A Different Perspective? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

3.3k

Users

16

Likes

71

Frequent Posters

Abie10 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
Great post samana you've made good points but I still want to knock Gayu's head. I do agree she is in a difficult phrase but why accept yash being najayaz to the world? Why call yash ganda khoon in the previous epi ? In the last epi gayu clearly showed blood and nothing else.
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: jyoti06

Samana I said more or less in one of my posts I made about Gayatri and Yash both .. as much as I felt bad for Yash , I felt equally bad for Gayatri since it was not easy for her either to make such a complicated decision but she made because she knows Yash inside out and she knows that she can afford to take Yash for granted which is not the case with Akash

Like u said , Gayatri dint measure the consequences or never thought Akash can stoop so low and misuse his powers .. she just did what she could to make sure Akash dont leave ... she never thought this will result in Yash being treated like a servant ...

I still dont support Gayatri here because of the way she overnight made a decision but I understand from where she is coming in this case 🤔



@bold: But that is just it, what choice did she have? Akash was not going to stay unless all his demands were met. He was not in a rational mood to negotiate because for him it's all or nothing and he made that very clear to her. She made a decision on the spur of the moment, based on what she knew, because someone had to take decisive action. She knew she couldn't let Akash leave or it would do irrevocable damage to the sensitive thread that connected them now. With Yash, she knows their relationship can withstand such a sacrifice, like you said.


Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: DMKJ_VB

Samana- fantastic post! But as I said in the DC...though I agree with lot of what u said about gayatri...I think she does prefer her blood relations over Yash! I would be glad If I am proved wrong and u r proved right though, as that would make PV so much more intriguing!



I hope I am proved right too!

I think there was a reason they showed Gayatri supporting Yash and Aarti in the custody battle and then being overjoyed when Yash won Ansh's custody. Once Gayatri accepts you from her heart, she is fiercely loyal and pretty much nothing can shake that foundation, though she may say hurtful, petty things day-to-day.
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: gafulu14

agree, but certain point g3 has to not accept lie n everything sky demand



What other choice did she have?

She is trying to show Akash that she loves him as much as her other sons. If she falters then he will never believe her.
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: ..MissLonely..

I think I'm one of the Odd ones myself ...lol will elaborate soon =P

-Nice Post Samana <3



Glad to hear it, and can't wait for the elaboration! 😊
Edited by Samanalyse - 12 years ago
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Mohini19

Nice post.

The storyline is getting ridiculous with every episode.
Ah, I beg to differ. I think the storyline is fantastic and one of the best we have had on PV!

Thanks to Ms. Aarti Scindia for putting yash and the family through this entire mess.
No thanks to Mr. SP for cheating on his wife and then lying about it? No thanks to Radha for switching the babies at birth and depriving Akash of his rights? Aarti is the one at fault here, really? 😕

The entire child swapping, legit and illegit child track has so many loopholes and bloopers.

  1. What was Radha doing all these years? Why appear suddenly now out of nowhere?

She told Aarti she didn't want the secret ever to come out but it slipped out in anger when SP was humiliating Akash in front of everyone. I guess she showed up at the wedding because she just found out her son was working for his father and wanted to stop him? That is a little more fishy but why she revealed the truth after all these years is clear... it was an accident.

  1. Why is it that Aarti needed the truth to come out so badly? She didn't think about the repercussions at all.

Because it was the right thing to do. Of course she thought about the repercussions! She saw the repercussions happening in front of her eyes: men unknowingly harassing their own brother because their father had the audacity to lie about his past deeds.

  1. What was the need to bring Radha into the house? That was so stupid.

She is Yash's birth mother and he has a duty towards her. That is why he invited her. I agree that it complicates things a great deal but if anything Radha should have refused to come. Yash invited her out of duty and that was right and proper by me.

  1. Radha was missing when yash brought a drunken Aakash from the bar. Why does she conveniently appear and disappear as it suits her? This is so stupid.

I agree on this one. I am waiting for a lot of Radha confrontations!

  1. Aarti becomes a leader when it comes to telling the truth and all. Why was she silent when G3 and Pankaj were questioning yash for slapping Aakash?
  2. What was the need for Aarti to go to the pub just by herself? It makes ZERO sense.

Because it might have done nothing more than to make the situation worse. Her whole idea behind going to the bar was so that the family did not find out what Akash had done, so their newfound acceptance wouldn't go down the drain. It was dangerous, stupid even, but it did make sense. She was just following through when she remained silent.


Oh well, the list is endless. But, I'll stop here.

Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: ratnaprabhashri

I will say that at present im not angry or support g3 all decision she could have given a thought to the demand of akash and than agree with some of it for now and as time progress she could have agree with some other demands by fullfiling akash each demand at one goe i dont agree with her and if her beh for yash will not change in future too seeing how akash is misbehaving with him i will total disagree with the post regarding g3 beh or justification ofit



I don't think Akash was in a mood to negotiate. He made it pretty clear that it was all or nothing, so she chose all to make sure he didn't leave.
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: lulujjj

Nice analysis Samana loved it into bits dear gayathri and yash understand each other very well and she knows deep inside her heart yash would agree with her decisions even if sp rejects it.


Kitni batein really that scene seeing yash and gayathri in pain ,made me cry and aakash demands were spot on, no one could doubt his intentions the dialogues were written in his favour. Loved the episode.



Yes, Gayatri and Yash do have a wonderful, tacit understanding. They are both hurt by having to take this step but they both understand why it is necessary. I loved that they both formed a united front, even against SP himself!
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Abie10

Great post samana you've made good points but I still want to knock Gayu's head. I do agree she is in a difficult phrase but why accept yash being najayaz to the world? Why call yash ganda khoon in the previous epi ? In the last epi gayu clearly showed blood and nothing else.



She has to agree to Yash being najayaz if she wants to declare Akash as jayaz. The whole of Bhopal knows that SP has only 3 sons so how else can they say that Akash is jayaz, unless there is a switch? I read the blood comment a bit differently. Gayatri asked Yash if he was trying to prove that he was Radha's son, through the comment, implying that he should deny his gandha blood and stand by his "good upbringing" instead. If you think about it, the comment actually meant, prove that you are my son and not Radha's by behaving the way I brought you up to behave and not the way her blood makes you.
Abie10 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Samanalyse



She has to agree to Yash being najayaz if she wants to declare Akash as jayaz. The whole of Bhopal knows that SP has only 3 sons so how else can they say that Akash is jayaz, unless there is a switch? I read the blood comment a bit differently. Gayatri asked Yash if he was trying to prove that he was Radha's son, through the comment, implying that he should deny his gandha blood and stand by his "good upbringing" instead. If you think about it, the comment actually meant, prove that you are my son and not Radha's by behaving the way I brought you up to behave and not the way her blood makes you.



That was my main issue,why dint she think of her upbringing first? Gayu have always supported yash knowing that he will always take the right decision. Where was all the trust then? From a viewers POV wont I see her in a different view that her blood is overshadowing her 30yrs upbringing.

Edit: I think this the first time u replied to my post even when It's not DC thanks it means alot..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".