imbalanced comments n marks :(

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

lg001

@lg001

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#11

agreed...
their marks & comments r imbalance...

Quote

Lola

@Lola13

Voyager

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#12

watched for the first time a full epi of JDJ (because of rani.. :p).. otherwise I just watched the performances..

from what I have understand.. Remo said to GC.. he didn't dance.. it was a great act,stunts and everything.. but didn't dance.. madhuri and KJO.. same..

now comes Isha.. who in my opinion didn't dance at all... just flew around.. acrobatics (for me it comes in the same category as stunts)... but jury says she danced great..

I was like *WHATTT ? o_O*

when all the pairs danced.. in my opinion..Rithvik was the best.. !! he deserved the 10... not Isha.. !

if I think like this in just watching one episode... thank god I didn't watch the other episodes.. 😆

from today's episode.. I think Rithvik is the deserving winner.. ! 😊

Edited by Lola13 - 13 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

karneetholic

@karneetholic

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#13

im not doing ne isha vs gurmeet... i ve a prob wid marks n remarks of ALL 2 b clear...

Me_Anonymous:: y do u think gymnastic is a degradatory term????it is not..how can sports be diff from stunt in a dance

Quote

Me_Anonymous

@Me_Anonymous

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: karneetholic
im not doing ne isha vs gurmeet... i ve a prob wid marks n remarks of ALL 2 b clear...

Me_Anonymous:: y do u think gymnastic is a degradatory term????it is not..how can sports be diff from stunt in a dance

I do NOT think it is a derogatory term. It's how people use it (on this forum) that I have a problem with. It demeans all those professional Gymnasts who put so much effort and work in their profession.

For example members say and imply: Isha should go and join a circus or do Gymnastics. It's like if everything else fails try these 2 professions. To me that sounds demeaning and disrespctful toward these professions. Others might not see it that way, I do and still stand by it.

If people said normally then I would not say anything. Btw, what Isha does is not gymnastics or not the type of gymnastics I have seen and know of.

Quote

Operaqueen

@Operaqueen

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#15

Yes, if isha had done gurmeets act, she would have definitely scored 30, I thought gurmeets act was very impressive. How about having isha do a a classical Indian dance? I am sure she would suck at it.

Quote

Tich

@Jin.

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#16

Agree with you...isha's act was to be least scored.. but favoritism continues..

rithvik and rashmi scored 30 on 30 when isha wasnt there.. but as soon as isha came back judges started their unreasonable comments to decrease their marks and overrate isha.. she did deserve standing ovation for her bravery but the act wasnt anything compared to others.. if isha got 30 then all the other three should get 30 too.. they were spectacular today..

Quote

karneetholic

@karneetholic

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: Me_Anonymous

I do NOT think it is a derogatory term. It's how people use it (on this forum) that I have a problem with. It demeans all those professional Gymnasts who put so much effort and work in their profession.

For example members say and imply: Isha should go and join a circus or do Gymnastics. It's like if everything else fails try these 2 professions. To me that sounds demeaning and disrespctful toward these professions. Others might not see it that way, I do and still stand by it.

If people said normally then I would not say anything. Btw, what Isha does is not gymnastics or not the type of gymnastics I have seen and know of.

i wasnt making fun of it...
but i dnt take dis as nething diff from ne other stunt n stunt is not a dance that i kno very well too

btw wat i thot to b offensive was ishas comment when she said i dnt wanna perform lyk a handicapped ..i think she didnt mean it but sounded very wrong...

Quote

karneetholic

@karneetholic

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: AquaNymph
Agree with you...isha's act was to be least scored.. but favoritism continues..
rithvik and rashmi scored 30 on 30 when isha wasnt there.. but as soon as isha came back judges started their unreasonable comments to decrease their marks and overrate isha.. she did deserve standing ovation for her bravery but the act wasnt anything compared to others.. if isha got 30 then all the other three should get 30 too.. they were spectacular today..

true except da part dat isha was 2 b scored least ..i think she n rashmi was lyk worthy of 28 n ritwik 29

Quote

Phosphorus

@Novarieaa

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: AquaNymph
Agree with you...isha's act was to be least scored.. but favoritism continues..
rithvik and rashmi scored 30 on 30 when isha wasnt there.. but as soon as isha came back judges started their unreasonable comments to decrease their marks and overrate isha.. she did deserve standing ovation for her bravery but the act wasnt anything compared to others.. if isha got 30 then all the other three should get 30 too.. they were spectacular today..

I would beg to differ on the bold part. When Isha was not performing , Rashmi did a classical performance in breathless round and that was FAB. That was a performance worthy of 30. Do you really think, what she did today, deserved perfect 30?! Agreed that was an innovative and hatke act but the dance moves were VERY restricted . 27 was an apt score for that performance.

I don't really remember what Rithvik performed when he got 30 so not mentioning him.

So your statement in bold is uncalled for.

Edited by ThatOneGal - 13 years ago

Quote

Tich

@Jin.

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#20

Originally posted by: ThatOneGal
I would beg to differ on the bold part. When Isha was not performing , Rashmi did a classical performance in breathless round and that was FAB. That was a performance worthy of 30. Do you really think, what she did today, deserved perfect 30?! Agreed that was an innovative and hatke act but the dance moves were VERY restricted . 27 was an apt score for that performance.
I don't really remember what Rithvik performed when he got 30 so not mentioning him.

So your statement in bold is uncalled for.

rashmi's performance may not be worth of 30 but 27 could be given to her. Gurmeet's score was least and told that there were only stunts. But even Isha's act has less dancing. And what about Rithvik? he was perfect today. Yet judges chose to underrate him. I have nothing against isha, but i'm against partiality and favoritism here. And this happens in every season of jhalak. Last season it was Sushant and this time it's Rithvik.

Quote

1 2 3 4

Bala

imbalanced comments n marks :( - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics