Qubool hai decline - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

56

Views

7k

Users

31

Likes

441

Frequent Posters

GitaIyer thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#21
@nKapoor0
I asked a simple question. and read carefully, i said "I didn't get the meaning".
If that is rude, then what adjective should be given to your replies?
GoodGoneWrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#22
Gitey - just a like?
TM - Clarification since this was a long post and I forgot the beginning when I reached the end. Aren't u saying the entire TV industry is in decline? Or is it just QH? Or is QH the reason you realized the insipidity of the telly industry? I am actually quite lost as to the relation between the bigger picture and your title. Please elaborate.

Rivs
545636 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#23
i didn't understan this KSG fans.
u all selfish peoples
KSG already decied leave qh
& also he hasn't any probleme with qh
what is you all problem😕

TRP prove many qh fans accepts raqesh as asad.
qh always rocks

GitaIyer thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: QueenOfMyCastle

Gitey - just a like?

TM - Clarification since this was a long post and I forgot the beginning when I reached the end. Aren't u saying the entire TV industry is in decline? Or is it just QH? Or is QH the reason you realized the insipidity of the telly industry? I am actually quite lost as to the relation between the bigger picture and your title. Please elaborate.

Rivs

Rivs, I was too awed by your "Wow" comment.😉
Even I was confused about the post, and when I raised my confusion, I was called rude.😡
staker123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#25
sorry to say
but how is this possible that a person has stopped watching a show still she knows asad's character is butchered🤣


every one has moved on


qubool hai story😛
asya's marriage😳
TRP audience😉(2.9- much better than december)
qubool hai fans(who watch qubool hai for its story)👏
KSG himself
time for moving on😆
-RohitMaxwell- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#26
New ID! Daily Ban! M Tired! Same Scene!

Mod IP ban better option!
806047 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#27
I'm reminded of that Tina Fey quote from Bossypants: A good rating is a good rating, even if people tune in just to be mad about how much it sucked.
SurbhikiPankhi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#28
I think it's pointless to bash a show on its own forum. You're just inviting trouble or if you like cheap publicity
545636 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#29
I luv ksg but i fedup with "only" his fans.
please accept real&changes
GoodGoneWrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#30
I had to reread the post again to get the message. So I decided to quote. Only then will I be able to respond properly. Thanks for understanding.😃

Originally posted by: mamta-s

There has never been any sanity or continuity in Qubool hai from the start.The only factor that redeemed it was Karan's brilliant acting.No character has remained true and there is constant change for the worse.

I agree that no character has remained constant except for Razia and Billo. But I will not say that only Karan's acting redeemed the illogicality of the show. You see Karan would not have picked up the show had the story been stupid, silly and run of the mill to begin with. So giving the guy's intelligence some credit, I infer that the story had dum(potential) since the beginning. And since the stroy is what brought Karan in, I will say that it was the redeeming factor, the intrigue behind the main plot that is. With me so far?

I presume this is the reason Karan would have had differences and been evicted when he protested.I admire the man for having the courage to walk tall.You could see the change in Asad's persona after the first nikah interruption and unfortunately for the worse.How often have we lamented the decline in charectirization but our pleas always fell on deaf ears.Now of course the Asad on screen bears no resemblance to our original Asad who had us hooked to the show.He has changed physically but along with that even his character has been slaughtered.His attitude towards Zoya has lost its original sensitivity which was so endearing.
The latest bonding between Asad and Haider is a shocker!!!How much can the CVs alter a pivotal character so drastically? They have now totally destroyed him.Our Asad would never forget that Haider is wooing the girl who was Ayaan's life and encourage him !
Yes Karan did protest and quite loudly too, but only after ZoYaan was finalized. But the story went downhill before then, when Tannu track got stretched and focus shifted from GF to Tannu. NajRan angle did not help either. but I guess since KV and its inhabitants were front, line and center, no one had a reason to complains. Neither Karan fans, nor AsYa fans and not KaBhi fans either. Make sense?
I will not argue about the comment on the decline of the AAK and his character. It was done and the story was altered.
Now the Asad/Haider bond. I guess when u are in a life altering situation, the first person to lend you a supportive hand, will forever be someone you stay indebted to. I have first hand experienced it when my nephew had to undergo treatment for a fatal genetic condition in a foreign (for him and his family) land and had to depend on strangers for more than a year. We are as a family, forever indebted to everyone who stepped up to help at that time. And if I remember the scene correctly, every over friendly gesture from Haider did receive a AAK look of discomfort. Not the one u are used to, obviously. And as a few of the other members in the forum explained to me, if the girl in question has defended to move on, who is Asad to stop anyone? Jab miya biwi razi to kya kahega Qazi? Suna hai?

Qubool Hai has now become a total waste of good time.And this is the feeling I get when I do not even watch it.If the degradation is apparent from the comments made on this forum how much worse it must be to see it on screen!!
So your above statement about the Asad-Haider scene was based on what you read in the forum? This totally explains your views. My dear friend, either you are not reading all the posts, or you are sticking to the ones that are made to criticize only by a certain faction of the forum. Unfortunate but true.

What is puzzling is Gul Khan allowing this to happen!We have seen that she is capable of lyrical romance sans vulgarity..so why is she permitting the Channel to destroy her concept?Surely the better option would be to walk out handing the reins to Zee and a typical saas bahu production
house instead of standing by silently and watching the slaughter.
Is it pakka news that the Channel is running the show now? 😲 In that case, I feel extremely bad for Gul, since this is her only show on air now, given that Arjun is being pulled off. She is left with nothing.😕 Yes it will be better for her to remain jobless and render her staff jobless just so that a group of people, who are not even watching the show, can be pleased. What you say and infer makes perfect sense to me, I think. NOT.

An analysis of the changes in the basic persona of the QH characters will explain the decline as well as the reason for so many leaving the show.Almost no one has remained true to their original avatar. While accepting the dictum that change is the only constant surely the change should be for the better.
I hate to disagree with you, but the TRPs just went up, to prove the point that not a lot of people have walked away from the show. Actually the viewership increased.😊

1.Asad is no longer the endearing young man who hid his many layered personality behind a disciplined facade.And that is purely because the new actor does not have the capability to emote as brilliantly as KSG...no offence to him as he tries his best but Karan's shoes are far too big for
anyone to fill.But I thought that the Asad u are referring to here was already dead a long time ago. Did you not just say that in the beginning of the post. Let me scroll and check. Yes you said Asad declined after the first nikah attempt. So this is in contradiction to what u earlier stated. I would rather not discuss RV since Asad declined while KSG was there as you yourself stated.
2.Ayaan ,unable to cope up with the changes just fled the scene.
Do you read articles? Or see his interviews? or is he your neighbor? VM left, due to bollywood commitments, ones that were made known since the time he was applauded for his work in Lootera. Just correcting u here. And the PH and Channel actually changed tracks to allow him the leave he needed. Something, very few PHs and channels would do, not for the one of the main 3 characters of the show.
3.Nikhat is the one character who has suffered worse fate than even Asad.Her's has been a seesaw journey veering between strength and total lunacy.Archana Taide obviously does not have the seniority to protest as is obvious from the fact that her name is missing from the popular cast.
Wasn't it the forumwasis who kept harping on the karma of Shireen and her badduas biting her back in the form of Nikhat's despair?
4.Shireen's character was unstable from the beginning ..a sort of tragic/comedy relief but she too disappears unable to accept the havoc.
Again another actor who was allowed to take a break from the show. How accomodating of the PH and the channels? Don't ya agree?
5.Dilshad, who was the most appreciated after Asad looks a stranger.Her current avatar does no credit to her initial sobriety.
Agreed. That was just lame what they did to Dilshaad.
6.Humeira is now hardly recognisable and so distanced from her innocent earlier self
she was never innocent IMO. She was always manipulating but yes she was endearing. Remember her tricks to hurt Ayaan?
7.Rashid, the man responsible for the entire drama that is QH started as a weak man but not able to slip further has now been rendered totally helpless after a comatose spell and is now moving around speechless in a wheel chair.
I rather not discuss him...😡
8.Gaffur the other man responsible for the angst in the lives of the people in QH is always alternating between good and evil.He has perhaps finally found his correct persona...do betiyon ka troubled baap !
Yup given. What acting from Tejji to show his troubles.👏
9.Badi Bi's journey keeps alternating,between some of the worst human rights violations shown on ITV, to a total absence and then merely as a passive bystander.
Another character I refuse to acknowledge.
10.Tanveer is the only one to remain true to her original character ..so true that she refuses to give birth to a child of so many fathers! My guess is that the latest to be trapped by her is Zanab Gaffur! So from becoming Zoya's sauten she will now be her step mom.This is the only clue that QH may continue after the fall of Razia.Tanveer will move centre stage to wreak havoc in the lives of all now.
11.Nazma as everyone already knows is no longer the endearing Tamatar of her Bhaijaan ...she has been pushed into the background as soon as she entered the spooky environs of QM.
Najma was killed a long time ago. Let's not bring it up now as a reason for decline.

That brings us to the crazy Qureshis and the less said about them the better ...they remain the unwanted fillers they always were.
Yup. But u forgot Nuzhat, the other filler. And Wajid, my main man?😆

So the only two who have been able to hold their own,with minor aberrations,are Razia and Zoya.

Thus the QH Circus continues!Whether it is curtains or a continuation depends on the TRPs after the culmination of most famously interrupted nikah .
Let's wait and see. I don't care one way or the other as long as the main story that drew me in is told.

This brings me to the crux of my long spiel.We the viewers are at the receiving end of the Channels' ego more then the actors,techinicians and production houses.We are also the ones to hold the remote.It is time we made a concerted effort to bring some order in this totally bizarre scenario.Instead of wasting valuable time fighting for naught we must unite to use that remote and enforce our rights emphatically.
Where did the channel come in suddenly? Oh yes, ur assumption that they are running the show right now in the guise of 4L anf Gul.
I am glad u have decided to use the remote. If you don't like it, don't watch it makes a lot of sense to me. but I am liking it, so I will not be following your request. But I am sure that those who are fighting will listen to your appeal, since they are obviously not liking the show, just like you. I am in total agreement with you.

A qualitative change has to be enforced in the grim world of our television industry. True.

Channels must end their Czarist attitude and put their own house in order.
Shows should be made with bound scripts and a well defined story.
Pre-production work should be completed before shooting commences.
The show must end when the story does.Maybe a new season can continue after a break.
All associated with the show should be treated as professionals at par with those working in other fields and not like bonded labour.
Agreed.

That is what we the viewers should ensure and work towards. Use the remote and move on as it is a strong weapon in our hands. Another very important one is to appeal to sponsors to not endorse shows that hinge on the ludicrous. If they persist we may alert them that we will boycott the use of their products too. I will definitely not be using anything advertised on QH.
Why should I work for the channels to change? Are they paying me to entertain me? No. I am paying them and in turn they are entertaining me with one or many of their shows. Well I don't watch many, but I refer to the many other's who feel like me.
So in order to boycott the products on QH, you will watch it? But I thought u said u stopped. You are really not being consistent my friend.

We can appeal to official forums like IBF/BCCC which is a quasi govt organisation to help us clean the stable.
Clean QH? Clean the telly industry? And are the official forums here. It is kind of a moot point to make appeals here when no one here has the power to do what u are asking. How about starting a blog or some other type of movement to achieve this end? I will render support in what I agree with.

So friends this is a Channel vs Audience campaign.Karan is better off outside the madness of Qubool Hai now :)
So now we are back to Karan and the channel and everything. I am so confused with how this post goes from one point to another totally random point. But I do agree, Karan is better outside QH. I totally agree there. For an actor who was never sincere in the job he took and had only committed for a short period (as displayed by the statement that he was going to leave a long time back and he did not have a new contract) has no place in a show that stll has life remaining.

Edit: Wow that was a long response. I just got carried away like the TM and had to respond or put forth my opinions.
Edited by QueenOfMyCastle - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Qubool Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: jyoti06

7 years ago

Qubool Hai Creations Gallery #21

Qubool Hai C r e a t i o n s G a l l e r y # 21 _______________________________________________________________ Please post all your creations

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".