Better than the Original Comments - Page 3

Originally posted by: sunom

Every part of your body, heart, mind, soul are burning and sugandha was really really best of best. I am happy that she is more than original. I am also happy that you are sad. You never said a single word when sajid said that he never listened such voice/song like sniti.

IMO sniti is a garbage.

Originally posted by: PimpJuice

Eh, nothings burning in my body. =)
And, Im not trying to offend Suganddha fans over here, I was only stating a brief example that's relative to the topic. Goodness 😆

Maiya Maiya song has been sung mind blowing by anwesha whereas I am not her fan. I am fan of mauli, she sang namak ishq ka brllliantly.

Originally posted by: PimpJuice

I agree. At the same time, I believe judges would say anything to boost up votes and positive attention for their gharana. The thing that annoys me the most is when judges say it for the wrong performances 😆
For instance, Suganddha was nothing close to Alisha ji's Kajra re 😕 So Vishal's comment was really unnecessary.

If i can think of any, or at least a performance where that comment would be appropriate .. it would be for Maiya Maiya (Mauli) Her performance preserves the memory of the orig AND gives the song something more with her rendition. 😃

Originally posted by: Cutiepie Rani

That's why I mentioned Mauli's performance in my first post. Her's was an exception. She did sing a ton better than the original singer, but still credit cannot be taken away from the original. Suganddha on the other hand was no where close to the original. She did sing well but you can't match her up to Alisha ji's singing.

Originally posted by: sunom

aur kuchh?

ab dance kar ke dikha

👏😭😭

Originally posted by: Cutiepie Rani

Hi guys. Hope you haven't forgotten me. I took a step away from this forum.

Anyways what do you guys have to say when judges tell the contestant that they sung better than the original? Honestly I feel that's utter nonsense. I think that in most songs you can't take the credit away from the original singers. There's always an exception like Mauli's Maiya Maiya was clearly better than the original singer. But still how do you feel about these comments? I don't think a contestant should be compared to the original singer in the first place. Everyone has their own unique voice. Neither should credit be taken away from the singers that have originally sung the song. Its an insult to the original singer when the judges say "you sang better than the original." I mean even if they did sing better, why do the judges need to air that on screen? Its a huge insult to the bigger names of the industry. And these music directors should know better! Just my two cents.

Originally posted by: Cutiepie Rani

PLEASE don't take my comments in a negative manner. I have nothing against Suganddha. She is a brilliant singer and a beautiful human being. I just had to state what I felt. No one has to agree with me. Keep loving & supporting her if she is your favorite. =)