "aur" part, since it is high it is harder to sing but it just came kind of out of the blue, how to say that? but wow, so beautiful, i was humming it while doing my homework... just great!!
Mamta ji - What a lovely song you have picked, and it was so so nice in the beginning and then i felt that it kind of had a less effect and got a bit more nasal towards middle-end.... just wish you had kept the melody as nice in the beginning throughout the entire song, but it was very well sung... great!
Vidhya ji - You have sung this song so well, again like i've said before your voice is so cute and it's really nice!! I just wish for more feeling in it, after all we are talking about taking away hearts😉 just some more emotion and it would have been really good.... great job!!
That's as far as i got, cholly, will finish listening to the others later...... great great great!!!👏 (all the emoticons go to each person, just didn't have time to add them each time😳)
And BTW Dolly ji, how nice, you put Rekha for Amma, she is one of her fav actresses😉!
Kabhi Neem Neem Kabhi Shahad Shahad
