What was most unfair on jdj

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

@TheRowdiest

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 13 years ago

#41

@ TM- u didn't include GC dear in ur list

Keeping GC in the show when he never danced 😉

Quote

Rati Gupta

@RatiG

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: Operaqueen
You said it yourself, she is a trained dancer in RoleMalkamb, so then to be fair why is she not doing other dance forms, why is it that we get to see a lot of aerial acrobatic acts from her most of the time? I don't think she deserves to win, because she came in with a lot of experience and expertise compared to other contestants. Period.
btw, I know you want to make a point but I equate the increased font size to screaming!

No i wasnt screaming😆

Isha do other forms also...havnt u seen..she did lots

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

karneetholic

@karneetholic

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#43

to me
1. isha s participance..she cud very well be judge
2.bharti being in top 5
3.isha getting direct entry to semis without performing 4 2 weeks.1 week cud have been understanble
4. bharti asking for second chance :O :O :O
5.gia inspite of good dance got less marks always
6.scorin isha 2 30s whereas she deserved 27-29..coz her xpression is not as gud as gia or rashmi
7.ritwik getting less da isha inspite of dancing more

Quote

Greeshma

@pulu1995

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

#44

It wud be unfair to say wild card contestants should not win.. Yes, the other ones have worked hard from the beginning but kya kare.. even these are very much talented. They should been there from the beginning.
And Isha direct entry was very very unfair and also keeping Bharti for TRP sake. What about all the other contestants who worked day-night to get into semi? If judges meant injury, Bharti also should have been given chance on a fair note. But I loved the wild card contestants as they are really good but wish they were from the beginning as the game would be fair then.
Shibani and Gia deserved more. Darsheel was a child artist, spectacular but .. and Isha has been brought up as a dancer and nothing else other than that in life. Anyone who is trained so much would perform like her.. Look at the kids in other show . ok no comparing but JDJ5 turned out -sad.

Quote

LilButterfly003

@LilButterfly003

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#45

Agree 100% for num 2!!!😉 n maybe 7...😕

Quote

LilButterfly003

@LilButterfly003

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#46

Originally posted by: shruti_ms

sure why not
last year when sushant was given a rest for a couple of weeks salman was so angry and he was very verbal with it
how come he has no problems now that his partner is being given a straight entry into semi finals
i dont see him angry now

Said it rite...when it has come 4 salman nw things r gr8 if isha has got veto...what a mentality!!!!!!big ''bravo'' 2 him👏👏👏

Edited by Bambi003 - 13 years ago

Quote

Greeshma

@pulu1995

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

#47

Also agree that some dint really deserve 30.. not comparing with uk version but the act has to be flawless from the basic point.. I still remember Ore piya sequence from jdj4... it has to be something like that. PERFECT!

Quote

LilButterfly003

@LilButterfly003

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#48

Originally posted by: sweetysumaiya

This is actually my first post.. I dont believe everyone at fault,.the whole concept of jdj is gone to tatters.. I love uk version of strictly,. No problems no drama...like jdj

The whole of jdj is wrong this year,,
And also judges todays episodes were rude...they cant see that some people like ritwick m gc work 12 hours aday...so. Obs they gna get mistakes... But some people are nt working.. So whats gc and rd doing in limited time is good,
Judges should only comment on dance what went well and even better if.. Not how votes should be or how people are being saved thats just rude...
Hence todays epi would b the worst

True...GC & RD r workim relly hard...i dont rely read 4 GC bt RD tweets n if they read(Madhuri is friend) mayb she'l get 2 knw!!!latest-how hectic hs day ws...even 4 GC yaar...they work n dance real dance n nt some sort of gymnastic which im fed up with!!!!!this is to dance n nt to dangle in the air!!!!!!
But such a biased show thers no point 2 make judges c the unfairness...ankhoon par pati bande hai-cant c anythng then...i find it unfair 4 RD,GC,Rasmi getim lower marks than isha who didnt evn dance compared to others...sorry bt my POV she shud b out n let others who deserve to b in the finale...my POV nthim else!!!!!

Quote

Mrinmayee

@Mrinmayee

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

#49

I agreed with u completely TM.

And I feel point no 2 is most unfair.

Something else also needed to improve the quality of JDJ like

1.They should give the detailed profile of each contestants.

2.The viewers should also know what all dance formats they are going to incorporate in the season.A brief description of each dance form.

3.All contestants should be made to perform all dance forms NOT like if someone is comforatble in one format then they will do the same repeatedly and get better scores.Its simply unfair and boring.

4.Will be better to have two technical judges for more clarity on dance forms and performers.

5.Wild card entries should be from the eliminated ones who performed from day one NOT randomly taking anyone after few weeks .

6.One dance form should NOT be repeated at all.

Quote

Aditi

@NxtRockstar..

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#50

I don't find a equilibrium with the fact that Isha is given 30 for this week's act. There are other acts of her too where she wasn't worthy of 30 acc to me. But let's talk about fresh one.

Another unfair deed was allowing her to be in show without even exposing to voting. She wasn't in condition to perform. I agree but her voting could be remain open for the week she wasn't performing. At least audience can give logic to their mind of her being in show due to voting.

Third unfair thing is "selection of WC from fresh lot instead of calling ht eliminated ones back.

I have only seen this season and I can say, it was a bad experience so no re-purchase of rigged show.