This year none is as all rounded as Aneek - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

139

Views

7.1k

Users

26

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

paratha thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: jo_jo1214



Please do not label Amanat as just a Ghazal singer, he is very vesatile and talented and has proven that time and time again.

Amanat looked so ugly to me. How can you say he had x-factor? Mauli and Sumedha had x-factor and Shekhar(Judge) too.
b4begin thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#62

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

James version is the best than Aneek and Debo being last.....

You are spot on. James is like Kishore/Rafi in Bangladesh. I do not know if you heard his songs or not. Just type james and listen to his song, he has a tremendous voice. One cannot become a James that easily.
Maye be when aneek grows up.....
tansarbh thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#63
On the topic, you are right that this year, we don't have GOOD singers in the show as comapred to 2007.
Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: akanna

Possible. But since I heard them through those shows on TV, first Debo and then Aneek, somehow I couldnt enjoy Aneek's one as much as I did Debo's. No matter how many times I listen, it wont change - human mind setting. I havent heard the James' version, so I dont know, but I have heard KK's version, which I thought is closer to Debo's one than Aneek's. No offense - that is how I felt about it. Maybe that I never felt the connection with Aneek's song as much as I did for Debo's. 😊

Akannaji, you are entitled to your opinion but I just want to say that Aneek actually performed the song before Debo did. Debo sang it in challenge 2009, which came on televission in the beginning of July (and started airing in the US a month after words, in August.) Ekse Badhkar Ek started the season with Aneek on it in the beginning of June. Aneek's first performance was In Dino. After the jodis were formed, his first performance that would be scored was Bheegi Bheegi, which was sang on the second week of the show, before srgmp even started and before Debo sang. So, if you were watching the respective shows as they were being aired on tv, as you say you did, you would have seen Aneek's perf first. And the only reason you say you can't relate to Aneek's is that you heard Debo's first. Chronologically, it was Aneek then Debo. I am not trying to make you change your mind, i respect your views and I'm glad you are sharing them with us but, just for the record, i want to post who sang the song first.
akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: LuckyJade

Akannaji, you are entitled to your opinion but I just want to say that Aneek actually performed the song before Debo did. Debo sang it in challenge 2009, which came on televission in the beginning of July (and started airing in the US a month after words, in August.) Ekse Badhkar Ek started the season with Aneek on it in the beginning of June. Aneek's first performance was In Dino. After the jodis were formed, his first performance that would be scored was Bheegi Bheegi, which was sang on the second week of the show, before srgmp even started and before Debo sang. So, if you were watching the respective shows as they were being aired on tv, as you say you did, you would have seen Aneek's perf first. And the only reason you say you can't relate to Aneek's is that you heard Debo's first. Chronologically, it was Aneek then Debo. I am not trying to make you change your mind, i respect your views and I'm glad you are sharing them with us but, just for the record, i want to post who sang the song first.

No, the reason why I cant relate to Aneek's one is not because I heard Debo sing it first. I felt the conenction with Debo's song but I didnt feel the same with Aneek's. In the back of my mind, I felt I heard from Debo first and then Aneek, as Aneek sang that one towards the end of the ESBE season. Or could have been quite close to each other. Anyway, I still like Debo's one no matter what. Somehow couldnt feel for Aneek's song, whereas I felt the connection when I heard KK's too. I have to hear James' one now. 😃
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#66

Originally posted by: b4begin

You are spot on. James is like Kishore/Rafi in Bangladesh. I do not know if you heard his songs or not. Just type james and listen to his song, he has a tremendous voice. One cannot become a James that easily.
Maye be when aneek grows up.....

I have heard James voice b4 and his voice is very manly-strong...Aneeks voice will take dunno how long to get there..Agree with you there..😊
kuhu.kuhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#67

Originally posted by: LuckyJade

Akannaji, you are entitled to your opinion but I just want to say that Aneek actually performed the song before Debo did. Debo sang it in challenge 2009, which came on televission in the beginning of July (and started airing in the US a month after words, in August.) Ekse Badhkar Ek started the season with Aneek on it in the beginning of June. Aneek's first performance was In Dino. After the jodis were formed, his first performance that would be scored was Bheegi Bheegi, which was sang on the second week of the show, before srgmp even started and before Debo sang. So, if you were watching the respective shows as they were being aired on tv, as you say you did, you would have seen Aneek's perf first. And the only reason you say you can't relate to Aneek's is that you heard Debo's first. Chronologically, it was Aneek then Debo. I am not trying to make you change your mind, i respect your views and I'm glad you are sharing them with us but, just for the record, i want to post who sang the song first.

Soniia u r absolutely right ..Aneek's rendition of bheegi bheegi was mindblowing !!!!!...nobody did justice to the song the way he did IMO ....after the song was over ...Raja , Harpreet and all the contestants stood up from the chair and bowed ...that's how mesmerising he was .....when u generate such admiration from ur own fellow contestants then it's an aweinspiring experience ....and for us Aneek fans we have experienced such emotion and still do when we hear Aneek's renditions 😛
and I agree with u , belle and summer' and other Aneek fans views ( which completely went off track when people suddenly started comparing Aneek with other singers) ..that nobody in this year shares the versatility that Aneek had and still has👏 ......God bless other talented singers ..bhagwan un logon ko bahut tarakki de ...lekin Aneek's versatility is unmatchable in recent years IMO .....😃
Edited by bruno4 - 16 years ago
Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: akanna

No, the reason why I cant relate to Aneek's one is not because I heard Debo sing it first. I felt the conenction with Debo's song but I didnt feel the same with Aneek's. In the back of my mind, I felt I heard from Debo first and then Aneek, as Aneek sang that one towards the end of the ESBE season. Or could have been quite close to each other. Anyway, I still like Debo's one no matter what. Somehow couldnt feel for Aneek's song, whereas I felt the connection when I heard KK's too. I have to hear James' one now. 😃

I recall that Aneek's performance was at least 2 or 3 weeks prior to Debo's (or, Aneek's performance was shown on tv 2 or 3 weeks prior to Debo's.) But you said that because you heard Debo's first that is why you liked it, i quoted that. :) However, you gave a fabulous point about why you like Debo's and noone can counter it: you liked his because it resonates with you and touched your soul and, remember, noone can argue with that because your feelings are yours, and they are personal to you. But, please, keep in mind that, for the record, your first contention about the chronology of the performances does not hold. But, i mean this, God bless and keep supporting Debo!
Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#69

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

I have heard James voice b4 and his voice is very manly-strong...Aneeks voice will take dunno how long to get there..Agree with you there..😊

Truthfully, everyone's voice matures at its own pace but, i can tell you, Aneek's is taking leaps ahead toward full fledged maturity. Keep in mind he's only 18...
b4begin thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

I have heard James voice b4 and his voice is very manly-strong...Aneeks voice will take dunno how long to get there..Agree with you there..😊

He is only 18. Also he sould not have to be James. When he get a more mature voice throw in his range and varsatility .... No one can touch him.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".