HANDLING THE HYPOCRISY? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

2.1k

Users

18

Likes

90

Frequent Posters

Veena.S thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Kabe

Good post.
But aftr readng the post, 1 quest i got, wil ths apply to KST also for hiding meera truth from prats

well applies, meera went to much xtent, she tattood his name also, krish said lot of lies in hidin abt meera, no wife can't bear it if she knows tat other girl lovin her hubby, Watever Krish did is he can't see pratz in pain, n watever pratz did is she knows he can't handle it, to protect him frm society n her Jungly inlaws... Morethan pratz revealin truth, here in tis case krish knowin himself would b the best, i think tats wat goin 2 happen... Watever they both did in love, they can't see eachother in pain... Sorroundin situations also lead them to hide the things... we can't name it as Hypocrisy, my POV...
Edited by Veena.S - 13 years ago
Bruce_L thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Veena.S

well applies, meera went to much xtent, she tattood his name also, krish said lot of lies in hidin abt meera, no wife can't bear it if she knows tat other girl lovin her hubby, Watever Krish did is he can't see pratz in pain, n watever pratz did is she knows he can't handle it, to protect him frm society n her Jungly inlaws... Morethan pratz revealin truth, here in tis case krish knowin himself would b the best, i think tats wat goin 2 happen... Watever they both did in love, they can't see eachother in pain... Sorroundin situations also lead them to hide the things... we can't name it as Hypocrisy, my POV...

well said
Caped_Crusader thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#23
Hypocrite...I Think No One(KriYa) Is Hypocrite Here...They're Just Luv Birds...
643898 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: telstra

if prats a hypocrit then krishna too a hypocrat remember he too devoid prats knowing the most important truth about him leaving home in middle of nioght and its a basic right of wifey to know what her hubby upo.

i agree its not a personal truth of prats but still important
for me the central idea of all this both krishna and pratigya r ukps and idiots no one can b blamed😃
mine pov krishna was a liar and hyprocite since beginning of the show so him hiding the truth is nothing new but this post is abt mahan devi pratigyaji not him😉 and krishna can never be compared with prats as they have completely different idealogies

643898 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: babithaj

I know, i'll be the different one here...😲But its just my view for her sacrifice... some of u can call it hypocrisy...😛

What P did n doing is not Hypocrisy... P's sacrifice will make K react Matured n he'll do his part to rectify it... [goin 4 treatment]
P cannot be a selfish lover... telling those TN ppl tht she is not the one with problem... but their son.. by doing this, she will hurt K... [If she does also, ppl will blame her for saath dena n hurting her hubby without a heart,for being so selfish with her principle]some of u can say.. if he knows the truth later , tht he ws the actual one with the problem will hurt him MORE... but NO, he will deal with it correctly... This will help him.. he has already made his mind tht he n P alone together is enough...So he is now ready to accept the truth...but P will not step back n say tht she sacrificed and all.. like what Adarsh did... Adarsh is a selfish hypocrite, i agree... but P is not...Even K wud've reacted the same way... if it was him who knows abt the results if it was P being problematic... But then he is K, and here all will support him n justify his actions...Its not new..🥱

krishna is justified cos no one expects MAHAN acts from him but prats lying and hiding sth is never expected as she is the symbol of truth
-Sheena- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: babithaj

I know, i'll be the different one here...😲But its just my view for her sacrifice... some of u can call it hypocrisy...😛

What P did n doing is not Hypocrisy... P's sacrifice will make K react Matured n he'll do his part to rectify it... [goin 4 treatment]
P cannot be a selfish lover... telling those TN ppl tht she is not the one with problem... but their son.. by doing this, she will hurt K... [If she does also, ppl will blame her for saath dena n hurting her hubby without a heart,for being so selfish with her principle]some of u can say.. if he knows the truth later , tht he ws the actual one with the problem will hurt him MORE... but NO, he will deal with it correctly... This will help him.. he has already made his mind tht he n P alone together is enough...So he is now ready to accept the truth...but P will not step back n say tht she sacrificed and all.. like what Adarsh did... Adarsh is a selfish hypocrite, i agree... but P is not...Even K wud've reacted the same way... if it was him who knows abt the results if it was P being problematic... But then he is K, and here all will support him n justify his actions...Its not new..🥱





Meaning that if K would have hidden the truth then he would be accused of P having the right to know and that he is lying to P..Would you understand as to why he would hide it or would he be accused of lying and P will be hurt by the lie?

P character is based on truth so her hiding is not in accordance to her character per say..
-Sheena- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Meaningful

though P's lecture is very valid and true, I found it very bookish without any empathy towards komal's feelings and agony. Why can't prats use her soft side for once while delivering her pbj lecture. It is just like a divorce lawyer talking to her clients.



It is a directorial error and PG struggles at times in delivering such scenes which makes it look bookish.
Edited by starlight123 - 13 years ago
corvette thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#28
though P's lecture is very valid and true, I found it very bookish without any empathy towards komal's feelings and agony. Why can't prats use her soft side for once while delivering her pbj lecture. It is just like a divorce lawyer talking to her clients.[/QUOTE]

I didnt!!😆
corvette thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: MERARAI

MKAP writers have creative licenses to spin this story any which way ...and unrealistically at best.
While trying to educate the masses in India let's hope they aren't sending mixed signals to the very same audience who may find themselves in a similar situation.

Adarsh's actions are underhanded and cowardly in the way he's handled the matter. Komal appears dense in not noticing that for a man who's been away for 3 years he is not only being aloof from her but hasn't shown an ounce of affection to his daughter but slapped her instead. No one in the Sax family sees something is amiss and it's business as usual at GH. The only other person who smelled a rat in their midst was Tam, who had an agenda of his own and is playing it to his advantage for now.😛

My POV is that while she herself is harboring a secret ...whatever her motives and intentions...however honorable or self-sacrificing, protective of K being her justifications... it's hypocritical of her to take Adarsh to task and lecture him with her PBJ when she hasn't fessed her truth yet.🤪 It's the pot calling the kettle black. POPS let her get away with learning a few lessons she's giving the rest of them.😛

Why did Prats rip up the divorce deed... Komal may want to go through with the divorce at some point down the road and take Adarsh for all he has in alimony and child support. 😆


if Prats believes her Krishna will fall apart if he finds out the truth about his deficiency, how does a postponement of telling him the truth to his face protect or save him from falling apart. The nature of the news is life-altering as it is. Does she think she's going to soften the blow by "sacrificing" and doing the pooja paat for his sake? It may seem like a sacrifice on the surface but the truth is she didn't trust him to tell him the truth and however loving a couple, secrets have a way of creating cracks in their marriage. It doesn't take much, any level of deception however small can add up to blow things apart over a period of time. Krishna fudged Meera's story to Prats and now she's hiding the results of the reports. 😛LOVE ALL! or is it Duece? Score even.


🤔

didn't think it was the remit of any tv program to educate - influence maybe, but not educate - its a tall order that...

sure, every couple goes through problems, individuals make mistakes, but no one's perfect!

love is not just a glue but a tremendous rectifier too - and if there's love there has to be faith
I see your point of view here Mera as a little too black and white - great in court when one is neutral not so great if you're one of the parties involved

Its not about point scoring either - its about saying i goofed and learning from it, growing from it.

Out of the three trust probably is the less sturdier than love and faith, granted. But 2 against 1 is still better odds in favour of salvaging rather than writing off.

Neither P or K's intentions were mala fides - they have just made the wrong move - well intentioned - but wrong choice/option

Its only been what 5 years - there's loads of time and room for growth!!!!! Whether SP will give the time that's necessary is another matter!!😆
Just my POV - no offence intended!😃

babithaj thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Veena.S

well applies, meera went to much xtent, she tattood his name also, krish said lot of lies in hidin abt meera, no wife can't bear it if she knows tat other girl lovin her hubby, Watever Krish did is he can't see pratz in pain, n watever pratz did is she knows he can't handle it, to protect him frm society n her Jungly inlaws... Morethan pratz revealin truth, here in tis case krish knowin himself would b the best, i think tats wat goin 2 happen... Watever they both did in love, they can't see eachother in pain... Sorroundin situations also lead them to hide the things... we can't name it as Hypocrisy, my POV...

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".