WHY IS DEBO A WINNER, INSPITE OF SRGMP? - Page 13

Originally posted by: vsmaganti

"Among the one's I watched...Mostly last 3 to 3 1/2months..I saw Debojit only once on the TOP. most of the time either it was Vineet or Himani were the toppers more than Twice and Twice by Hema Chandra."

I think he was in the top twice - after the 1st agnipariksha round and after the amrita rao/ shahid kapoor round. most of the time it was vineet who was at the top, NOT himani. but debo was in the top 3 to 4 most of the time.

"From what he claims for whom he is doing all this and stuff like that..."

I'm not sure what u meant here....

"With that many years of experience behind him...when competing with someone who are less experienced.....He should have given excellent performances all the time...leaving no room for any these arguments.."

That is a very idealistic statement. no 1 can be perfect to the extent that he/she should give excellent and flawless performances all the time. even hema and nihira had some bad days (very few compared to their good days). he didn't have years of playback singing experience and it's not like he is a professional competing with amateurs. the guy works and is working pretty hard so at least give him some credit for that. after all, this thread was doing just that and not even criticizing other contestants. so I find it completely irrelevant to start dissecting this thread to find errors in debo just for the sake of arguing (forgive me if I misunderstood u)

"Also what I meant to say was...I noticed the jump in no of votes(highest percentage jump in the number of votes) for Debojit...Only after walkout...and not before walkout.."

again the jump in the no. of votes is irrelevant since it's not that after the walkout debo jumped from the bottom position to top position. as I said before, he was in the top 3 to 4 the majority of the time to begin with. So the relative no. of votes matter, not the absolute no. of votes.

😊

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh

I too am trying but cant help it when somebody is raving out eulogies of undeserving kind.

Originally posted by: musicpulse

oh, can't wait for spring! Happy skiing and avoid accidents😊

also this thread simply shows appreciation for debo. It does not even bash the other contestants. don't know why debo bashing started. 😕

😊

This in pure english is "MISUNDERSTANDING" ....I appreciate if you can take this as a constructive criticism...and not bashing up somebody ....Please don't go there...as we are not going to gain even a penny by doing so no matter what. I was only trying to point out the reasoning on which Sinha Saab wrote the post.

Originally posted by: bapigua

tabu criticized the home town bias as well.

Originally posted by: vsmaganti

Originally posted by: qwertyasdfgh

sorry, I didn't specifically mean u. but i have seen some posts in this thread that r more or less criticizing debo even though this thread is not confrontational or meant to be so. I hope I made myself clear! 😊

here lies the problem: whom u consider undeserving maybe pretty deserving to some1 else. 😊

Originally posted by: friend17

😊

To vsmaganti:

After the PM (and your latest reply to me in this thread), I felt that u weren't criticizing NSinha's thread just for the sake of criticizing debo. If that's indeed true then just forget what I wrote so far in this post (i.e. arguing with u) and let's move on. 😊

Originally posted by: MadhuD

BS! Yeh phir aa gaya Assam ka gungaan karne.

1st of all many many thnx for posting such a nice article in ur thread Sinha ji…Keep it up…may God bless both Debu and ID…..2nly I will thnx purana_papi for making a illiterate man show his standard…beware MadhuD and his/her followers..choooo go away and play elsewhere here grown up matured educated ppl r discussing something serious which will go above ur head.