imbalanced comments n marks :( - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

30

Views

3.8k

Users

21

Likes

114

Frequent Posters

Me_Anonymous thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: karneetholic



i wasnt making fun of it...
but i dnt take dis as nething diff from ne other stunt n stunt is not a dance that i kno very well too

btw wat i thot to b offensive was ishas comment when she said i dnt wanna perform lyk a handicapped ..i think she didnt mean it but sounded very wrong...



I didn't say you were. That's why I wrote in the brackets that people on this forum use gymnastics in a derogatory way and that I hate.

On a general note (not referring to Isha or Gurmeet or any other contestants performances on JDJ5):

Stunts are performed in Professional Dancing Competitions. BUT they are not the only thing in the dance, the stunts make up about 1% of the actual performance. All the stretches and lifts come under 'tricks and shine' part of dance competitions. So stunts are performed but kept to bare minimum so not to minimise the actual dancing. Like I said, haven't watched Gurmeet's performance yet so can't comment if his only had stunts.

I heard that handicapped part too and it did strike me as odd. She should have been a lot more careful with her word choice. I haven't really watched that comlpete bit yet. I tend to skip the general-talk parts in episodes and only move to actual performances and then scores (sometimes don't even bother with Judges comments). So I don't know and can't comment on this anymore.

Edited by Me_Anonymous - 12 years ago
Novarieaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: AquaNymph


rashmi's performance may not be worth of 30 but 27 could be given to her. Gurmeet's score was least and told that there were only stunts. But even Isha's act has less dancing. And what about Rithvik? he was perfect today. Yet judges chose to underrate him. I have nothing against isha, but i'm against partiality and favoritism here. And this happens in every season of jhalak. Last season it was Sushant and this time it's Rithvik.

Sushant was a victim of favortisim?? When did that happen?? I wasn't a follower of last season. But from what i have read, juges also used VETO power for him to keep him in the competition !!
Yes, Rithvik had more dance in his performance than others but i guess Isha was flawless ( i haven't seen her act yet) that's why she got 30.
Edited by ThatOneGal - 12 years ago
gbhat thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#23
I totally agree. I did not see much dance from Rashmi but she managed to get 27 Ritwiks performance was more compared to any one. I feet the judgement is biased.
DrSonali thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
Today Gurmeet got 25 b'se they said there was less dance. But there was nothing new in Isha's act. We have seen it before. She definitely deserves standing oration for her spirit but dance wise nothing new for her n for us. Agree that she can not explore more with tied hands but she has not tried it even before.

She was not confident when she had danced for Bollywood pair dance.

Even Rashmi had not danced b'se of limitations but still it was less then how come she got 27? Its only for Gurmeet they give less marks. I hope he dances very well in finale as he danced today in second act. God plz Bless him.
nyxx thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#25
Its all scripted...their comments and points never coorelate!
Isha did not deserve that 30 or the 10. The other 3 did much better, and if they are really going by voting system..It should have been just Gurmeet, Rithvik and Rashmi in the top 3. The same rop act again and again?...youve got to be kidding me...I know Salman is super versatile and always tried different things with yana last season, this season, Isha cant do any bollywood...just her aerial acts, contemprary..and thats all...thats called restricted!! The other 3...I salute them for not going against the judges on being unfair and all the favourism to Isha...
Used to admire and love Isha, but I really dont care much for her.
and yeah if Rashmi got 27..Rithvik deserved much HIGHER than her!!
Edited by nyxx - 12 years ago
piya2025 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#26
I don't understand how judges gives marks most of the time n more than the marks I have problem with their comments..They are not up to the mark but Anyway although I have no problem with Isha (As she has been doing what she does the best,so many people comments on that from the beginning abhi what should I say in the last days) but Salman's expressions makes me laugh.Those " Oh god!yea kaise huya"😆Seriously aisa karna zarrori hai..🥱I kinda dislike his such drama (Well.yeah atleast thats how I feel,No offense intended to his fans,My POV only)

& if I have to pick one performance which had more dance along with rest of the stuff..I thought Ritvick was good,followed by Rashmi may be,Isha--It was great how she did what ever she did with the broken arm..GC-Well I never could connect myself with his act (most of them) but in today's performance his expression were nice n that's for sure.

PS-BTW No favorism intended,So kindly if anyone wants to taunt me with that,won't work :)
krutiv100 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Lola13

watched for the first time a full epi of JDJ (because of rani.. :p).. otherwise I just watched the performances..

from what I have understand.. Remo said to GC.. he didn't dance.. it was a great act,stunts and everything.. but didn't dance.. madhuri and KJO.. same..


now comes Isha.. who in my opinion didn't dance at all... just flew around.. acrobatics (for me it comes in the same category as stunts)... but jury says she danced great..

I was like *WHATTT ? o_O*

when all the pairs danced.. in my opinion..Rithvik was the best.. !! he deserved the 10... not Isha.. !

if I think like this in just watching one episode... thank god I didn't watch the other episodes.. 😆

from today's episode.. I think Rithvik is the deserving winner.. ! 😊




@bold I was shocked when Judges gave Rithvik 8 and Isha 10...Rithvik was robbed he was so much better and rightly deserved the 10. Isha should have got 8 or even 6 cos for the first time I felt that Gurmeet was really good and had great chemistry with the new choreographer.

@blue-I totaly agree...I'm rooting for Rithvik to win...👏

456521 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28
I really liked Gurmeet's performance today both solo and group. He deserved at least 27 for his solo performance. Judges do seem biased. Especially Remo seems too critical towards Gurmeet 😕 I admire Isha's courage and her beautiful performance but we have seen the aerial dance for nth time on JDJ.
Edited by saloni111 - 12 years ago
Jin. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: ThatOneGal

Sushant was a victim of favortisim?? When did that happen?? I wasn't a follower of last season. But from what i have read, juges also used VETO power for him to keep him in the competition !!

Yes, Rithvik had more dance in his performance than others but i guess Isha was flawless ( i haven't seen her act yet) that's why she got 30.

yes, sushant was a victim of favoritism.. jdj4 aired on sony and they favored chang to win as he was a sony boy.. sushant expressed his disappointment and vowed never to be there again.. that may be the reason why he didnt turn up this reason when mahi, chang, yan were there but sushant inspite of being first runner up didnt turn up.. btw how can u say isha's act was flawless when u havent watched it.. judges favor isha and never point out their mistakes like they did for behne de and salman's tujhe bhula diya acts.
vgiri thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30
Honestly.. I enjoyed Isha's dance..I really dont mind her getting 30 coz she has 0 points from saturday.. is the dance worth 30 points I dont know..
If she is given 30 for that performance then they should have given 30 for Rithvik too..yeah he has score advantage from Saturday but his Sunday dance was equally or better than Isha's. You cannot give scores based on sympathy.
Rashmi.. yes her dance was restricted.. that's an awesome dance song, if she had done it by herself she would have nailed it..I liked the concept but she cannot take chance at this point.
Same goes to Rithvik..I just love his expressions and moves.. but the Laser distracted the focus.
Gurmeet..sry.. I am not a big fav. of his dance, dont want to comment on that..He has HUGE fan base..
Can we have Rithvik in Top 3.. that is ALLL I want..⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".