SAREGAMAPA finals vs INDIAN IDOL finals - Page 5

SRGMP finals were better. i didnt feel any sense of nervousness or anxiety while watching II coz the competition was tough enuf.. Debo vs Vinit was like the talk of the town.

The reason why SRGMP produce better singers than II because of the judges. The judges are soo much more stricter and there were sooo many thousand rounds b4 they cud reach to the finals. In II, i think Anu, Farah and Sonu were WAYYYYYYYY to lenient. SRGMP was really unpredicatiable coz everyone was sooooo talented. but u cud literary count the number of good singers of II in one hand. So alot of the responsibility goes to judges which they didnt make the best use of.

But i think although Sony promises many many things. Ultimately in the long run, it's ur talent tht will speak volume.

We have already discussed this topic in the past which Programme of singing is the best….All said SRGMP but only few said II –2 and rare said few…… Hmmm m i sounding poetic 😃

I agree with you guys but as far a s girls concern I am not sure if they are even derseving to be in Ek Mei Aur Ek Tu !!!!

I like Amey in Indian Idol 2 and somewhat Meenal rest all are below par thah SrGmP standards :)

Originally posted by: sandeepdubbaka

Hello everybody,

We all know that saregamapa is better than indian idol. But ,especially when u compare the finals of saregamapa and indianidol, one can clearly see the difference. Even abhijeeth sawant was not upto the mark compared to rajeev when he sang rang de basanti. And the other contestants are also below par the standards. I felt most of the top12 contestants wouldnt have passed the first round.

Hemu and debo were far better than karunya when u compare how they sang the song from bluffmaster.karunya may be better while singing classical songs,but couldnt perform modren songs on bigstage which was so important.

I felt it was one of worst finals,except for one or two performances. Overall I want to say is the quality of singers at saregamapa was far far better than indian idol in noth the departments , singing and performance.

May be this question have been asked many times, as I am new to the forum ,after watching indian idol finals, I seriously wanted to know the opinions abou this.

I agree that SRGMP is far better than IL2.. but i don't agree that Karunya is less talented than so called SRGMP contestants.. He is very talented and sang all kind of songs with ease

But grand finale of IL2 was much better than SRGMO05...

I was disspointed by both results ofcourse

guys guys...enough! this is totally crap! i agree totally that i liked srgmp...but plz give me a break...when i read what ppl wrote in this tread i just could not stop laughing..how can anyone compare?????? do u guys know music better than sonu..why cant u guys take it what sonu nigam said?????"SONU SAID KARUNYA IS THE BEST SINGER HE EVER SAW IN ANY SHOW "EACH AND EVERYBODY SAID INCLUDING GREAT SINGERS AND MUSIC DIRECTORS THAT KARUNYA IS THE BEST.."IN FACT IN MANY SONGS THERE IS NO COMPARISON TO WHAT KARU SANG..just coz he did not sing like abhishek bachan u cant tell karu is not a good singer..in fact to sing like abhi u dont need talent...abhishek bachan is an actor not singer.....i would not like to say anything bad abt any singer..all i want to say is just coz one singer sand rang de basanthi better than other dont critisize..i know what rajeev did on recent episodes...and u ppl also know that .....but every singer is good in his or own way..so just enjoy thier songs!what is in thier future u will know very soon when thier album comes out!
all this jodi singing is looking like they r love birds...

I agree that Saregamapa is better in terms of singing but don't count Karunya and Amey any less than the Saregamapa contestants. One more point that one cannot say that Karunya is bad by just comparing his one song of bluffmaster with Hema. Karunya has done justice to many difficult songs...you ought to listen to those before saying this. Karunya and Amey are both great singers and well trained.

Originally posted by: Vishy Anand

I agree that Saregamapa is better in terms of singing but don't count Karunya and Amey any less than the Saregamapa contestants. One more point that one cannot say that Karunya is bad by just comparing his one song of bluffmaster with Hema. Karunya has done justice to many difficult songs...you ought to listen to those before saying this. Karunya and Amey are both great singers and well trained.

Exactly my thought. Karunya and Amey were definitely better than so many SRGMP singers. I think Hema and Nihira were probably the best in all reality shows 2005.

Originally posted by: sandeepdubbaka

Hemu and debo were far better than karunya when u compare how they sang the song from bluffmaster.karunya may be better while singing classical songs,but couldnt perform modren songs on bigstage which was so important.

I totally agree with you except that Karunya is the only one who can give the SRGMP singers a run for their money.

Originally posted by: Vishy Anand

I agree that Saregamapa is better in terms of singing but don't count Karunya and Amey any less than the Saregamapa contestants. One more point that one cannot say that Karunya is bad by just comparing his one song of bluffmaster with Hema. Karunya has done justice to many difficult songs...you ought to listen to those before saying this. Karunya and Amey are both great singers and well trained.

Karunya and Amey are NO less than any SRGMP contestants.. if I had to make a top 12 to compete in my ideal competition it would probably be Amey, Karunya, Prajakta Shukre, Himani, Nihira, Arijit, Hemu, Vinit, Sharib, Debojeet, Monali, Amit Sana.. these were accd. to me the best singers from the reality shows off late.. if votes favoured them, I'd see Karu and Amey till top 5.... and probably Hemu or Nihira winning the competition 😳 ! Thats in an ideal world..

The poll is talking about the finals in terms of singing, in terms of grandeur and in terms of the winner.. debojeet is better than sandeep for sure.. and the whole finals was like talk of the town..when II finals happened.. no idea..

Originally posted by: sweetmusic

Exactly my thought. Karunya and Amey were definitely better than so many SRGMP singers. I think Hema and Nihira were probably the best in all reality shows 2005.

Completely agree... Nihira, Hemu, Arijit, Karunya and Amey are probably the best in all reality shows in 2005 - 2006