Tahzeeb of Asad Ahmed Khan,Thank You note-11 - Page 13

Originally posted by: ElishaAmir

you are welcome dear...

Originally posted by: crazy4KASH_AR

It seems that the rest of the forum agree with my analysis of Asad's Tahzeeb-ul-Akhlaq
What are your views people about Asad's behaviour?
Come on,share it openly and let's have a good time in discussing our favourite character.
Why has this thread become so silent all of a sudden?

Originally posted by: ElishaAmir

its elisha. from toronto. i am a silent watcher :). dont participate tht much in the forum. but i liked the post u made and u analyzed the points soo well i had to thank you for tht.

Originally posted by: bary

hey asma,see how asad is with ayaan saying about how he will make a bad impression on girls if he cried,see it seems like is he the same asad,asad is a brother there while he plays a father with najma,well dont know if its for good or bad,i feel so bad for najma,she is soo damn cute too
oh and again like i thought zoya may make some impression on najma in near future coz she lives in same house now,god how i like zoya to see the match again coz najma and zoya are like two poles while najma hides the remote when she sees her brother zoya shouts for the recorded match..looking forward to see them both with asad

Originally posted by: shafaqsheikh

<font color="#000033">luved your post...</font>

Originally posted by: crazy4KASH_AR

I'm quite disappointed with the fact that you feel that this thread is converted into a cast issue.

Also, I would request you not to linger on a point like forever...

Sorry but the title says-Tahzeeb of Asad Ahmed Khan exctlyyy..you shud have pointed out at that... but you related it with cast...you shuld have remained with asad thoughts and his thinking ...

It clearly indicates that here I have made this thread to throw some light on Asad's character in the light of his culture. a culture cant be a property of one man...as you tated darling...his culture...it can be his thoughts of tehzeb and his ideas and way of leaving

Also, one does not follow everything that has been preached in a religion at times.Remaining knowing ignorant about certain beliefs has become quite popular these days.So you can't really say that one is wrong and one is right.A culture does the preaching and people follow whatever they feel comfortable with their personalities and remain knowingly ignorant with those values which they can't connect with logically.A culture always appreciates people to follow what they can from their hearts and not for the sake of showing off.
So kindly avoid pointing about what Islam says and not says in relation to Zoya and her family. why swetuuu?why cant i say about it when you are pointing out asad thoughts and doings and dont's in the light of islam... is asad cast different from zoya jiju cast...????

You are not wrong at all Payal in saying that Asad is acting like a typical Indian male.I would better say Asad has acted like a typical male of any house of any religion of any country who would show concern about his sister partying out late night.He never said that he is going to remain with Najma and see what she does there.Also,he didn't stop her from going to lounge.The only thing he stopped her was from wearing jeans.
Yes, Islam says women should try to avoid wearing apparels that give them a resemblance of a male.
I request you not to challenge something which has been conveyed directly to all females from Allah with the help of the prophets of Islam.then you mean to say zoya and her family and even asad own sister dissobying there own cast??? Allah must have had a reason for it and I personally don't dare to challenge this thing on the basis of freedom ,etc related issues.
Man is the best survivor and possesses the capability to adjust in whatever conditions are presented before him.Over the years,Indians have also changed their thinking and adapted to the lifestyle of the west which is called modern by many people. who said we have adopted west... to be come modern...have you read early vedic and later vedic...you will come to knwo the surprise fact ke we were more advance then western were...lolzzz..its so funnyyy we were advanced from west 1000 yrs before and in later vedic we threw ourself behind nonsence customs and stupidity and called it necessity and importnace and god's choice...
Islam has requested females to hide their beauty just like people hide expensive jewels with the help of loose clothes,purdah and decent least revealing dresses.It has not ordered anyone to follow it by hook or by crook.Muslim women have started wearing jeans and all modern outfits by making their own relaxations and adjusting their looks and attire in such a way that they look modern yet elegant in any dress they put on.
Another meaning of Tahzeeb is elegant also by the way.
When did I or anyone said that Zoya or her family is not following Islam?
AS I've said before Zoya looks graceful in whatever she wears. Plz note that her T-shirts/tops are never revealing or vulgar.
To avoid vulgarity is most important for a girl of any culture and Islam also tries to indicate that women should never appear vulgar and literally offer themselves to lustful eyes of men intentionally or unintentionally. exctlyyy...this is what i meant..cant his sister wear jeans with top reveling nothing...i at that time also said and i will say again same... it is asad choice asad thinking asad wants ke his sister should not wear jeans... where as you enlighted it in the light of asad islamic thought..and then i counter-attacked you if its in islam then why zoya is wearing it..if its against it what you stated then how come his jiju and appe prctising otherwise???? look did you yest. episode...in one point you stated ke for other hapiness asad sisiter is wearing jeans and thats why he stoped her,coz she not wearing for her own thoughts and hapiness...because all her friends are wearing and now she too wants to wear...then in yest. episode his other step sis was wearing entirely for her own wish and hapinesss...yet again he made her change...isnt it clear and so quit openly stated ke its asad choice..his demand...his need...his thinking... there is nothing like any cast and its belief...

i am extremly hurt ke you think i am directly chalenging your prophet..how can i do that...for me evry cast is n top ... for me its most respectable part of humantiy... this is what shape a human being ... yes i questiond but you are the one i questioned... coz you were not enlighting asad thoughts but his thoughts under his cast... and that made me question you ... ke if he doing things under cast as you analyised then why others are not doing it...if acording to you he is not wrong then who are doing other wise is then wrong ... thats why i said .. its asad need...his thoughts... his belief .. his demand ... there is nothing related to cast or its discremnation and beliefs ... its an individual personality entirelyyy

Asad seriously didn't commit a crime by stopping Najma from wearing jeans and going out.And plz don't keep on insisting that if for him suit is the dress for office then for Najma why is jeans not the best attire.At the end of the day,Najma has faith in her brother and since her childhood she has been looking upto her bhaijaan for all the decisions of her life.Now when she is about to change her personality by giving a try to jeans for the sake of pleasing her friends,I don't expect Asad or any brother of this world to say yes to her request in the first place.
Asad has been used to giving advices to his sister and he is the fatherly figure of this house.Had Asad been really wrong,I am sure Asad's mom must have been the first person to oppose him.She remained silent throughout the conversation of Asad and Najma because she knew that brother and sister have a great bond and can decide among themselves without her interference.Dilshad didn't say anything to Najma which clearly means that she didn't oppose the idea of Najma going out in a jeans with her friends but at the same time she understood the most important logic of her son's statement that changing yourself by forgetting your beliefs and doing this for the sake of pleasing others is highly inappreciable.You want a change do it for yourself,not for others-is one of the hidden motives of Asad's statement.

Honestly speaking, the way in which Najma asked permission from Asad was not very convincing.
Had she really been interested in wearing jeans and not redefining her personality because of her friends and lounge,her way of seeking advise from her bhaijaan must have been completely different.And as far as I have understood Asad, he does not have the heart to deny his baby sister again and again.Eventually, he must have bowed down to his sister's wishes upon a lot of persistence provided she wanted to change her dressing style for herself and not for others.

And yes I used Islam to highlight this scene other than using the typical Indian culture because unlike other cultures, western outfits and Muslim culture have always been a debatable issue.So, I thought that by using Asad's character as he is playing the role of a modern Muslim guy I can state a few points in relation to jeans western dresses and Muslim culture.
Frankly speaking,it is quite easy to consider Asad saying the statement to Najma because he is a muslim just like it is easy for you to say that he behaved just like a typical Indian.just imagine someone who has never came across Indians or the culture is watching this show using English subtitles,he will relate to this statement of Asad in the light of the culture he follows rather than the country to which he belongs.

Also, my intention of making this thread was to relate Asad's traditions with his attitude and traditions include both the religion and country to which you belong.
I have highlighted all the scenes of Asad to elaborate how I have seen his 'tahzeeb' in his actions.
I was here not to preach people about Islam but to connect Asad's traditions with his attitude and behaviour.

Well this is my point of view Payal and you have all the right to still disagree and differ from me.
After this post I really give up because Payal dear if you have decided to keep the right to freedom topmost in your mind because then I can't help you.
According to me,freedom in limits is much better than careless freedom.This is true for all boys and girls.
I would like to put a rest to this debate because I don't get any new idea of giving my logic for Asad's statement and your concerns.
Also, it would be a bit early to call Asad a typical Indian patriach just because of a single statement.
As I've said before,his character is hidden in layers and we definitely need time to unravel different shades of his character.
I request you to be a little patient and give a little bit of more time to Asad to see if he is really a conformist or a guy with modern thinking but rooted to his culture at the same time.


I apologize if any statement of mind has offended you unintentionally.I completely understand your concern and point of view.The reason why you have asked this question is completely justified and I highly appreciate the way you have put across your points.Plz try to go through this post with an open mind and don't take anything to your heart.I really value our friendship and I hope this debate won't bring any change in it.

PS-I hope u've gone through the post where I've requested you to go through some posts where people have shared their personal experiences in this thread.That is the reason I had not yet replied to your questions darling...

Anyways I'm loving this discussion a lot
Take care sweety
love you
Muah!