Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :) - Page 26

Poll

Do you think it was right on part of Vineet, Hema & Himani to walk out

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

737

Views

175.7k

Users

389

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

Roybkk thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
This program started off well in serach of new talent but its becoming a nuisance as the days are going by. Some of the mentors are shamelessly promoting their gharana people. Its really disgusting now. Himani, hemchandra and Vineet should be banned from further performances for their disgraceful behaviour.
Mr. Ganjendra Singh should definitely not come up with such shows and such rules in the near future. He should try to make it more unbiased and free and neutral
rpavan thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
WILL THERE BE SHOW TODAY IF SO HOW MANY OF THEM WILL BE THERE
ALL 4..OR IS IT REALLY HIMANI IS VOTED OUT
vishalvaishs thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: rpavan

WILL THERE BE SHOW TODAY IF SO HOW MANY OF THEM WILL BE THERE
ALL 4..OR IS IT REALLY HIMANI IS VOTED OUT

Is it True??? is HIMANI OUT this time? is here anyone with any latest info abt the same????

nityamc thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

See 80% of the share of votes Debojit has got have come from Assam and waht's wrong with that. And just in case one thinks I am from Assam. my count for him was in mere 2.8% from DELHI!

He does have the capability to sing, or else you are doubting the judges who cleared him in the first go and the names are prestegious... Shiv Hari, Kavita Krishna Murthy...

Voice quality of everyone is not same... And I guess we should encourage Debojit & Hema. Vineet is a pet of Himesh so he has found a god father in the industry anyway and same goes for Himani.

The rest of the two need our support. Now on it will be only Debojit for my vote, coz the rest shouldn't have played the challage if they don't have sportsmanship. Hema & Himani you have proved I have wasted my money on two of you.

Carry on Debojit, You are no less a Indian than vineet, Himani & Hemachandra put togather. And I will continue to vote for him even if my count is amongst the lesser 2.8%.

It was sad to see Vineet's father's reaction. The least Zee could have done was edit it. This is not expected from Gajendra. This is the only programme I watch through out the week for the quality of singers. Please go back to your normal mode.

rpavan thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: vishalvaishs

Is it True??? is HIMANI OUT this time? is here anyone with any latest info abt the same????

See yesterday show showed that..vineet is 2nd hightest and debojit first highest
and in deccan chronicle it was said that hem is in top 3
so ideally it shd be himani with least votes

punjini thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
I haven't seen the "big fight" yet because in Singapore, we get each episode one week later than India. I felt the programme was doomed right from the day voting started for the best singers, that too with each candidate entreating the viewers to vote for them as many times as they wished. What kind of logic was this? It became a "free for all" akhara, so to speak.

When the singers began to dress up in designer wear and act like "performers" rather than artists, I felt the programme was losing its exclusive status. What was the idea in making them act and emote in front of the camera? Genuine singers like Swananda and Nihira who believed in making their vocal chords "perform" were forced to gyrate and dance which they were clearly not comfortable with.

I was upset when Swananda was eliminated. She has such a beautiful voice, almost flawless! And now Nihira is gone too. I just cannot understand how the likes of Himani can win while singers like Nihira lose!

When Jatin-Lalit's gharana was eliminated, I was even more upset. Surely the best music directors of this decade can't lose to wannabes like Himesh Reshamiya or Aadesh Srivatsav or Ismail Darbar who don't know anything about original melodies!

I just hope the next series of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa will remove the flaws of the present format.
rpavan thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: punjini

I haven't seen the "big fight" yet because in Singapore, we get each episode one week later than India. I felt the programme was doomed right from the day voting started for the best singers, that too with each candidate entreating the viewers to vote for them as many times as they wished. What kind of logic was this? It became a "free for all" akhara, so to speak.

When the singers began to dress up in designer wear and act like "performers" rather than artists, I felt the programme was losing its exclusive status. What was the idea in making them act and emote in front of the camera? Genuine singers like Swananda and Nihira who believed in making their vocal chords "perform" were forced to gyrate and dance which they were clearly not comfortable with.

I was upset when Swananda was eliminated. She has such a beautiful voice, almost flawless! And now Nihira is gone too. I just cannot understand how the likes of Himani can win while singers like Nihira lose!

When Jatin-Lalit's gharana was eliminated, I was even more upset. Surely the best music directors of this decade can't lose to wannabes like Himesh Reshamiya or Aadesh Srivatsav or Ismail Darbar who don't know anything about original melodies!

I just hope the next series of Sa Re Ga Ma Pa will remove the flaws of the present format.

Hi Punjini
its the same problem for me too
am also in singaproe its very sad that we get the telecast one week later
dont knwo whether the votes v cast thru internt are considered

Mrs.Brett Lee thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
Vj bro great topic. 😊 . So nice to see u in SRGMP Section. I think Vinit and Hemachandra shouldn't have gone because now viewer will think they r doing drama.

I think the voting pattern should be changed. It should not be by the public as public is not always right. 😃
msengupt thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

This is to protest in very strong words about the

unsportsmanly behaviour shown by the following

participants of Saregamapa , Himani , Hemchandra and

Vineet . It was extremely ridiculous how the

participants fled from the stage due to the fear of

impending defeat . With such mental strength they

should not have come and participate in a reputed show

like Sa re ga ma pa which had always upheld the public

opinion .This shows a total lack of moral courage in

these participants and they do not stand fit to

compete on such a public platform .

More hurtning was the comments passed by the so called

Majical Mentors who showed their support to such

obnoxious comments as " This programme is the voice of

India not the voice of Assam " . I think our so called

learned mentors must have spent their lives very hard

pursuing music and hence could not devote sufficient

time for studying the Geographical boundaries of our

country . Thus it seems to be not in their knowledge

that Assam is also very much a part of India and they

are bound to respect the opinion of the people of

Assam too .

Even going by the great knowledge of our Majical

Mentors I fail to understand how come participants

from UK and US were included in a programme termed as

VOICE OF INDIA .

Anyway this comes as the blessings of the Almighty in

disguise and we strongly feel that if we can consider

the participants as " Matured " human being , let us

atleast respect their decision and let them quit the

show and join Indian politics instead .

So it may be decalred that DEBOJIT is the winner of

the Challenge 2005.

kashvii thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: saregam

yeterday what happened in SA RE GA MA PA stage was shocking, all 3 mentors were fighting like street dogs. and who was leading them the Honourable ISMAIL DARBAR, the man who started all this by walking out last week. and smartly collected all the SYMPATHY VOTES for DEBOJIT. AND WHEN 3 VINIT, HEM, NIHIRA decalered to walk out there was a cunning smile on his face, he was not at all seemed shocked. he got what he wanted, he swore to make NIHIRA the singing sensation of India and swore to alla to let him live until he makes NIHIRA a star. that was a cunning show of tricks, 3 mentors are music directors but they do not seem to back good singers, they back their students, and it is a damn fact that only ADESH was retain 2 candidates in last 4.so here is the proof of ability, when you can not make one good singer in 7 months then ismail is a loser, and by playing foul he can not save his student from public wrath.



Are you like hardheaded or something?..."cunning smile", "street dogs", "playing foul tricks", you idiot, all of india understood what was happening when those three fools walked on stage...Ismail just understood that, and couldn't help but smile....they didnt even know what the hell to say.....public voting has been around so long and if ur part of the challenge, you should accept the results...its utter nonsense when they said "jab nihira bahir gaye, to hume yeh karna chahiye tha"....they freakin danced and smiled for the first 20 mins of the show and after debo was announced the winner, they did that stupid s***...if they really thought that nihira's exit was wrong, than why wasn't debo informed about the plan?....why didnt all four walk out.....NO....they had already decided that if debo won, they would do it....thats the kind of participants they are, full of ego, explicitly stating in BOLD print that they are better than today's winner and they will not tolerate india's voting...
and secondly, debo's always been gettinng 75% and more votes from NE, and he even got yellow lights with the those votes, today was his day of celebration and joyce after a long time....and they go and ruin it for him.....i dont get it at all...all this time voting has been noted be in correspondence with where the participants are from...ex..hema always asks for vote in telegu and get vote form his region, same with vinit and himani, they get more votes from their areas than any other, and the SAME thing with DEBO....so after all the days and episodes where various participants left, TODAY they think the majority of indian votes is wrong??....sone stupid acts by a bunch of 17 year olds....;

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".