This year none is as all rounded as Aneek - Page 8

Originally posted by: Summer3

Frankly it is a waste of time comparing Raja , Amanat and Aneek. as to their singing ability. Very academic and nothing much will come out of it.

I expect these three to come up with their own compositions and make a contribution to the music world. Which will of course benefit most people.

Originally posted by: LuckyJade

I agree, to a certain extent. Any of these young talents who have an inclination toward composing music should consider doing so, along with pursuing singing for films. But this shouldn't be something one expects from them either because some of them may not have the aptitude for doing so or because it is hard getting in the industry as a new singer with no connections, i imagine it is at least or even harder doing so as a new composer. So they might have to do some prioritizing as to which avenue (either singing or composing) they want to focus on more.

Originally posted by: Summer3

These 3 are the cream of the crop. They can sing for a few years and also work on their own compositions. I think both Raja and Amanat have their own band groups too. But if they have too many singing assignments then there maybe little time for creativity.

Originally posted by: sreya_cp

Yeah i fully agree with Summer ji's topic.😊

This year's contestants in Srgmp ch 2009,are not even close to Aneek Dhar.They sing good,no doubt.But Aneek 's singing is of very superior level.His voice quality,versatility,diction,technically perfection are his assets.He never messed a single song.I am a fan of Aneek since srgmp bangla days.And i have never found him singing less than his his potential.whether in bengali srgmp,or srgmp ch 2007,or ekse he is brilliant and superb as usual.And i think you all will agree with me,that Aneek is the only singer who performed CONSISTANTLY.Whatever the situation may be,whether he is not well or he is picked by the judges he never allows anything to affect his singing.Thats show his determination.

And those who are saying that Raja,Amanat were better than Aneek,i respect their opinion,as thay are fans of them,it's quite obvious that their fav singer would be superior in their opinion.But for me,being a diehard fan of Aneek i would always say and believe that Aneek is the best..And to be very frank when i hear those songs which were sung by Aneek previously,in other contestants voice,it really makes me feel ill at ease.for example-as somepeople were comparing Aneek's bheegi bheegi wuth Debojit's bheegi bheegi..I would say that Aneek's version was far far far better.He added so much passion to it.and the way he sang the song both in hindi and bengali..ohh..it was wonderful.I may sound biased,but in my opinion Aneek is rare find and he is what called as a perfect singer.And one more thung i would say,that Aneek adds very good variations to the songs.They sound new and beautiful.And yeah he is most versatile.where u can find a singer who can sing folk songs,rabindrasangeet,comedysongs,romantic ones,hip-hop(rap)numbers ,classical,fast ones ,patriotic songs,sad oneswith equal ease...? I have not heard anyone excelling in all genres EXCEPT aneek.so i wish to conclude that Aneek is the best!!👏!And will always be.May god showers all blessings to him.and he gets all success and prosperity in each walks of his life,as he deserves them.His singing and warm behaviour has surely won millions of hearts.He would definately be an established playback singer within few years.😊

Sreya

Originally posted by: LuckyJade

I recall that Aneek's performance was at least 2 or 3 weeks prior to Debo's (or, Aneek's performance was shown on tv 2 or 3 weeks prior to Debo's.) But you said that because you heard Debo's first that is why you liked it, i quoted that. :) However, you gave a fabulous point about why you like Debo's and noone can counter it: you liked his because it resonates with you and touched your soul and, remember, noone can argue with that because your feelings are yours, and they are personal to you. But, please, keep in mind that, for the record, your first contention about the chronology of the performances does not hold. But, i mean this, God bless and keep supporting Debo!

Originally posted by: akanna

I dont want to keep on arguing on this matter, as it wont change anything for either of us. 😃 Maybe that I liked Poonam and Raja over Aneek in C07, that I still havent felt so high about him. This year, I like Vaishali and Prathibha the most in the remaining ones, and then Soumen and Debo with some of their songs. Somehow Aneek didnt come across me as a strong singer. Just my opinion. But I dont have problems listening to him either, as he doesnt turn me off, so I can sit and watch him sing unlike some others. 😉

BTW, I thought he was 19 last year so that makes him 20 years old this year. 😊