The lagging lead on liberalism front! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

2.8k

Users

24

Likes

158

Frequent Posters

raosudha thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
I do agree that lately CV's are not showing Pratz as a strong woman.
But Pratigya is portrayed as stong woman and that is how this serial started. she has always stood up against injustice so many times. If you are watching MKAP for two and a half years you will know that is how she is portrayed.
Answers for some of those questions:
1. Pratigya is living in Thakur Family. They are rich. It is a joint family. Thakur women don't work outside of their family. Pratigya will have enough work inside the house. Probably Krishna's thinking is that there is no need for her to work outside the house. But if P really needed the work and if she had to, I am sure if she discussed with Krishna, he would have agreed. But it was Krishna who had to work, so she convinced him to work. Because she did not want them to depend on SS. Krishna did start working eventually. Pratigya helped Krishna to start a business and did work in the Dabha for a while. But she could not continue because she had problems with Shakthi's complaints and enough to do at home.
In Arush's case it is different. Tanmay does not make enough money. Arushi had to work to pay rent and stuff. She had no choice.
2. Prtigya tried everything she can to prevent crimes in the Thakur family. She even made Shakti and Amma go to jail almost. It did not happen, because Kesar withdrew her complaint. Pratigya has always raised her voice against injustice. No one is perfect. Even a presidet or a Prime Minister could do only so much. We cannot make people do what we want.
3. Pratigya tried to stop Arushi's marriage is what any sister would do. Aman was already married. I would do the same thing what Pratigya did. What did Arushi do on the other hand. She did not trust her sister. She committed bigamy by marrying KN and tried her best to break her sister's marriage.
About Pratigya spending more time with Krishna I do agree that Pratigya should spend more time with Krishna and not with Samar all the time. Also, Samar is old enough to sleep in another bedroom.
All in all, no one is perfect. Pratz is alwys trying to do what she can. There are always limits to what one could do. About Krishna's remarriage issue I don't know why she did not try to stop it earlier. May be she was too hurt or she thought Krishna would not go through with it. But CV's have messed it up somewhere here.
About Arushi, she should not interfere in her sister's private and personal problems. It is not her place to disclose Krishna's infertility problem with her family. It is an invasion of privacy.
I agree with you abour krishna's infertility issue, Pratz should have told the truth to him.
telstra thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: ssrbaqri

Hi frndz,


The common perception is that Pratz is a strong lady who never yields to injustice. This makes some people to view her as a role model. But sadly I hv drawn an altogether different conclusion from the show. Sample this:
what a gm post anyways i am here sharing mine pov and as topic maker u have to accept everyones pov and i sincerely dont want anyone to grant me a degree of sanity or insanity on basis of mine pov i hope its clear
1. When Krishna asked her not to work in the office so as to earn money, she simply surrendered and did not even protest. In comparison, when Tanmay forced Arushi to abandon job, she refused to give in to his unjust demand. Here, Arushi emerges as the leading lady and a better icon of women liberalism.hmm in mariage if either one hubby or wifey is angry no need of other to do same aswell no need to fight to other one on same pitch . it kills the love between a couple. yes arushi offended tanmay and chose career over family and u can easily see where her marriage heading. as for pratigya she chose family hubby over career and see somewhere thakurs too respect her and krishna he too love her patience is important and she will get her reward for being patient soon prats will acheiveboth career and hubby love and understanding in one stroke.
2. Pratz has been staying at TN for past 5 years and has seen thakurs commmitting all sort of crimes. Although she protested against such practices on certain occasions but she has never been able to secure justice being delivered to her criminal in-laws. In terms of output, she has been a huge failure as a daughter in law whatever prats did was more than enough on every occassion she atleast raised her voice against wrong doings and sometimes she wins too see kesar in hspital getting treated its always better to stand up for right rather than keeping mum and win no win doesnot matter. .
3. Despite having so many troubles in her own life, she has constantly been intruding into others' territories. Like she interfered in Arushi's personal life by stopping her marriage to Aman. Infact, it was this foolishly handled move that ended up in Arushi marrying KN. Arushi was justified in turning hostile b'coz Pratz failed to produce any conclusive proof of Aman's cheating, in time.lol arushi personal life was not started yet at that point of time and prats was doing it as she knew aman is married and she has done it to protect aman wife marriage plus obviously she knew her sis life is a stake whom she loved a lot she did brought proves but its amans wife fate that she was not able to stand up for her relationship prrats did what any concerned sis will do but arushi her marriage to kn was never justified as before that too in aman case we saw she was geting jealous from her sis and feeling proud that she got educated rich aman and she never listened her elder sis.her choice
4. As a wife, she has been unsuccessful in giving quality time to her hubby. I wud never recommend any wife to follow in her footsteps.😆😆😆😆we r no one to judge her as wife as per her character portrayel and whatever cvs showed us krishna is very happy with her and she is there for krishna whenever he wants
All this only proves that Pratz is not behaving as one wud expect from a lead of women-centric show.

hmm basically mens r hypocrites they always appreciate a working women a bold beautiful smart girls but when its questioned whom they want as a life partner they always choose seedhi saadhi a girl who bow down to his wishes .
if wife sacrifice some private moments as she was doing something for hubby family hubbies feels proud of it but never admits
MERARAI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: elle45

I agree on certain parts of your initial post. Arushi has taken more of a stand on the having a job issue than Pratigya, so yes, maybe Arushi is doing a better job on that front. However, I completely disagree with point no. 3 where you said that Prats unnecessarily stopped Arushi's wedding without proof. I do not think that if you try to save your sister from a someone's trap, it should be considered 'interfering in her personal life'. A sister has enough rights to do that. If you're going to jump in a well, shouldn't your family try to stop you? Pratigya acted in the best of intentions. Her sister mistook it and made bad decisions.

I do agree with some other points, it is a bit disappointing to see that Pratigya's positivity has not managed to change the thinking of anyone in the family except Krishna. Amma, Shakti etc, as still as evil as ever... And I don't foresee any positive changes in the near future.


👍🏼



babithaj thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
P got what she wanted.. she wanted Krishna to earn and be matured and a little education... she g\attained all tht thru Krishna... To change, ppl shud have tht wllingness first... and as u guys can see, no violence has been goin on in Tn after her entry... before Kriya's marriage , lots of injustice happening with them... So she has changed and still on the process.. she will attain... if she attains tht the show will end.. so I just say...some evil ppl will remain evil all their life. Nice things can only be taught... to follow or not follow is upto them...

Ok.. for a husband like Krishna, any woman can go to any extent for his love for her...P too underwent some stupidity in the name of rituals.. so what... her liberalism is still intact... Is there anything like Liberal woman cannot love and do things for the person she loves...???

Arushi is always stood tall for her selfish and immature behavior... whereas P is a girl who always thinks good for ppl around her, even they be evil to her... This is what P is ... and she has been a great example for independent woman , always... Not act and then think type like Arushi...
if we can argue, we can dragg all unnecessary things.. but don't want to ...

Ok, while talking abt liberlism, why u dragged making husband happy??? K is really happy to hv her as his wife.. he is even Proud and feel pride abt P, his wife... P is the one true soul with k and she will always be there for him, come wht may...
Is Tanmey happy with Arushi????😕😕😕😕😆😆😆
ssrbaqri thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Anondo.R

What exactly you wanna say? You want to see Arushi as the lead? 😆


Bro, how can I expect Arushi to play the lead when the show is already titled 'pratigya' n there is no scope for anyone else. I only want to see Pratigya setting a better example for others to follow.
telstra thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
for me a strong women is this
643898 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
the only change i am seeing in prats is that she has stopped her useless bhashans😆 but other than that she is the same boring and dumb woman who we saw since the beginning of the show 🥱 and i disagree that arushi is stronger cos she is also a sucksena and sucksenas are very famous for both their nonsense acting and characters 😆
Edited by adib40 - 13 years ago
Anondo.R thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: ssrbaqri


Bro, how can I expect Arushi to play the lead when the show is already titled 'pratigya' n there is no scope for anyone else. I only want to see Pratigya setting a better example for others to follow.

Much better 👍🏼

ssrbaqri thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: telstra

for me a strong women is this


Beautiful pic, naz. And powerful lines. 👏
corvette thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: ssrbaqri

Hi frndz,
The common perception is that Pratz is a strong lady who never yields to injustice. This makes some people to view her as a role model. But sadly I hv drawn an altogether different conclusion from the show. Sample this:
1. When Krishna asked her not to work in the office so as to earn money, she simply surrendered and did not even protest. In comparison, when Tanmay forced Arushi to abandon job, she refused to give in to his unjust demand. Here, Arushi emerges as the leading lady and a better icon of women liberalism.
2. Pratz has been staying at TN for past 5 years and has seen thakurs commmitting all sort of crimes. Although she protested against such practices on certain occasions but she has never been able to secure justice being delivered to her criminal in-laws. In terms of output, she has been a huge failure.
3. Despite having so many troubles in her own life, she has constantly been intruding into others' territories. Like she interfered in Arushi's personal life by stopping her marriage to Aman. Infact, it was this foolishly handled move that ended up in Arushi marrying KN. Arushi was justified in turning hostile b'coz Pratz failed to produce any conclusive proof of Aman's cheating, in time.
4. As a wife, she has been unsuccessful in giving quality time to her hubby. I wud never recommend any wife to follow in her footsteps.
All this only proves that Pratz is not behaving as one wud expect from a lead of women-centric show.


only 1 like? I wonder why...

perhaps because the majority watch the show for a degree of entertainment (granted it may not always be 100%)

perhaps because unlike your belief (in itself offensive) we dont look to a fictional character, made for entertainment, a puppet of TRPs and whatever CVs personal goals are, as a role model

All this coming from a male, a male who is making recommendations to other mainly women, as to what constitutes female liberalism and a so called strong woman

Give me a fecking break!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".