imbalanced comments n marks :( - Page 4

Originally posted by: karneetholic

isha really made me cry 2day but i have 2 b honest as a neutral viewer...

first of all rashmi got a comment dat her dance was restricted...but wasnt gurmeets dance limited 2 tandav??? wasnt ritwiks dance limited to laser n wasnt ishas dance limited 2 rope?????

then y sum 1 gets 25 n some1 gets 30????

then gurmeet was told he was doing stunts only...wasnt isha doin gymnastics almost 90%????

ritwiks got 27 without ne major fault ..among 4 he has danced da most...even more dan ishas dancing part .its a shame dat he got 27 wid rashmi who had far less dance..:O

i dnt think ne dance was worth 30 ..isha ritwik were lyk worth 28 29 BUT not 30...md said dere wasnt sympathy but deres no way dat isha wud have got 30 wid less dancing n more gymnastics..

judges dont have ne balance in deir scoring.. i kno isha was brave n deserved standing ovation but not 30 for her less dancing

u have to agree irrespective of ur favourites...i ve mine favourite 2 but 2days marks were highly imbalanced!!

Yeah, totally agree...Judges told GC that in his performance there were less movements...But I feel Isha also given less dance movements...Of course, with rope she did great moves, but as we all know its not dance moves...And Being a good trainer in arial/rope act, with one hand act is not much stressful I feel...
But in one episode GC and Shampa had done act with both hands tied...In Badman act...Shampa executed well, there were much dance movements in that act...Both did very well with both hands tied...

GC again he did not perform his best in his act...But his expression is perfect...In Dance, everything will be counted with dance as u all know expression, timing etc...
And after the Isha's act Madhuri Ma'm told that they r giving marks for their dance not for sympathy and all...If they r seeing the Isha's dance point of view, her act duration is less, dance movements r less...30 marks more for her act I feel...

And Rashmi and Ritwik their act was also perfect...they also should get perfect 30 if Isha got for the same Arial/aerobic acts...

I like Ritwik's energetic dances, Rashmi's graceful dances, Gurmeet's different style dances...I feel He was the one who tried more forms like Pulikal kerala dance form, Katakali, Bharatham, robotic, Rumba, Zouk,paso souble.
Isha also shown variety...but most of the time I have seen her aerobic/ Arial kinds of dances...

Judges are showing so much partiality...