Sa re ga ma challenge/ Updates/ Comments - Page 18

shaan keeps talking about the final 8 stage.

as per me the final 8 will be

girls : nihira / swananda / himani / twinkle

boys : debojit / vishwaas/ hemachandra / abhijeet

Challenge2005
Zee, 10 pm

Today's performances are based on the late R D Burman's songs. Vineet and Joyeeta from Himesh Reshammiya's gharana,Sharib and Ujjaini from Jatin Lalit's gharana, Himani from Adesh Shrivastav's gharana and Irfan from Ismail Darbar's gharana mesmerise the mentors and the celebrity judges - Khayamji and Kumar Sanu with their heart rendering performances.

Originally posted by: toronto123

Let us recap, how gharanas stand:
Boys first:
ID- Debojit, Niladri (both thorugh), Paresh & Irfan (yet to perform)
JL- Abhijit, Sharib (yet to perform)
AS-Viswas, Rajiv(both through), Hemachandra (yet to perform)
HR-Nanu, Dilshaad (both eliminatd), Vineet (yet to perform)

Girls :
ID-Nihira, Twinkle (both through), Vineeta (yet to perfom)
JL- Manjira (eliminated), Swananda (through), Sanchali (yet to perform)
AS-Raktima(through), Hemabindu(eliminated), Himani and Keke (yet to perform)
HR-Joyita, Ujjaini (yet to perform)

Did I put them correctly? So following are yet to perform in the 2nd charan:
Boys:Paresh, Irfan,Abhijit, Sharib, Hemachandra and Vineet

Girls: Vinita, Sanchali, Himani, Keke, Ujjaini

I think there is slight error as ujjani is from jatin lalit team and not from Himesh's

Mentors   ; ;Participants (girls)
Aadesh - Rakhtima Hemabindu Himani Keka
Jatin-Lalit- Manjeera Swananda Ujjaini SanchaLi
Himesh-   ; ; Supriya BanJyotsna Joyeeta Priyani
Ismail-   ; ; Nihira   ; ; Twinkle   ; ; Anindita Vineeta


Mentors Parti cipants (boys)
Aadesh- Vishwaas Rajeev Vishwanath Hemachandra
Jatinlalit- Saptak Bhumik Sharib Abhijeet
Himesh- Nanu &a mp;n bsp; Dilshaad Vineet Aishwarya
Ismail-   ; ; Debojit Niladri Irfan Paresh

The ones who have been eliminated so far- Hemabindu, Manjeera, Supriya, Banjyotsna, Priyani, Anindita (girls)
Vishwanth, Saptak, Bhumik, Nanu, Dilshaad, Aishwarya (BOYS).

The ones who have gone through to the next round (second round of elimination is still on)- raktima, nihira, swananda and twinkle (girls) vishwas, debojit, rajeev and niladri (boys)

The names written below each other have competed in the same group against each other meaning Raktima, manjeera, supriya and nihira have competed against each other and so on.

(Moderators- please help i have tried to remove the unnecessary semi colon and nbsp but some how i can't - please do it for me- thanks)

My guess list in the final rounds

Boys - Debojit/Abhijeet

Girls - Nihira/Sunanda

Somehow, I feel Twinkle is like any normal singer (with lots of overconfidence!)

Btw, it is H I M A bindu not H E M A bindu. In telugu the word means (literal) 'ice drop'

Originally posted by: pmahesh

Challenge2005
Zee, 10 pm

Today's performances are based on the late R D Burman's songs. Vineet and Joyeeta from Himesh Reshammiya's gharana,Sharib and Ujjaini from Jatin Lalit's gharana, Himani from Adesh Shrivastav's gharana and Irfan from Ismail Darbar's gharana mesmerise the mentors and the celebrity judges - Khayamji and Kumar Sanu with their heart rendering performances.

Nice change in judges. Kumar Sanu and Khaiyyam, a music director and singer.

Originally posted by: kishore_bhakta

Nice change in judges. Kumar Sanu and Khaiyyam, a music director and singer.

I agree. Let us hop that they are better than Alka and Jagjit. However, Kumar Sanu himself is not a complete singer (very typed). Is he a right material for judging when he himself could not overcome the limitations!!

Well, he is a successful singer, at one point the top singer- there is no denial of that fact. Though person like me and kishore_bhakta will never curse this guy for marginalising Kishore da's style of singing. Like Sonu did a great "repairing" job of Raff saheb's style of singing when Shabbir and Md. Aziz had done enough damage!!! Same way Abhijit has done some "repair" work after Kumar Sanu did so much of damage to Kishore Da's bindaas style of singing. Personally I feel that Kumar Sanu was a singer of the "crisis" time in Bollywood music world. He was fortunate to have got some outstanding compositions of which "1947 - A love story " turned out to be a landmark o his career. I feel that when QSQT came, Udit had shown the originality and if and only if Nadeem Shravan's Ashiqui(one of the best compositions ever..by any music director..) had not taken Kumar Sanu the break. But as always happens , in long run only the original runs and so Udit Narayan is first choice of ARR and all top music directors today and Kumar Sanu must be feeling happy if he gets one or two situational songs or title songs once in a while!!

Anyway, Zee TV has also limitations in getting the judges. So given that situation Kumar Sanu is not that bad a choice. Khaiyaam on the other hand is a great choice as judge and hopefully he manages Kumar Sanu and balances the judging.

Looking forward for next Monday/Tuesday now eagerly and will come back in this forum now on Tuesday (because I do not want to know the results beforehand!!!)

Judges were OP Nayar & Kavita krishnamurty
In todays episode.

I want Paresh or Vishwas to win...but i cant chose.
Nihira will win cuz she sings betta than sum playback singers.
As for judges, i wuld def. like to see sum one diff.
But the host/anchor has to stay the same, i don want him changin 😉

I am in Singapore and i think we are an episode later compared to India. So please post as what happened yesterday