Mahindra-Julie Analysis

-De.De- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
I was re-watching Mahindra-Julie scene and I paid attn. to dialogues alot more this this and to me they seem to be just 2 people who understand each other. I think Mahindra goes to Julie because she's somewhat like him or been through in situations like him so he feels easy to pour out his heart in front of her and vice versa.

OMG.. one thing I've to sir Atul sir... please whoever wrote the dialogues..that person is simply amazing. (Sorry,don't know the name.😳) One thing is realyl strong in Powder which makes each episode worth it is Dialogues!!😃 I simply LOVE the dialogue: "Pagal ho tum shehar ki sharkein namte ho."👏👏 One of the amazing dialogues.👏 Its like printed in my mind now.😳

I think I've began to understand Mahindra-Julie slightly now, last night I didn't thought from that through because I think being MahiDa fan it was slightly a shock for me.😳😆 But as I've seen now I think Mahindra-Julie are just 2 people with in no specific named relation. They simply understand and know each other for who they are. As so far I haven't seen any other friend of Mahindra than Kartik & Julie. There are times where your closet friends also fail to understand you (Kartik) then a person comes who can completely feel your situation as they've been through the same at some point in there life. Maybe that is it what binds Mahindra-Julie apart from the Raghav link.

Being Raghav in jail somehow Mahindra feels Julie is his responsibility aswell plus she's the only person in front of whom he can pour his heart out/cry/laugh be the REAL him.😳😳

So.... this is what I think of Julie-Mahindra's relation.😳 Hope, I'm half-way correct.😉😳

Btw Deb - Mahindra-Julie are not living together!

Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

3.5k

Users

10

Likes

40

Frequent Posters

sehar mehrotra thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
Hey Ika .......its like u r reading my mind...............i was juz going to open a similar topic...........😳😉
yaar i really dun understand wats goin on b/w mahi n julie..........though i agree ki julie is mahendra's only friend besides karthik n bcoz raghav is in jail mahendra is taking care of her.....................but yaar........he also said....."tum mere jaisi ho isi liye tere saath rhne ko dil krta hai"...........😲
dat line took d whole situation to a vry diff angle...............romantic one i guess..............
jo bhi ho...............i really want mahendra nbrinda to be together at the end!!!!!!😳
-De.De- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: sehar mehrotra

Hey Ika .......its like u r reading my mind...............i was juz going to open a similar topic...........😳😉

yaar i really dun understand wats goin on b/w mahi n julie..........though i agree ki julie is mahendra's only friend besides karthik n bcoz raghav is in jail mahendra is taking care of her.....................but yaar........he also said....."tum mere jaisi ho isi liye tere saath rhne ko dil krta hai"...........😲
dat line took d whole situation to a vry diff angle...............romantic one i guess..............
jo bhi ho...............i really want mahendra nbrinda to be together at the end!!!!!!😳


Sehar hun.. he said "Shayad hum dono pagal hain esi liye baat kar pata hon tujhse, milne ko dil karta hai." That's what he said, like I said I piad really good attn. to dialogues this time.😳
And this dialogue makes me think the analysis I did is somewhat right.😳 (Hopefully). Even if he has something for her, one thing we all know that Maahindra-Julie wouldn't end up together as he said "Hume konsa shaadi karni hai". And we can't also forget the Raghav sequence.

mishti_17 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Ika a nice topic...😃
Coming to it that scene was sooo depressing🥺 , I didn't wanna remember it again but kya karein cudnt do it, n weren't we expected to react badly, I mean 3 weeks widout Mahida😭😭 n then such a depressing scene😒, it was a super torture(now don ask me from where that came😆).U have defined their relationship quite well👍🏼, Its nothing, Its just 2 human beings sharing their joys n sorrows😊.Mahi feels its his responsiblity to look after Julie since Raghav is in jail...I have a stroong feeling that Julie is Raghavs n Mahi knows it, not saying this coz Im a diehard MahiDaian but coz i know its gonna be that way...
@Sehar
Dear at the end me too want it to be Mahida only..😍
Pooj@ thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
Thanks for d analysis... will hv 2 rewatch the scene now!
-De.De- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: -Kalindi-

Ika a nice topic...😃
Coming to it that scene was sooo depressing🥺 , I didn't wanna remember it again but kya karein cudnt do it, n weren't we expected to react badly, I mean 3 weeks widout Mahida😭😭 n then such a depressing scene😒, it was a super torture(now don ask me from where that came😆).U have defined their relationship quite well👍🏼, Its nothing, Its just 2 human beings sharing their joys n sorrows😊.Mahi feels its his responsiblity to look after Julie since Raghav is in jail...I have a stroong feeling that Julie is Raghavs n Mahi knows it, not saying this coz Im a diehard MahiDaian but coz i know its gonna be that way...
@Sehar
Dear at the end me too want it to be Mahida only..😍


I know when I saw first time I felt like being stabbed.😳😔 I never expected this but then again was in too shock.
Yes this is 3rd week without MahiDa😭😭 but great news as next week MahiDa.😃
Now coming back to Julie-Mahindra scene as they say there are always 2 sides of coin and being a hardcore MahiDa fan this scene first killed me.
As I watched again then it clicked me, it all is quite simple and there. It clicked me that why these two are together (wihle Raghav remaining mystery). And the dialogues were just too awesome in this scene.👍🏼 I listened to dialogues very carefully and then understood the meanings.😳

I can't say I'm 100% correct as alot still mystery but seeing it to certian extent I felt what I wrote in this analysis. Easy to put this way: they are walking together but still they are not together! I hope that is clear.😳 Still if there's feeling in one of them's heart, they still know they wouldn't be together, so they are just walking together with each other until the turn comes. It's not necassary that what you see is truth, not always.
Edited by Day_Dreamer - 15 years ago
-De.De- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Pooj@

Thanks for d analysis... will hv 2 rewatch the scene now!


Gosh you are always late to watch such scenes!😆 go and watch. And when he said wife thing he said "yeh jagde miya-biwi karte hain, humein konsa shaadi karni hai"😳
snoopdoggy thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Day_Dreamer


<font color="#0099ff" face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif">Sehar hun.. he said "Shayad hum dono pagal hain esi liye baat kar pata hon tujhse, milne ko dil karta hai." That's what he said, like I said I piad really good attn. to dialogues this time.😳
And this dialogue makes me think the analysis I did is somewhat right.😳 (Hopefully). Even if he has something for her, one thing we all know that Maahindra-Julie wouldn't end up together as he said "Hume konsa shaadi karni hai". And we can't also forget the Raghav sequence.</font>




hello everybody
what are u talking about...remember how did that scene start...julie sitting near the window in her shorts and top like her house clothes and mahi was not wearing his shirt as if he is used to something like this in her house, like they spend close time together..u know...humein kaunsi shaadi karni hai meaning that it is just a temporary thing and they both understand this...Julie ultimately belongs to Raghav(remember selva said to mahi in a bar, iss aurat ko chhodh de raghav ki khaas hai). but he is in a jail, julie gives tips to mahi and in return mahi makes sure raghav is fine in the jail....but in between since mahi is kinda like her coz she listens to him and may be attracted to her, gets close to her and julie doesnt have a say here coz her boyfriend is in the jail and she also may be likes mahi...i mean it was quite clear that they share a physical relationship...before mahi says bye to julie he goes close to julie to kiss her but she turns her face coz they have an argument on money before that....so..u get it...

-De.De- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: snoopdoggy



hello everybody
what are u talking about...remember how did that scene start...julie sitting near the window in her shorts and top like her house clothes and mahi was not wearing his shirt as if he is used to something like this in her house, like they spend close time together..u know...humein kaunsi shaadi karni hai meaning that it is just a temporary thing and they both understand this...Julie ultimately belongs to Raghav(remember selva said to mahi in a bar, iss aurat ko chhodh de raghav ki khaas hai). but he is in a jail, julie gives tips to mahi and in return mahi makes sure raghav is fine in the jail....but in between since mahi is kinda like her coz she listens to him and may be attracted to her, gets close to her and julie doesnt have a say here coz her boyfriend is in the jail and she also may be likes mahi...i mean it was quite clear that they share a physical relationship...before mahi says bye to julie he goes close to julie to kiss her but she turns her face coz they have an argument on money before that....so..u get it...


Hi Sonal.. good to see your feedback. Sonal, I didn't also said my analysis is 110% accurate, I only wrote what I felt. What you are saying could be possible, they might've physical relation too. But I don't know why but I think this is not the case. Because the way you put it, it seems like Mahindra is taking advantage of Julie's condition and I don't think he can sink this low.

And IF Julie likes Mahindra and knows Mahindra likes her (obvious to her), then why is she so worried somuch about Raghav?! Why she's giving tips to Mahindra because to see Raghav fine in jail? It shows she does only love Raghav. And for Mahindra, she cares and like I said before both understand each other.

And Mahindra must be used to her house and she too maybe that's why both were really comfy with each other's presence (Ie. like Mahindra not wearing shirt).

I'm also saying there are 2 views/sides of each thing. What you are saying can be correct or maybe what I'm saying is correct. Or simply both of our views are right. *sighs* I guess we've to wait for future episodes to see what happens.

Take care...
Edited by Day_Dreamer - 15 years ago
sehar mehrotra thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Day_Dreamer


Sehar hun.. he said "Shayad hum dono pagal hain esi liye baat kar pata hon tujhse, milne ko dil karta hai." That's what he said, like I said I piad really good attn. to dialogues this time.😳
And this dialogue makes me think the analysis I did is somewhat right.😳 (Hopefully). Even if he has something for her, one thing we all know that Maahindra-Julie wouldn't end up together as he said "Hume konsa shaadi karni hai". And we can't also forget the Raghav sequence.

hmmmmmmmmmmmmm i think ur observation is ryt.....................i truly hope its ryt n theres nthin goin on b/w mahendra n julie!!!!!😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".