Round 7-Groovy MD’s : Feedback thread - Page 6

Thanks a lot for your encouraging feedback Barnali 😊 Does quite a bit for boosting sagging morale 😃

Thanks for your feedback CKY...

Sarita: Wonderful voice Sarita. Decent expression although not outstanding....could have been a lot better. Why did you hurry the song, Sarita...Listen to the song yourself and you will realize that the song sounded hurried. Another idea...put the real song and your song on together para by para and you will know what I am talking about...You would realize that your speed was far more forced that the actual song. I know without music it is difficult to follow the pace of the song but you have to kind of follow the music in your brain and sing to that tune...Other than that...a good rendition. 👏

Originally posted by: ChameliKaYaar

Review and Feedback Time...Yipeeeee 😃

Pawan: Pawan Pawan Pawan...You started strong...but there were problems in holding your sur...there were lots of inconsistencies...Hear the song and you will realize that you did not pick the sur when you started the antara from where you had left it at the end of mukhda...and your shurs were shaky within the antara as well, there were loss of surs in between pauses. I enjoyed the beginning with your rendition of kukoroo kuku kuku😆...But overall impact was low,my friend. However, an ovation for a good attempt👏

Thanks for the comments. Actually I had a throat surgery 😭 thats why I was not in the swing. now, I came back and trying to sing for the next round. Hope I can make it before the last date.

Originally posted by: pawan.caprice

Thanks for the comments. Actually I had a throat surgery 😭 thats why I was not in the swing. now, I came back and trying to sing for the next round. Hope I can make it before the last date.

Hey Pawan, I hope you are feeling better now ! Wish you a speedy recovery and best of luck !

Originally posted by: advil

Hey Pawan, I hope you are feeling better now ! Wish you a speedy recovery and best of luck !

Thankyou for all your support😃 I am felling better day by day

Originally posted by: pawan.caprice

Thanks for the comments. Actually I had a throat surgery 😭 thats why I was not in the swing. now, I came back and trying to sing for the next round. Hope I can make it before the last date.

Pawan its a request from us.Dates hav already been extended till 23rd.And if u feel maybe 2-3 days more may help u then please do get in touch with your mentor. We can always help u out.Its just a fun contest and for such troubles we definitely can always make adjustments.

Originally posted by: Barnali

Aparna : beautifully sung again aparna.👏 Maybe at few places u shifted from the actual tune and gave your own touch. But they are not sounding out of place. Technically perfect. Luved the emotion u brought into the song.My own personal view. I would hav luved u to sing some soft RDB number from the 70's.

Agree with you here. Somehow I am rarely happy with the songs selected by Aparna, even though I like her voice so much e.g the Devdas song. In this RDB song, the lyrics are lovely but the tune is nothing to write home about. RD himself had admitted what a struggle it was to put the lyrics into a tune, and the strain shows...

Originally posted by: Barnali

Ashish : I hav already given u the feedback. U hav done full justice to the song.One of my very fav songs by kishore.Luved the feeling u brought into the song but would hav luved if some more feeling was brought.It seemed as if something little bit was missing somewhere.But technically again perfect.

Agree with this. Ashish sang very well but if you ask me which song of his stands out until now, it is the Marathi song.

Originally posted by: punjini

Agree with you here. Somehow I am rarely happy with the songs selected by Aparna, even though I like her voice so much e.g the Devdas song. In this RDB song, the lyrics are lovely but the tune is nothing to write home about. RD himself had admitted what a struggle it was to put the lyrics into a tune, and the strain shows...

Sahana, but Asha won a National award for this song. Surely, it could not have been on the merit of its lyrics and Asha's singing ability alone. I wonder if RD said 'It was a struggle to compose this song BUT the end result was immensely satisfying'. Personally, I too prefer 'Katra Katra' but I know several people whose favorite song from Ijaazat is 'Mera Kuch Saamaan'. Granted, some of them probably like it because of the lyrics but I think there must be more to it than that. The tune does have a haunting quality about it.

BTW, this discussion falls into the subjective realm that I was referring to a few posts back. It is probably something we will just have to agree to disagree on. And what better way to increase the traffic on this thread! 😉

Oky, so cholly, have downloaded the ones I haven't listened to and will give my feedback on them as well... :)

My mom has read the feedback and she says a big big thank you!! 😃 😳 Working on her throat now as it was hurting last time, I think it's better now :)