SAREGAMAPA finals vs INDIAN IDOL finals - Page 6

i agree with the part the srgmp finals were better than the II2 finals.....and yea rajeev sang RDB better than AS...bue rajeev didnt sing it live...which makes a big difference...if AS didnt sing the song live i'm 99.9% sure that he would've sang better than rajeev....i'm not favouring anybody...but just saying(writing) my opinion.

i disagree with the part that debooo is worse than karu. and karu can sing modern music. karu sang right here right now better than deboo. but hemu sang it better than karu...he sang it the best of all..(but i liked abhisheks better 😳).

and yea.....sa re ga ma pa singers are better than II2 singers... srgmp has found some nice talents.

i soooo agreee wid u.. on da day of da finals i waz thinkni bout da same thing..

II iz sucha known show and da finals sucked... SRGMP had so much galmour and fun in the finals it actulli looked like something big

and II juz looked like every other day where da 2 contestants perform on stage...

i HATED it soo much

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

My top 8 in order of best Nihira, Sharib, Debu, Hema, Karuniya, Ameya, Himani and Arijith.

I agree with you. These were the best find in 2005, except Debojit and HImani. They sang well, But I cannot say they are really a find.

Nihira, Hema, Amey, Karunya, Arjith, Sharib(inconsistent but original voice, fresh and new) in that order

saregamapa finals looked grand ....but they did not sing live ....but all the finalists were very talented ....top 5 were the best ...where as Indian idol they did sing live but except karunya there was nothing to look for ...it was torture to listen to the new Indian idol and the old ......amey and Karunya are the best of Indian idol.....rest 🤢

Originally posted by: svh2010

i agree with the part the srgmp finals were better than the II2 finals.....and yea rajeev sang RDB better than AS...bue rajeev didnt sing it live...which makes a big difference...if AS didnt sing the song live i'm 99.9% sure that he would've sang better than rajeev....i'm not favouring anybody...but just saying(writing) my opinion.

i disagree with the part that debooo is worse than karu. and karu can sing modern music. karu sang right here right now better than deboo. but hemu sang it better than karu...he sang it the best of all..(but i liked abhisheks better 😳).

and yea.....sa re ga ma pa singers are better than II2 singers... srgmp has found some nice talents.

rajeev didnt sing it live😕i thought only debo did lip syncing for the song composed by id

Hey guys what are you comparing with?
Saregama pa was prerecorded and they lipsynced on stage.
How can you compare live with prerecoded songs.