imbalanced comments n marks :(

isha really made me cry 2day but i have 2 b honest as a neutral viewer...

first of all rashmi got a comment dat her dance was restricted...but wasnt gurmeets dance limited 2 tandav??? wasnt ritwiks dance limited to laser n wasnt ishas dance limited 2 rope?????

then y sum 1 gets 25 n some1 gets 30????

then gurmeet was told he was doing stunts only...wasnt isha doin gymnastics almost 90%????

ritwiks got 27 without ne major fault ..among 4 he has danced da most...even more dan ishas dancing part .its a shame dat he got 27 wid rashmi who had far less dance..:O

i dnt think ne dance was worth 30 ..isha ritwik were lyk worth 28 29 BUT not 30...md said dere wasnt sympathy but deres no way dat isha wud have got 30 wid less dancing n more gymnastics..

judges dont have ne balance in deir scoring.. i kno isha was brave n deserved standing ovation but not 30 for her less dancing

u have to agree irrespective of ur favourites...i ve mine favourite 2 but 2days marks were highly imbalanced!!

Agreed but this is not d first time in jdj, i'm toh now used to it.

Agree! Isha did deserve standing ovation for bravery but 30 aise hi makes no sense for same old act of rope she did so far 3/4 of the time in Jhalak.

(this opinion of dance & points r related to that only not to ishas accidnt)

Originally posted by: karneetholic

isha really made me cry 2day but i have 2 b honest as a neutral viewer...

first of all rashmi got a comment dat her dance was restricted...but wasnt gurmeets dance limited 2 tandav??? wasnt ritwiks dance limited to laser n wasnt ishas dance limited 2 rope?????

then y sum 1 gets 25 n some1 gets 30????

then gurmeet was told he was doing stunts only...wasnt isha doin gymnastics almost 90%????

ritwiks got 27 without ne major fault ..among 4 he has danced da most...even more dan ishas dancing part .its a shame dat he got 27 wid rashmi who had far less dance..:O

i dnt think ne dance was worth 30 ..isha ritwik were lyk worth 28 29 BUT not 30...md said dere wasnt sympathy but deres no way dat isha wud have got 30 wid less dancing n more gymnastics..

judges dont have ne balance in deir scoring.. i kno isha was brave n deserved standing ovation but not 30 for her less dancing

u have to agree irrespective of ur favourites...i ve mine favourite 2 but 2days marks were highly imbalanced!!

I'm not happy with the group dance scoring at all...Gurmeet was the best of them all.

Originally posted by: adigaag

I'm not happy with the group dance scoring at all...Gurmeet was the best of them all.

\

Originally posted by: karneetholic

isha really made me cry 2day but i have 2 b honest as a neutral viewer...

first of all rashmi got a comment dat her dance was restricted...but wasnt gurmeets dance limited 2 tandav??? wasnt ritwiks dance limited to laser n wasnt ishas dance limited 2 rope?????

then y sum 1 gets 25 n some1 gets 30????

then gurmeet was told he was doing stunts only...wasnt isha doin gymnastics almost 90%????

ritwiks got 27 without ne major fault ..among 4 he has danced da most...even more dan ishas dancing part .its a shame dat he got 27 wid rashmi who had far less dance..:O

i dnt think ne dance was worth 30 ..isha ritwik were lyk worth 28 29 BUT not 30...md said dere wasnt sympathy but deres no way dat isha wud have got 30 wid less dancing n more gymnastics..

judges dont have ne balance in deir scoring.. i kno isha was brave n deserved standing ovation but not 30 for her less dancing

u have to agree irrespective of ur favourites...i ve mine favourite 2 but 2days marks were highly imbalanced!!

I completely Agree with u ..

😳

Originally posted by: kahkashansakina

I completely Agree with u ..

judges ko GC se problem hai ...

kal bharti ne jo kaha tha woh bohut jala hai madhuri ko. aisliye Aaj bola madhuri ne sympathies kae bina par marks nahi mila hai dance ki wajhe se mila...par madhur ji dance tha kaha...

GC - Less dance and more stunts...so less mark

Reshmi - restricted dance...so less mark

ritwick - gimmicks with laser...less dance..less mark

isha- pure dance dance and dance only...no sympathies nothing...full mark...

Originally posted by: karneetholic

...
then gurmeet was told he was doing stunts only...wasnt isha doin gymnastics almost 90%????

[this post is in reference to the "told" part of your post]

No Comments on any other thing except the highlighted part as I haven't yet seen all the performances, just bits and pieces.

Gurmeet's Dance form was TANDAV and Isha's was ROPE MALAKHAMB. Notice the DIFFERENCE here. I have recently found out Rope Malakhamb is a Sport in India so her "Gymnastics" (as majority here like to call it in a deragatory way🤢) was already GIVEN and expected considering the (dance) FORM she was performing while Gurmeet's is an ACTUAL DANCE FORM and it doesn't have the inclusion of too much props (I think).

I have seen TANDAV performances and they don't have "tricks" or ''gimmicks'' or ''stunts'' in them. I am not a Hindu but I understand the whole concept of Tandav and why or when it was performed. It was PURE DANCE as far as I know so involving ''tricks'' seems a bit to me. Tandav has a religious background. I don't know how majority here percieve it as but I'd prefer if people STICK to the ORIGINALs if something has a religious/cultural/traditional background to it.

Btw, for those who like to compare performances, please check out Jayati's Tandav performance. It didn't have any gimmicks in it and it was still very EFFECTIVE in getting the anger and all such emotions across.

I'll save my views/comments on RD/Rashmi/Isha/Gurmeet's performances till I have actually seen all of them and only then will decide if it had a lot of 'stunts' in it.

Let me reiterate the point of my post here. It is in direct reference to ONLY the "told" [by the judges I presume] part of the TM's post anything else anyone 'reads' it as, do so at your own risk but don't expect a reply😊.