A Different Perspective?

Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
I realised I have a different perspective on the episode than most people so I thought I would post some of my thoughts for you all to consider. I would love to know what you think!

I don't see what Gayatri did today as making Yash paraya at all. In fact to my eyes, she asserted even more that Yash was apna and Akash paraya, because only those who we truly accept as our own can we take for granted. I know ideally a parent should not choose between two children and favour one or the other but situations do arise when you have no choice, and you have to choose the kid who needs your support the most. Gayatri knows she is taking a risk here, but she also knows that Yash is fiercely loyal to her and she and him have built a relationship over thirty years. She has cultivated the right to his unconditional understanding and the fact that Yash gives it willingly shows this.

It is killing her to do this but her feelings aside, the fact remains that it is unfair that Akash was stripped of everything that should have been his and Yash got it instead. Everyone in Bhopal knows that SP has only three sons and there is no way to say that Akash is legitimate without saying Yash is not. These are all technicalities to Gayatri who loves Yash as her own son, but these technicalities are what are causing the most angst in Akash. In my opinion, Gayatri is being a good parent by removing the cause of Akash's angst first, giving in to all his demands, so they can proceed to build a real relationship with as little baggage as possible. She already has a relationship with Yash and so this is her priority now. I can totally forgive her that and in fact think she is doing the right thing.

Sometimes mothers have to be the bad guys when nobody else wants to take the flak and that is what I see Gayatri doing. Yes, she is favouring Akash over Yash and yes she is calling the son she lovingly raised "najaayaz" but nobody else seems to be willing to take the steps necessary to integrate Akash. Gayatri is doing what must be done for her children, even if it makes her look like the villain of the story. Isn't that what being a parent is all about on some level?

The only thing she hasn't bargained for is Akash's nefarious intentions and the insincerity of his demands. She doesn't know that Akash not only wants his share but wants to humiliate Yash and thereby SP who refuses to acknowledge him. The catch is that SP sees this, and the more he sees Yash suffer, the more he will be pushed to take on the punishment himself. He loves Yash and at some point his tether is going to break and he is going to jump in to save Yash from the pain he is taking on because of SP's refusal to take responsibility. Gayatri can only do so much by herself, especially with Akash threatening to leave. SP has to be the one to "discipline" Akash and teach him how to live with his siblings through his acceptance, just as Yash did with Ansh when he first came to the house. Only when Akash feels unconditional acceptance will he acknowledge the authority of SP, and SP won't accept Akash until he changes himself and plays by the rules of the house. It is a vicious cycle that Gayatri is trying desperately to break.

Seeing Yash hurt and humiliated is what is finally going to make SP proactive, so this phase is very important. During the debate track, Aarti had to side with Palak for obvious reasons, and Ansh did feel the pinch. But what consoled him was learning that he might not have mumma's undivided attention anymore, but that when mumma was busy elsewhere, he could always turn to his papa. Gayatri is doing the same thing here. Just like Aarti had to build a relationship with Palak from scratch and so had to give her priority and snub Ansh, Gayatri is doing the same with Akash. The only difference is that she does not have SP's support the way that Aarti had Yash's and so one child is going to come out feeling unfairly treated and neglected.

Could we blame Aarti then for what she had to do, even though it meant Ansh feeling like his mother wanted him to lose? Can we really blame Gayatri now?

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

3.2k

Users

16

Likes

71

Frequent Posters

pickachu thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Nice post samana!
But still i don't knw why i don't feel bad for gayatri at all!
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Samana I said more or less in one of my posts I made about Gayatri and Yash both .. as much as I felt bad for Yash , I felt equally bad for Gayatri since it was not easy for her either to make such a complicated decision but she made because she knows Yash inside out and she knows that she can afford to take Yash for granted which is not the case with Akash

Like u said , Gayatri dint measure the consequences or never thought Akash can stoop so low and misuse his powers .. she just did what she could to make sure Akash dont leave ... she never thought this will result in Yash being treated like a servant ...

I still dont support Gayatri here because of the way she overnight made a decision but I understand from where she is coming in this case 🤔
DMKJ_VB thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Samana- fantastic post! But as I said in the DC...though I agree with lot of what u said about gayatri...I think she does prefer her blood relations over Yash! I would be glad If I am proved wrong and u r proved right though, as that would make PV so much more intriguing!
gafulu14 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
agree, but certain point g3 has to not accept lie n everything sky demand
..CountingStars thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
I think I'm one of the Odd ones myself ...lol will elaborate soon =P
-Nice Post Samana <3
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: pickachu

Nice post samana!

But still i don't knw why i don't feel bad for gayatri at all!



Because she is taking the plunge and being the bad guy when the actual bad guys refuse to take responsibility for their actions. SP comes out looking all loving and concerned for Yash and Radha just looks like she is suffering this battle between both her sons when in fact both of them refuse to do anything proactive to improve the situation! Gayatri looks like the bad guy because she is taking responsibility for the mess that those two created and doing the best she can to actually work with it.

Akash needs to believe that Gayatri will put him above everything else for him to start feeling any sense of apnapan. Someone had to take the first step and she did and took the fall for it. That's why she looks like the bad guy.
Mohini19 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Nice post.

The storyline is getting ridiculous with every episode.

Thanks to Ms. Aarti Scindia for putting yash and the family through this entire mess.

The entire child swapping, legit and illegit child track has so many loopholes and bloopers.

  1. What was Radha doing all these years? Why appear suddenly now out of nowhere?
  2. Why is it that Aarti needed the truth to come out so badly? She didn't think about the repercussions at all.
  3. What was the need to bring Radha into the house? That was so stupid.
  4. Radha was missing when yash brought a drunken Aakash from the bar. Why does she conveniently appear and disappear as it suits her? This is so stupid.
  5. Aarti becomes a leader when it comes to telling the truth and all. Why was she silent when G3 and Pankaj were questioning yash for slapping Aakash?
  6. What was the need for Aarti to go to the pub just by herself? It makes ZERO sense.

Oh well, the list is endless. But, I'll stop here.
Edited by Mohini19 - 12 years ago
ratnaprabhashri thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

I will say that at present im not angry or support g3 all decision she could have given a thought to the demand of akash and than agree with some of it for now and as time progress she could have agree with some other demands by fullfiling akash each demand at one goe i dont agree with her and if her beh for yash will not change in future too seeing how akash is misbehaving with him i will total disagree with the post regarding g3 beh or justification ofit

lulujjjj thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Nice analysis Samana loved it into bits dear gayathri and yash understand each other very well and she knows deep inside her heart yash would agree with her decisions even if sp rejects it.

Kitni batein really that scene seeing yash and gayathri in pain ,made me cry and aakash demands were spot on, no one could doubt his intentions the dialogues were written in his favour. Loved the episode.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".